Re: Best Scout Scope?
Scout scopes are the antithesis of all the options you are looking for. They embody the KISS principle at its core and thus, you aren't really going to find them in that niche market.
I have used the Leupold and Burris dedicated scout scopes and I prefer the Burris. To my eyes, the glass in the Burris is superior to that of the Leupold in terms of overall clarity/resoution and in lower light (thanks in part to the heavier plex reticle versus the normal duplex in the Leupy), the eye relief on the Burris is better, it is lighter in weight, shorter in OAL, and about $50-75 cheaper than the Leupold.
Now, in terms of drawbacks, because the Burris is a true 2.75x magnification scope as opposed to the Leupold (which is advertised as a 2.5x but is actually a 2.3x), the Leupold has a larger FOV (about 8-10' or so at 100yds) which is desirable on a scout rifle setup. Also, at one time anyway, I believe that Leupold offered some customization of the scout scopes through their custom shop which might allow you to modify the reticle and/or turrets if you so chose, but I wouldn't do it based on my experiences with various rifles in a scout role/configuration.