Knives seem to be very personal..
The user wants something very specific.
Likewise builders like to build with their ideal features in mind.
I like my knives to be pretty spartan, drop or working clip, a manageable size, pommel suitable for some light hammering, spine suitable for some battoning, 90 degree edges for striking a fire steel/fire starting.
The maker I was talking to had issues with some of my ideas, particularly the "hammering" of the pommel.
He took my ideas and came up with what would work with his skills/desires as a builder.
He came back with this....
My original sketch to compare...
If anything he added some bling to my spartan desires.
I liked it and we parted with an agreement if he built it Id buy it but than I never heard anymore so I kind of moved on. He builds really nice knives and I hope he is finding success. Who knows I may get contact one of these days stating "Hey your knife is done, pay me $X and Ill send it".
Just an interesting side note on how when it comes to knives the user/builder really have to be in unison on their ideas.