Chamber issue on Compass Lake built Aero M5

Good morning all.
This will be a bit lengthy. Please be patient as I'm looking for some advice.
I purchased a Compass Lake built Aero M5E1 308 rifle this winter, the rifle was built in 2019. Here is a post about it:
The seller said that it had at most 10-20 rounds through it. When I bore scoped the barrel there was no carbon fouling and only a little copper build up, and the throat still had reamer marks on the rifling. From this I believe the barrel was only test fired by CLE and not the original owner. What was disappointing though was the reamer was clearly not centered on the bore when the chamber was cut. I could clearly see the freebore section on the upper half of the chamber, the lower half still had the rifling extending all the way to the case mouth. This didn't look good at all but decided to break-in the barrel and start load development, you never know it may just shoot... Unfortunately, and as expected, the rifle has not produced consistent accuracy. I've got a couple loads which showed promise, shooting 1/2 MOA @ 100 with a single 5 shot group, but then opening up to 1.5 MOA on the next.
Not wanting to take the time to go into loads, load development or shooting technique I want to focus on what to do with this rifle. Is the Aero M5E upper, rifle also has an Aero lower, capable of producing 1/2 MOA (or close to it) with a quality barrel? Or should I sell this and have a new rifle built on a Seekins, Larue, or some other brand receiver that prevents the handguard from attaching to the barrel nut and allow a thermal fit barrel? The goal is to engage targets out to 800 yards, accurately. Thanks for taking the time to read and respond...
 
The target does not lie. Yank the barrel, take the loss, get a new barrel done correctly..

Or not -- and accept your downrange performance and results.

Cut-rifled Kriegers are generally much better than mass-produced "Consumer-grade" tubes.
I definitely am not accepting the results so far. The barrel on this gun now is a 10 twist Krieger, which is why the chambering job was so disappointing... If I keep this rifle it'll get another Krieger or a Bartlein, probably a little slower twist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sinister
I've got a couple loads which showed promise, shooting 1/2 MOA @ 100 with a single 5 shot group, but then opening up to 1.5 MOA on the next.
Not wanting to take the time to go into loads, load development or shooting technique......
Not saying it's the issue here, but a large frame 308 AR is a little bit harder to drive accurately/consistently and is more dependent on shooting technique.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bfoosh006
I could clearly see the freebore section on the upper half of the chamber, the lower half still had the rifling extending all the way to the case mouth.

A gunsmith might be able to fix that with a finish reamer w/o screwing up headspace

It could also be shooter technique, i've a hard time believing it would shoot a really good group and then go wonky, then shoot another good group

And of course call compass lake and see what they say (probably piss off but maybe you'll get lucky)
 
  • Like
Reactions: simonp
Either live with it or get a quality barrel ,everybody's got an opinion on best barrel producers ,so you don't need mine .

Fyi : I've got a Ballistics barrel and it's .320" MOA in 6.5 CM ,so sometimes one gets lucky . As I recently stacked #20 hunting loads into .404" at 278 Yd. .