Re: Congrats to Drew Brees!
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Bayou Boy</div><div class="ubbcode-body">One thing I have seen for sure. Players have hot streak seasons and sometimes not nearly as hot the next year. You have to look at the career to really say who belongs where and to be top 10 all time is nearly impossible.
All I can say is Drew is #1 AND #3 on total passing yards in a season. A record that has stood for 20 something years. It's not an accident and his accuracy is off the charts.
I LOVE Rodgers and I think he's gonna be outstanding for a long time. But before we start calling him better than someone who's had alot more experience and stats, etc, we need to let the test of time run its course. One season cannot possibly make a player the best that ever played the game. That goes for Brees too. </div></div>
To me total passing yards means very little or rather inconclusive when determining the best Qbs. Reason being like someone said earlier Brees has 120 more attempts than Rodgers this year and more than Brady as well...so can't really use that statistic. For everything that you judge a QB on there is something that offsets it. You can argue that someone has a higher completion percentage, but how many drops has that QB suffered at the hands of his WR and how good are his WRs? Yards, well how many times did he throw it? Wins, is his defense top notch and win some games for him?
There is just no set characteristic or stat that you can use. I think there are so many variables you have to factor in and that is the reason why I would not put Brees as MVP. You have two other QBs, Brady and Rodgers, that have worse defenses that have throw for similar yards, and have as many wins if not more than Brees and are not all that far behind in yards and have less attempts.
Granted Brees is an outstanding QB and has a high completion percentage which to me is a bigger deal than the yards themselves.
Last 8-10 years or so Brady has lead the league in twice in passer rating (2007 and 2010), Brees once (2009) while also coming in second once (2006) and Rodgers runner up to Brady last season (hasn't been starting long). Both Brady and Brees have lead the league in throwing TDs in a season about the same amount of times. It is just so hard to argue who is the best and who isnt, hence all the arguments by the analysts etc. I think we can all agree though that Brady, Brees and Rodgers are all in the elite category and make watching football right now very entertaining
- extra note remember that the Saints have a very good rushing attack (9th in the league) whereas the Patriots and Green Bay are not nearly as good (19th and 27th respectively). A good running attack helps open up the passing