Re: Leupold varmint reticle ?
I think a varmint reticle works great if you shoot a fairly fast round. I use one on my sako finnlight in 300 win mag. I have a 4.5-14x40 with the reticle.
14 power rarely has mirage issues - especially in cooler hunting weather for deer or elk. With a 200 yard zero you can go out to 600 with the hack marks just fine. Obviously the advice about verifying your hack marks is dead on.
Mine match up within 2 inches all the way out. Here are the MOA drop values for the varmint reticle so you can see for yourself:
200 - zero
300 - 1.81moa
400 - 4.13 moa
500 - 7.02 moa
600 - 9.35
Note that you can easily take a ballistic table and figure out exactly what your hack lines equate to.
Your zero is your zero whether you are at 5 or 14 power so it doesn't matter what focal plane you are on. Therefore, you can shoot at any power all the way out to probably 250, then you have to start holding over.
Logically any shot past 200 yards is not too close to crank it up to 14 power. I have never been compromised with a field of view or mirage issue by being on 14 power if shooting more than 200. I generally keep my scope on two settings - all the way down for walking, sitting, close work or all the way up for shooting past 100 yards.
In conclusion, the ballistic reticles work well for 95% of all applications that a hunter will need. Is it a 1000 yard sniper scope - NO, but it works on elk just dandy.
Respectfully.