The short answer boils down to preference. I am a long time fan of the 7x57 and have several rifles chambered in such and plenty of brass, dies and factory ammo. I just like the Tikka and the 7x57, so having a Tikka or a Sako in 7x57 would be a win for me.
Sure, there really isn't any argument I can make to justify the 7x57 over the -08 as they are pretty much ballistic twins. It kinda mimics the 308 -06 debate with efficiency and heavy for caliber bullets.
The only reason I mentioned punching to AI was that the -08 is wider in some parts, so even though the 7x57 is longer, this is not as wide around the shoulder and body, so for a 7x57 to be reamed in, the barrel will need to be set back. The AI is just as wide as a -08 and should clean it up, just wanted a Smith to ring in before pursuit of such a project.
It is not that I am recoil shy, as I already have Tikka's in 7mag and -06, but to me the 7x57 and -08 are the prefect ratio of energy/recoil and this seems like something I could use til I am 90 (if I live that long)
In the end I may just go with a Tikka compact or stainless in -08 and call it done.