Suppressors Beating a dead horse, Ultra 9 vs Magnus

03CR

03CR

Private
Full Member
Minuteman
Feb 10, 2017
59
47
#1
Rifle is an AI AX primarily shooting .308 and 6.5 CM. Have even tossed around the idea of a 16” 300BO barrel strictly for subs just because. I think I’ve narrowed it down to the Ultra 9 and the Magnus.

I don’t own any magnums and currently have no plans to. I don’t shoot PRS so length isn’t a huge concern. This isn’t a hunting rig so weight isn’t really a consideration. I guess ultimately what I’m after is sound reduction. I know the Magnus meters better but is the decibel reduction over the Ultra 9 really that noticeable at the ear and worth the few hundred bucks extra? I don’t have a way to quantify how much say a 5db difference is.
 
#4
I have an original 30P-1 that I use the most. Not really sure if it's technically the predecessor to the ultra 9, but it's a great can and I think excellent sound reduction. Been shooting my Magnus more and more and love it as well.

You won't go wrong with either of those options. Choose which ever your finances determine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: John_in_WYO
#7
Is the Magnus slightly quieter, or is it a notable difference? I don’t have a way to hear them in person so I’d hate to spend quite a bit more for the Magnus if the sound reduction difference is minimal.
 
#8
1731596920285.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Series 70 Colt
#10
03CR said:
Rifle is an AI AX primarily shooting .308 and 6.5 CM. Have even tossed around the idea of a 16” 300BO barrel strictly for subs just because. I think I’ve narrowed it down to the Ultra 9 and the Magnus.

I don’t own any magnums and currently have no plans to. I don’t shoot PRS so length isn’t a huge concern. This isn’t a hunting rig so weight isn’t really a consideration. I guess ultimately what I’m after is sound reduction. I know the Magnus meters better but is the decibel reduction over the Ultra 9 really that noticeable at the ear and worth the few hundred bucks extra? I don’t have a way to quantify how much say a 5db difference is.
Click to expand...
Here’s my suggestions… If you want…

Maximum DB drop - Magnus

Portability, and plenty quiet enough - Magnus-S
 
#17
Neither. Since you seem to be price conscious, go with the Enticer LTi. Indistinguishable in performance from the Magnus, in a much more affordable package, that's also significantly lighter and smaller.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: FuhQ
#18
Dave said:
Neither. Since you seem to be price conscious, go with the Enticer LTi. Indistinguishable in performance from the Magnus, in a much more affordable package, that's also significantly lighter and smaller.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I don't think that's quite an accurate statement... It's kind of misleading, since a suppressor has many factors other than just DB numbers. While it's a good can that does well in the numbers department, I don't think it's on an equal playing field with the Magnus...Especially once you factor in TBAC's industry-leading runout and precision of the build and assembly.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Dave
#21
Dave said:
Neither. Since you seem to be price conscious, go with the Enticer LTi. Indistinguishable in performance from the Magnus, in a much more affordable package, that's also significantly lighter and smaller.
Click to expand...
FuhQ said:
Yeah, I don't think that's quite an accurate statement... It's kind of misleading, since a suppressor has many factors other than just DB numbers. While it's a good can that does well in the numbers department, I don't think it's on an equal playing field with the Magnus...Especially once you factor in TBAC's industry-leading runout and precision of the build and assembly.
Click to expand...
I own 3 TBACs including a Magnus and a DDC Enticer S TI. I love my Magnus but Dave is right. The only thing that the Magnus would have over the Enticer LTi is esthetics and strength for the large magnum 30s. The DDC is around half the price, much lighter, shorter, changeable front caps for more suppression with smaller calibers, and more availability.

DDC has a great reputation for QC and customer service in the very few times I've heard it's been needed. TBAC is like a high end analog watch maker in the way that the quality is great and the name means something to a lot of people but they don't really do anything special functionally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baron23 and Dave
#22
carbonbased said:
A bit off topic, but what’s always confused me is with 556, why is the Ultra 7 the quietest of all current TBAC cans? (Shooter’s ear)

Not much quieter, but even if they’re all dead even it’d be weird. PDF attached or go to the link.

Click to expand...
There must be some typos on that sheet or the 5.56 is a sbr gas gun... They have a 6.5 Ultra 5 listed at 138 SE dba and 30 cal Magnus listed at 139 SE dba. I own both of these cans and have shot them both on 223 bolt guns and they are dramatically different(Magnus being much much better).
 
  • Like
Reactions: carbonbased
#24
jzerfoss said:
There must be some typos on that sheet or the 5.56 is a sbr gas gun... They have a 6.5 Ultra 5 listed at 138 SE dba and 30 cal Magnus listed at 139 SE dba. I own both of these cans and have shot them both on 223 bolt guns and they are dramatically different(Magnus being much much better).
Click to expand...
The 5.56 is an sbr with a .070 port
IMG_3142.jpeg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: carbonbased and jzerfoss
#25
jzerfoss said:
I own 3 TBACs including a Magnus and a DDC Enticer S TI. I love my Magnus but Dave is right. The only thing that the Magnus would have over the Enticer LTi is esthetics and strength for the large magnum 30s. The DDC is around half the price, much lighter, shorter, changeable front caps for more suppression with smaller calibers, and more availability.

DDC has a great reputation for QC and customer service in the very few times I've heard it's been needed. TBAC is like a high end analog watch maker in the way that the quality is great and the name means something to a lot of people but they don't really do anything special functionally.
Click to expand...
🤣😂🤣
 
#28
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: carbonbased
#29
FuhQ said:
🤣😂🤣
Click to expand...
With regard to the LTi vs. the Magnus, using the 2024 Summit data for 308, the mil-left and right positions are both dominated by the supersonic crack. That's why if you sort by Mil dbA Avg or ML dB or dBA or MR dB or dBA and look at the waves of any of the top about 10 cans, the SS crack at time just after approx 0.050 is the highest SPL. If you look at what happens after that, you see some differences. For example, if you sort by SE dBA and/or look at the SE graphs, you see that one of them has most of its wave significantly less than the SS crack and the other is louder at SE that the SS crack. So there's a little more comparison of large/quiet cans than just look at the ML/MR peak, which will always just show the SS crack. See FAQ #1 for more information on this https://thunderbeastarms.com/sound/summit2024/#FAQ

There are some spec/rating differences too, that might make a difference or might not. We made the Magnus line basically for magnums and 300 NM is nothing for it. We've shot the 375 cal RR versions extensively on 375 Swiss P and it works great.

For sure at its price the LTi is a great deal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baron23
#30
Zak Smith said:
With regard to the LTi vs. the Magnus, using the 2024 Summit data for 308, the mil-left and right positions are both dominated by the supersonic crack. That's why if you sort by Mil dbA Avg or ML dB or dBA or MR dB or dBA and look at the waves of any of the top about 10 cans, the SS crack at time just after approx 0.050 is the highest SPL. If you look at what happens after that, you see some differences. For example, if you sort by SE dBA and/or look at the SE graphs, you see that one of them has most of its wave significantly less than the SS crack and the other is louder at SE that the SS crack. So there's a little more comparison of large/quiet cans than just look at the ML/MR peak, which will always just show the SS crack. See FAQ #1 for more information on this https://thunderbeastarms.com/sound/summit2024/#FAQ

There are some spec/rating differences too, that might make a difference or might not. We made the Magnus line basically for magnums and 300 NM is nothing for it. We've shot the 375 cal RR versions extensively on 375 Swiss P and it works great.

For sure at its price the LTi is a great deal.
Click to expand...
Yes, absolutely, but I was referring more to the precision build of the can, attention to details, and the bore runout being just as important as DB numbers and price. And, while I like all my cans, and they’re all great, and high-quality units, without question my TBACs are the nicest overall quality cans I own.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: Dave and DIBBS
#31
FuhQ said:
Yes, absolutely, but I was referring more to the precision build of the can, attention to details, and the bore runout being just as important as DB numbers and price. And, while I like all my cans, and they’re all great, and high-quality units, without question my TBACs are the nicest overall quality cans I own.
Click to expand...
Sorry, I was just responding to the thread in general, not your post in specific. I understood what you meant.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FuhQ
#32
Zak Smith said:
Sorry, I was just responding to the thread in general, not your post in specific. I understood what you meant.
Click to expand...
Hey there, I’m getting one of your 338 ultras rr soon. I just have a question, what would your thoughts be on having an adapter made so that it can shoot with the griffin armament ratchet lok end caps?
I don’t mean legal opinion and I realize it wouldn’t be warrantied if something happened if it was on there. I spoke to someone earlier so jm aware of the warranty thing.
I’m getting a small time but quality suppressor manufacture to make the adapter, do you foresee any technical issues in
One actually making the correct thread pitch
Two the retention of the adapter in the 338 ultra(is there a taper interface?) being secure?
Three what kind of db numbers to expect compared to a standard flat capped 338? Does the RR version have one less baffle that it would be less quiet? I could have the adapter made so that it’s a bit length, say 1.2 inches of space, so that the length is the same as it is with the RR. More volume usually means more suppression.
Thanks.
 
#33
The 338 Ultra RR is a full size 338 Ultra with the RR endcap added, so there is no deficit in baffles. The dB comparison is on this chart,
https://thunderbeastarms.com/img/Poster_2024_magnus.png check the .338 row on the left side of the chart for peak dbA.

The BA mount is secure for precision rifle shooting. If you need a secondary retention lock you can get it in the "SR" version.

I'm not touching the other issue. You might want to review the silencer part of 18 USC, and this ATF letter https://www.atf.gov/file/186521/download
 
#34
The Magnus sucks in gas guns like most tbac cans. They have way too much back pressure. Awesome bolt gun cans and the tbac22 is the absolute shitnizzle.

And I say this as someone with a Magnus on a 16" Geissele super duty.
 
#36
DeathBeforeDismount said:
The Magnus sucks in gas guns like most tbac cans. They have way too much back pressure. Awesome bolt gun cans and the tbac22 is the absolute shitnizzle.

And I say this as someone with a Magnus on a 16" Geissele super duty.
Click to expand...
A highly suppressing can will increase backpressure on a as gun, it's a trade off for decreased muzzle report. From our line typically a different can would be chosen for a gas gun, however, the overall report will generally sound quieter a few feet off the gun with the larger can.

I would also forward the opinion that a 16" with a gas system shorter than Intermediate is not going to be optimal for suppressed use, with a Rifle length being better.

The 16" SD has a midlenth +1 gas system-- longer than midlength but shorter than Intermediate. For 556, and in my opinion, 16"'s that are going to be shot unsuppressed only should be made with Intermediate, and if you want a really quiet well balanced suppressed 16", just go with rifle gas. The 16"/RLGS ones that I've put together also run unsuppressed just fine.
 
#37
Zak Smith said:
A highly suppressing can will increase backpressure on a as gun, it's a trade off for decreased muzzle report. From our line typically a different can would be chosen for a gas gun, however, the overall report will generally sound quieter a few feet off the gun with the larger can.

I would also forward the opinion that a 16" with a gas system shorter than Intermediate is not going to be optimal for suppressed use, with a Rifle length being better.

The 16" SD has a midlenth +1 gas system-- longer than midlength but shorter than Intermediate. For 556, and in my opinion, 16"'s that are going to be shot unsuppressed only should be made with Intermediate, and if you want a really quiet well balanced suppressed 16", just go with rifle gas. The 16"/RLGS ones that I've put together also run unsuppressed just fine.
Click to expand...
Absolutely. I wasn't knocking tbac just pointing out they aren't really designed around DI guns compared to some of the modern flow through designs that have their own compromises. TBAC cans function and cycle fine it's more of an issue with gas blowback.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zak Smith
#38
People are way overthinking this. If you’re using a highly suppressive can, especially a high volume one and plan to use it on a gas gun then stop being poor and build and tune a dedicated gasser to not have any blow back. It’s not 2005 anymore. There’s dozens of ways to get it done: gas port size, AGB, eztune gas tubes, KAK downward BCG, side charging uppers, anti gas charging handles, JP SCS with weights and spring kits, etc etc.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

hafejd30
Suppressors TBAC Ultra 338 Gen 2 SR vs Ultra 9??
Replies
22
Views
1K
Bacarrat
Bacarrat
Trent A
Suppressors TBAC 338 Ultra G2 SR vs DA Sandman L
Replies
31
Views
997
FuhQ
FuhQ
T
Suppressors Dead Air Sandman vs TBAC Dominus vs Surefire SOCOM
Replies
84
Views
12K
FuhQ
FuhQ
jkramlich
Best Can for 6.5 creedmoor
Replies
22
Views
19K
davsco
davsco
BuckeyeLeadslinger
TBAC Ultra 9, Am I missing something here?
Replies
28
Views
2K
Tex68w
T
Top Bottom
Back
Home
Forums
Merch
Alerts