Well you added even more fuel to that fire with that one..
Not trying to roast you, but your example is perfect to use to take a peek into the realistic reasons for some of the pushback people get with their claims.. Especially if they make it sound repeatable..
Having shot ELR for far too long, longer that it was popular; one constant seems to be popular. Just about everyone claims completive F-class results when they post what they do. The catch is, it's usually longer, with factory ammo and nowhere near the same level of equipment.
FYI ELR: Just due to optical issues your gun is not going to have the same minute of angle as it is at 100, unless it was an anomaly. Now add in a bit off SD/ES.. and your going not only to have a huge vertical component but a hare more drift... Wait wind? Hope this makes sense..
Here is an example using a 130VLD - it is only a relative example and
does NOT include any of the variables that cause the misses I mentioned above: FYI I generally think in mils but will use MOA and linear inches
Lets assume 2900 AFPS
Factory Ammo: SD 15 ES 50 over a couple boxes -Typical very good factory ammo
1800y
Wind mild 5mph FV
| AFPS | 25 FPS change | Velocity ONLY based Change | 50 FPS change | Velocity ONLY based Change |
Elevation Linear in inches | 1707.8 | 1743.61 | 35.81+3/4MOA = 49.9" | 1780.12 | 72.32+3/4MOA = 86.43" |
Wind only from velocity variance | 154.4 | 155.86 | 1.46 +14.11" = | 157.31 | 2.91+14.11 |
Now if the mirage or dust in the air. displaces the image .5MOA variance (thats ultra low for mirage at that distance BTW)
add 9.4" to the numbers above..
With a Max ORD of about 700 inches and 1800y lets assume a minimal 2mph in wind variance during your day. As this academic example steps along add 2" to the vertical and crazy horizontal 61.8"+14.11" or almost 76" of uncertainty on your 18" plate, without Velocity errors or the Optical uncertainty..
View attachment 7255455
Below is a Analysis on a
ZERO WIND Variance, No Optical variation and low very low factory MV variation (antidotal as it may be, I have never shot ELR without some variance of wind)
View attachment 7255456
FWIW I am not saying that you didn't get lucky and bang the plate a bunch in a row, but the reality is it is not something that can happen all the time.