Well, first of all, stop calling them clicks and use the actual measurements on your dial. That way we can all understand what your numbers really are. Since you are using a NF NXS in MOA, each click is 1/4 (.25) MOA, so you are saying that at 200 (Yards I assume?) you had to dial only 1.0 MOA, at 300, 5.0 MOA and at 400 you were at 6.0 MOA. If everything else is correct, then you are right, it does not make sense. That trajectory does not compute, so somewhere you got something wrong.
For the standard FGMM in 175g running about 2650 fps MV, your numbers should look something like 2.0 MOA at 200 yards, 4.7 MOA at 300 yards and 7.9 MOA at 400 yards. Or in your terms, 8 clicks at 200, 19 clicks at 300, and 32 clicks at 400.
So, you need to either verify the yardages you zeroed and were shooting at or you need to check the turrets on your scope and make sure they are working properly. You will note that your 300 yard number is almost dead on.