That has not been my experience at all, and I've dressed five deer in a row before I started feeling like they were dulling up. D2 is good steel. I use my Coho fillet knife, and the little Cub Bear and capeing knives as my main gotos. Maybe you got a bad one, because I've used mine for years without complaint, and I have quite a few high end knives... I always go back to these because they work so well. I don't think I've actually "sharpened" them if five years. I throw some jeweler's rouge on the power strop and just polish them up.