• Frank's Lesson's Contest

    We want to see your skills! Post a video between now and November 1st showing what you've learned from Frank's lessons and 3 people will be selected to win a free shirt. Good luck everyone!

    Create a channel Learn more
  • Having trouble using the site?

    Contact support

Problem with vitamins

Mike_in_FL

Supporter
Supporter
Full Member
Minuteman
Supporter
  • Feb 29, 2008
    1,610
    696
    Tampa Bay, FL
    I usually try to take them after/with a meal. I was buying mostly separate supplements and then went back to a multivitamin. I'm getting a burning that seems to be lower than my stomach fairly rapidly. It's happened with a couple different brands.

    If I go singles, B, C, E, calcium, whatever I don't seem to have the problem. Any ideas? BTW, I know, stop taking them, lol.
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    I don't pretend to be an expert, but my advice would be to try to get what you need nutritionally from a well balanced diet, not from a pill. The sport supplement and vitamin industry is a multi-billion dollar sector(I think something in the range of 60 billion dollars worldwide)that is very loosely regulated by the FDA, domestically. None of these people, FDA included, truly have your best interests in mind, just your money. Here is an interesting link regarding Calcium supplements:

    http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-204_162-57440558/study-links-calcium-pills-to-heart-attacks/

    You be the judge.

    Feel free to PM me.
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    I've seen this time and time again.

    Someone tries to get healthy by taking vitamin supplements, but they don't change their diet. Useless!

    If you take a multivitamin and keep eating fast food all the time you are making no headway whatsoever.

    Eat a healthy diet and ditch the pills.

    To many vitamins can kill your liver at 3 times the rate of prescription painkillers or even alcoholic beverages. You want to talk about a problem. Medically deal with someone who has a damaged liver. Nothing works in the line of medication, and they die a painful death.

    So, in short ... ditch the pill popping vitamin habit. It's doing nothing for you!
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    Fruits, Vegtables, whole grains . Consume as much of it raw as you can, you can rub those bottles until the labels come off , but no jeanie is gonna is gonna come out.
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    I agree with obtaining your vitamins through food it is the best way. If you feel that you are lacking in a certain one then take that one. The ones that really benefit from taking one are those who have a strict and well balanced diet and are working out at a vey intense level. When you take these multi-vitamins and you go use the bathroom and you notice that you are pissing green its because you are flushing the pill out and your body is not using even a remote portion of it but as said prior it all passes through the liver and is not helping your body out just wasted money for the most part.
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    You're obviously best off getting your vitamins and minerals from a good balanced diet. I've heard if you think that you need to supplement that decent diet with something then try kids vitamins. Basically it's just to give you little extra help in that department, not to be over the top potent.

    Every vitamin maker tries to best one another by having more of everything else then the next guy. That can't be great for our bodies, but no doubt some supplements can be beneficial as well. I don't do vitamins, but I've considered a kids multivitamin a time or two. Now if I could only decide.... Flintstones or those little gummy bear ones?
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    Rooster, do you have a source for the info that vitamins are that damaging to your liver? I'd like to have a look at some studies if possible.
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    <div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: northshore440</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I don't pretend to be an expert, but my advice would be to try to get what you need nutritionally from a well balanced diet, not from a pill. The sport supplement and vitamin industry is a multi-billion dollar sector(I think something in the range of 60 billion dollars worldwide)that is very loosely regulated by the FDA, domestically. None of these people, FDA included, truly have your best interests in mind, just your money. Here is an interesting link regarding Calcium supplements:

    http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-204_162-57440558/study-links-calcium-pills-to-heart-attacks/

    You be the judge.

    Feel free to PM me.
    </div></div>

    ^^^This.

    No joke, if you feel a vitamin is helpful, a good diet and maybe a Flintstone vitamin would be ideal for a healthy person. I think they make 'em for adults, but you don't need much... It is true much our prepared food is depleted of nutrients, but it is also true the vitamin industry overdoes it.

    The burning or flushing could come from excess niacin. Other things can cause it, and some have been known to add it to vitamins "so you can feel it working, burning the fat and poisions". Whatever.

    Good diet, 1 Flintstone vitamin, and brush your teeth. Just like Momma said.
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    Now all that is saying you are healthy... A blood test from a good doctor will uncover deficiencies, in which they prescribe specific vitamins. That is different. A healthy person won't be deficient on average, and may experience negative effects from excess vitamins as some ARE poison in large amounts over time. Very large doses of vitamin C will cause a serious itchy red rash and open sores all over the body. Iron is deadly. Hence, my recommendation for the Flintstone vitamin. One can't do any harm, will fill in any minor deficiencies due to metabolism, lack of proper food, etc., but won't do anything for major deficiencies where you need to see a doctor.

    I don't know about shutting down the liver or heart, but I do know there are some nasty side effects from some, and some are in fact poisonous in high doses. Effects on the liver and heart wouldn't surprise me.
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    Again, not an expert here, but to the OP:

    If it HURTS when you take them, what is the realized benefit? I mean, theoretically, we believe that taking vitamins makes you big, strong, and healthy. That's what we've all been taught and read. But if you take them, and you have a distinct and appreciable negative result, perhaps you should question conventional wisdom...to the contrary of Mens Health and Muscle and Fitness. It's your body, right?
    When was the last time you took a multivitamin and felt stronger/faster/healthier shortly thereafter?

    The concept of "Health" or "fitness" is somewhat abstract and is not as quickly recognized as say, an ibuprofen when you have a headache, or a cup of coffee when you are lethargic. So how do you prove it, while saying Centrum, Geritol, or Flintsones are a significant contributing factor? Kinda reminds me of when Kellogs or General Mills says Fruit Loops or Lucky Charms are a part of "This nutritious breakfast", then shows a screen shot of their chosen cereal with fruit, milk,bread, and other breakfast delights on a table top. Where's the real nutrition?
    I'm not trying to preach here, and I don't want to give the wrong impression. I'm not some stinky hippy new-ager that thinks you should live off of dandelion milk and positive energy. However, I can tell you that fitness, health, and happiness do not come in a pill.
    Chances are, you are not deficient in a particular nutrient, you are merely taking a vitamin because you think you should. Because, that is what healthy, fit people do, right?
    Like I said before, PM me.
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    Didn't know this thread had developed a life of it's own. Well, I never said my diet consisted of bags of Lays and Mountain Dew. Nor did I say that I thought there was some kind of anabolic steroid placebo result from taking them. I think it would be safe to say that most don't eat a completely balanced diet.

    Supplements were recommended to me by sports coaches back in HS, a long time ago now that I'm pushing 50. I used to smoke which I understand depletes calcium. I don't have scurvy but I'm not eating oranges everyday either. I pretty much stay away from all fast food now. It's almost to the point where if I eat it, I'm almost physically ill whereas when younger could've probably eaten McDonalds everyday. It's funny to get what I'd describe as cravings for things like salad and rye bread now, lol.

    Needless to say I've stopped taking them. I have eaten pretty much high protein for quite some time. I just try and stay away from things I know affect me, like starch, potatoes, etc. I probably do more canned than fresh vegetables and have to make a conscious decision to go to the produce stand to get fresh fruit.

    I appreciate the comments, but was really looking for a guess as to WHAT is put into a multivitamin as opposed to simply taking calcium, C, and E separately.
     
    Re: Problem with vitamins

    A proper amount of vitamins in our meal is necessary to maintain the health and to run the different body functions.
    Eat natural foods instead of the packed supplements to get rich amount of vitamins. Eat more fresh fruits and raw vegetables for the vitamins.