Thanks for the Response Terry. I have a ton of respect for you, your opinion and your contributions to the community.
I look at the CDG, Origin, Tenacity (classic) as a $900 action not a $1500 one. The difference there, and they are all great actions for the money is more like $5-600. That's more substantial. As the prices have creeped up, they are no longer the value they once were and it makes it harder to recommend them when for a little more you can get a full featured flagship.
I would still always recommend someone to buy the best action they can and make a sacrifice elsewhere, as they upgrade they will always have that action as the base of their build. We all change stocks, chassis, barrels, scopes, brakes, ect..... A good action will last forever. Surgeon is a great example. It gives up almost nothing to a modern action.
Even a pinned and torqued rail is a failure point. People dick around and user error is the most likely cause of issues. An integral rail removes that possibility. Its one less thing to check on my checklist in diagnosing a rifle issue.
I shoot almost exclusively shoot Tates actions and Wades barrels. Ton of respect to those guys. Doesn't mean I see the allure of this action or agree with others rationale on why they should buy it.
And yes, there are a ton of dumb mother fuckers out there.
The one thing I don't understand is the Lug area. It looks like a pinned/2 piece Lug action but its supposed to be integral. Why the machine cuts and the appearance of staking when its integral?