Which of these handguards?

[rg1911]

Years ago, I put a square-section, flat-bottom handguard on an AR-15 because I shoot that rifle normally off a rest or bi-pod. However, it has no cooling slots and weighs almost 1.5 pounds. Looking for a replacement, I found these that look as though they would do the trick. However, I am not familiar with the names (except SLR) and would like to check the SH knowledge base to see if any of these brands should be on my short list (or should be tossed into the trash).

Other recommendations are always welcome.

The basic requirements are:

- M-Lok
- an inside diameter of at least 1.35 inches to fit over my SLR gas block
- a length of 13.7 inches to cover the block while letting me access the adjustment screw at the front
- a (relatively) snag-free bottom for shooting off a rest

Thank you,
Richard

SLR Rifleworks ION 13.7" Mid MLOK Handguard
https://slrrifleworks.com/index.php?route=product/product&path=66_106_134_135&product_id=1190

SLR Rifleworks HELIX 13.7" MLOK Handguard - F Model
https://slrrifleworks.com/index.php?route=product/product&path=66_106_143&product_id=1061

Grid Defense Octagon M-LOK Handguard Black - 14"
https://www.primaryarms.com/grid-defense-octagon-m-lok-handguard-black-14

Strike Industries 13.5" Strike Rail M-LOK Handguard
https://www.primaryarms.com/strike-ind-rail-135-mlok-handguard-si-strikerail-135-bk

Rise Armament 13.5" Lightweight M-LOK AR-15 Handguard
https://www.primaryarms.com/rise-armament-13-5in-lightweight-ar-15-handguard-m-lok-black

 

[wade2big]

Its a handguard..... Pick one.

 

[TonyTheTiger]

The Seekins SP3R is probably your best bet for bag/barricade riding.

I have that Rise HG and I like it but it had some issues and I wouldn't use it on a precision build.

 

[TonyTheTiger]

Its a handguard..... Pick one.

This is America. We have choices and we like it that way.

 

[wade2big]

This is America. We have choices and we like it that way.

I dont think otherwise. It is just a handguard. Pick the one you think looks the best and be done.

 

[rg1911]

I ask because I've read that not all handguards are equal. For instance, some don't like to stay firmly in place.

Richard

 

[Currycure]

pick one and be done with it. its not always the gun but the shooter that matters.

 

[TonyTheTiger]

For instance, some don't like to stay firmly in place.

Thats the case with that Rise Armament one. I had to wrap the nut in thim shim stock to get it tight.

 

[rg1911]

Thats the case with that Rise Armament one. I had to wrap the nut in thim shim stock to get it tight.

Now that's the type of information for which I'm looking. Thank you.

I think I'll go with the SLR, in large part because they have taken such good care of me with their gas blocks. I figure if something isn't right, they'll take care of it immediately.

Cheers,
Richard

 

[lennyo3034]

Geissele MK18.

 

[rg1911]

Geissele MK18.

It does, indeed, look impressive, and I'm sure it meets Geissele's high standards, but I'm retired on a fixed income.

Richard

 

[Fret]

I have the Rise Armament hand guard and the three threaded holes for snugging it down on the barrel nut weren't threaded right. I had to tap them.

 

[USMC_JA]

SLR rails are fantastic. Not sure they are as sturdy as other options but the machining and detail is first rate.

 

[awpk03s]

The new handguards by Larue are nice, especially for the money. But the longest one is only 13.2”

 

[Merle]

If you want something with a flat bottom I'd suggest the KDG MREX-AR handguard. It is mlok, flat on the bottom, and very light.