I guess the issue is that your advice relies on genetics and age. Some folks (like yourself), and at your age, can easily gain muscle just by cleaning up their diet and lifting weights. Genetics determine the viability of that, not programming. I think in a few short years you will begin understand this (and I don't intend that to come across as condescending).
I apologize if I came across as a dick.
The OP stated he weighed 185lbs and was skinny fat. Coupled with that, he is 37. As a general rule, for the male population, 36-42yrs of age is when you physiologically hit middle age, and your body's ability to easily gain muscle and lose fat begins to diminish. BF becomes much harder to lose (especially around the abdomen for guys), testosterone and strength begin to decline, and recovery becomes an issue (degraded protein synthesis). Just lifting weights without a plan is not going to have as much effect, and is wasting valuable time and effort. Will it have some effect? Sure (vice not doing anything). But if he "wants to get in shape" at his age, all I'm saying is, it's going to require some planning and discipline. Also, generally speaking. that same age is when life tends to get in the way; work, kids, home. It limits most people's time available to spend working out. So, the question becomes not "how do I get in shape", it becomes "How do I get in shape given the amount of time I have available, and at my age?"
This is me at 165lbs
And this is me a few weeks ago at 185lbs (my back and legs have gotten quite large)
While I suppose I could go for the "shredded" look, my main goal is muscle mass. I have always been thin (165lbs at 6'3" was what I weighed when I got out of the Corps), but now that I'm looking at the latter half of life, I begin to contemplate the 5 things that aging faces us with.
Sarcopenia (loss of muscle mass)
Osteopenia (loss of bone density)
Polypharmacy (relying on multiple drugs; BP meds, diabetes, etc.)
Flexibility (loss of Range of Motion)
Balance
An organized, well thought out program allows all of these to be addressed (short of a genetic propensity for some malady like diabetes, or the sheer misfortune of contracting cancer).
For a guy who's about to turn 48 this fall, I think my results (also) speak for themselves.
Again, the opinions/options have been laid out for the OP. He'll just have to decide what best suits his desires and time available, coupled with his genetic disposition to gain muscle mass and lose body fat.
Best regards.