Would you reject this action?

EchosGalahad · Oct 23, 2024

I ordered a custom action, and I'm just curious on your guys thoughts. The base of the bolt right in front of the handle is missing nitriding, and there is a scratch on the bottom of the action right where the mag would seat showing bare metal.

This is a new action, from a vendor. I don't want to put anyone on blast.

Not gonna affect function, however $1500 for just the action I suppose I had higher expectations on fit and finish.

roostercogburn98 · Oct 23, 2024

Did you contact CS and let them know. Have you accepted it from your FFL already?

brianf · Oct 23, 2024

New is new

If you paid full price you get full price.

I never understand why people are willing to deal with QC in the firearms industry.

The action costs as much as a new freezer…if the freezer was a scratched handle you’d get a new one

stanley_white · Oct 23, 2024

brianf said:
New is new

If you paid full price you get full price.

I never understand why people are willing to deal with QC in the firearms industry.

The action costs as much as a new freezer…if the freezer was a scratched handle you’d get a new one

IMO there is this “I don’t want to inconvenience a fellow 2A advocate” subconscious thing that needs to be replaced with “I bought a product and the company that produced that product failed me. They will fix it.”

-Stan

Buzzinga · Oct 23, 2024

Sounds like you know what you want to do...like Nike said--Just Do It

D̷e̷v̷i̷l̷D̷o̷c̷A̷Z̷ · Oct 23, 2024

brianf said:
New is new

If you paid full price you get full price.

I never understand why people are willing to deal with QC in the firearms industry.

The action costs as much as a new freezer…if the freezer was a scratched handle you’d get a new one

Freezers must have gotten cheap

EchosGalahad · Oct 23, 2024

I saw it on my way home from work but haven't accepted it yet, I need to go back today to do background check. I've never rejected anything before. Appreciate all the input guys

D̷e̷v̷i̷l̷D̷o̷c̷A̷Z̷ · Oct 23, 2024

EchosGalahad said:
I saw it on my way home from work but haven't accepted it yet, I need to go back today to do background check. I've never rejected anything before. Appreciate all the input guys

I know who’s not a Costco member.

EchosGalahad · Oct 23, 2024

D̷e̷v̷i̷l̷D̷o̷c̷A̷Z̷ said:
I know who’s not a Costco member.

I meant firearm haha. Wife works at Costco, spend way too much time there.

Aftermath · Oct 23, 2024

EchosGalahad said:
I ordered a custom action, and I'm just curious on your guys thoughts. The base of the bolt right in front of the handle is missing nitriding, and there is a scratch on the bottom of the action right where the mag would seat showing bare metal.

This is a new action, from a vendor. I don't want to put anyone on blast.

Not gonna affect function, however $1500 for just the action I suppose I had higher expectations on fit and finish.

Pics

45-90 · Oct 23, 2024

It should be without visible flaws when received, and not accepted by the public.
Most people will drive a new car back to the dealer or have the flaw repaired before taking possession.
But a firearm cost money to send it back in through the FFL dealer, and shipping will most likely be added on.
May times they are not even repaired, with two or three tries to get issues resolved.
Or a note that says it's in spec, for even mechanical issues.
Its up to you, but it can take a long time to get satisfaction, and its only a finish and a scratch, but you didn't put it there.
Many have a 30 day return policy that they try to run out.
Different people working at the same company, will present a different attitude towards the customer.

Mike Casselton · Oct 23, 2024

brianf said:
New is new

If you paid full price you get full price.

I never understand why people are willing to deal with QC in the firearms industry.

The action costs as much as a new freezer…if the freezer was a scratched handle you’d get a new one

Actually, the freezer would be considered scratch and dent.
They usually sell for around 1/2 price for minor stuff not even visible when installed.

Taylorbok · Oct 23, 2024

brianf said:
The action costs as much as a new freezer…if the freezer was a scratched handle you’d get a new one

Mike Casselton said:
Actually, the freezer would be considered scratch and dent.
They usually sell for around 1/2 price for minor stuff not even visible when installed.

I actually was just shopping for a second freezer, went to the local appliance places to look for scratch and dent, they both told me with freezers almost everyone accepts the financial compensation and keeps the freezer so you rarely see them back.

different story with appliances that are viewed more frequently

D_TROS · Oct 23, 2024

IF its going to be a safe queen return it along with your man card

if its going to be used carry on.

sadly i have a feelin i know which choice you will make

"...the base of the bolt"

wow.

GL
DT

Evintos · Oct 23, 2024

EchosGalahad said:
I ordered a custom action, and I'm just curious on your guys thoughts. The base of the bolt right in front of the handle is missing nitriding, and there is a scratch on the bottom of the action right where the mag would seat showing bare metal.

This is a new action, from a vendor. I don't want to put anyone on blast.

Not gonna affect function, however $1500 for just the action I suppose I had higher expectations on fit and finish.

Nitriding is not a surface coating and the black coloration is an oxide layer that is very thin and even if abraded off, the compound layer and diffusion layer still exists before it reaches base metal. Simply put, the black coloration is mostly cosmetic and provides little surface level corrosion resistance.

brianf · Oct 23, 2024

stanley_white said:
IMO there is this “I don’t want to inconvenience a fellow 2A advocate” subconscious thing that needs to be replaced with “I bought a product and the company that produced that product failed me. They will fix it.”

-Stan

The most used most embarrassing phrase with firearms..

“He’ll make it right”

roostercogburn98 · Oct 23, 2024

brianf said:
The most used most embarrassing phrase with firearms..

“He’ll make it right”

Sounds personal

stanley_white · Oct 23, 2024

brianf said:
The most used most embarrassing phrase with firearms..

“He’ll make it right”

I am tired of companies being praised for “Making it right” quickly.

Maybe make it right the first time?

Loyalty, easily bought, for the price of a return label.

-Stan

mark5pt56 · Oct 23, 2024

stanley_white said:
IMO there is this “I don’t want to inconvenience a fellow 2A advocate” subconscious thing that needs to be replaced with “I bought a product and the company that produced that product failed me. They will fix it.”

-Stan

That and ignorant fucks that say "it's a gun, it will get scatches, what's the big deal?" That's not the point, you paid for a new item, you should receive the same in new condition without defects. Fridge, car, gun, etc. Would you go buy a King Ranch or whatever and tell the dealer-nah, don't worry about that scratch down the drivers door and paint missing from the hood?

mark5pt56 · Oct 23, 2024

stanley_white said:
I am tired of companies being praised for “Making it right” quickly.

Maybe make it right the first time?

Loyalty, easily bought, for the price of a return label.

-Stan

You mean like having to return a rifle with gouges on the barrel's cerakote from the bolt that some monkey threw into the box, unwrapped?

Emerson0311 · Oct 23, 2024

mark5pt56 said:
That and ignorant fucks that say "it's a gun, it will get scatches, what's the big deal?" That's not the point, you paid for a new item, you should receive the same in new condition without defects. Fridge, car, gun, etc. Would you go buy a King Ranch or whatever and tell the dealer-nah, don't worry about that scratch down the drivers door and paint missing from the hood?

I feel the same when many of the items we buy are $1500-$5000 and sell used for 1/2 that.

TheOE800 · Oct 23, 2024

stanley_white said:
Loyalty, easily bought, for the price of a return label.

Have you seen the cost of shipping a firearm lately?

Wisconsinner · Oct 23, 2024

If you aren't happy with it send it back right away. I have an action I accepted with several blemishes in the nitride treatment. I've had it for a few years and just dealt with it but it pissed me off knowing I paid good money for it.

Just yesterday I took a picture of the blemishes and emailed the manufacturer They are having me send it in to get the finish redone. Now that rifle will sit in pieces till I get it back. I wish I would have addressed the issue right away.

camocorvette · Oct 23, 2024

Pictures or this is trash

Darryle · Oct 23, 2024

My new shit looks old before I get around to using it, I guess my give a shit is broken. By the time I permanently bed the rail and get a scope mounted, it's got character

EchosGalahad · Oct 23, 2024

mark5pt56 said:
That and ignorant fucks that say "it's a gun, it will get scatches, what's the big deal?" That's not the point, you paid for a new item, you should receive the same in new condition without defects. Fridge, car, gun, etc. Would you go buy a King Ranch or whatever and tell the dealer-nah, don't worry about that scratch down the drivers door and paint missing from the hood?

Thanks for this.

hafejd30 · Oct 23, 2024

Personally it wouldn’t bother me

But it bothers you enough to ask. So it bothers you.

Ask them to make it right. Or it will continue to bother you

I’m personally a fan of character as long as it won’t rust or affect the function.

For me getting a scratch on my truck makes me less concerned with getting the next scratch on it. So I use it as a truck more

I know guys who use their grill. Then wash the entire thing after use. It continues to look new and makes them happy. Different strokes for different folks

EchosGalahad · Oct 23, 2024

hafejd30 said:
Personally it wouldn’t bother me

But it bothers you enough to ask. So it bothers you.

Ask them to make it right. Or it will continue to bother you

I’m personally a fan of character as long as it won’t rust or affect the function.

For me getting a scratch on my truck makes me less concerned with getting the next scratch on it. So I use it as a truck more

I know guys who use their grill. Then wash the entire thing after use. It continues to look new and makes them happy. Different strokes for different folks

Amen about the scratch on the truck. Same way here.

I looked it over and the scratch is very very minor, nitride on the bolt looks more dull then missing upon closer inspection. Appreciate everyone's replies. I'll post pictures on Sunday when the overlords let me pick it up.

Thanks for letting me bounce this off more knowledgeable people.

Having trouble using the site?

Subscribe to HideTV with code XMAS20 for 20% Off

Would you reject this action?

Private

Fudd gun collector extraordinaire

Private

If it ain’t broke, you can’t resist.

Supporter

Banned x2 🤪 / Bear Pit Super Mod

Private

Banned x2 🤪 / Bear Pit Super Mod

Private

RECOIL FETISHIST

Major Hide Member

No, I just wear the T-shirt

Private

Flag-Sword-Cross

Lurker

Private

Fudd gun collector extraordinaire

If it ain’t broke, you can’t resist.

Gunny Sergeant

Gunny Sergeant

Old Salt

Argumentative

Private

Send it

My Squirrel is locked in a Faraday Cage

Private

Supporter

Private

Similar threads