Hi,
As sure as that meme is written in English.
Sincerely,
Theis
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
To enter, all you need to do is add an image of yourself at the range below! Subscribers get more entries, check out the plans below for a better chance of winning!
Join the contest SubscribeYou gonna spin a 175 SMK or 185 JUG out of its jacket from a .308 case? Probably not.Hi,
That is jacketed bullets spinning the lead out from being spun too fast.
Sincerely,
Theis
The context helps. FWIW, a 20 inch 1:12 will easily stabilize anything up to 175 grain bullets, but if you are interested in solids or subsonic rounds then you may indeed need more twist. However, those are still what I would consider niche cases, and for general purpose use in a 308 there would be no need to go past 1:10 even with a 16 inch barrel.OP here:
Well, this will be my first hunting rifle, and it will be the most expensive rifle I´ve ever bought as well.
A buddy of mine has this type of rifle now for three years, and I was hooked since the day I saw it.
I´ve seen and handled really a lot of rifles in my life, but this one is outstanding above all of them.
So I never got this rifle out of my brain and every time we met, he let me handle and shoot his if I wanted to, and this made it worse.
And because of the availability of components and ammo over here it has to be the .308 Winchester.
For supressor use in our woods here, I want to have it short and handy.
So you can have barrels with 1:12 from 20" up to 24", but this will make it heavy and nose-heavy, and I don´t trust the 20" barrel in the 1:12 twist - because of understabilization in this short barrel.
But you can have another barrel in .308 Win., this 18" with a 1:8" twist.
![]()
Twist Rate Stability Calculator
Our newly updated Twist Rate Stability Calculator not only tells you what your SG is, but it also lets you know if you are reaching your optimized BC.bergerbullets.com
You have to know, that changing barrels from a barrel maker is a very expensive and cumbersome thing (officials and documents).
And this rifle, which has an interchangeable barrel option, needs some very special connection points, which will not be made by every barrel maker easy.
So I called the manufacturer and asked him, if there is no other option, like a 1:10 in an 18 or 20" barrel or so.
And he said, they have tested their standard 1:12" barrel down to 16" and some have shot and others were all over the place.
So they talked to their barrel maker, which is Lothar Walther, and out came this 18" barrel in 1:8.
The sales manager told me, that he himself uses this rifle with exact this barrel and it shoots outstanding.
That´s the long story.
Wanting this rifle like I´ve never wanted one before, having to choose between 20" in 1:12 and 18" in 1:8.
And it must take solids as well as jacketed bullets.
![]()
Die STRASSER RS 14 EVOLUTION Jagdgewehre | Die Gewehre für Jagd & Sport
STRASSER Jagdgewehre und Sportgewehre der zuverlässige Begleiter für die Jagd & Schießsport ✔ Mehr Infos >>www.hms-strasser.com
![]()
Strasser USA - Strasser USA
Classic features combined with modern European designwww.strasser-usa.com
.... for general purpose use in a 308 there would be no need to go past 1:10 even with a 16 inch barrel.
A solid copper or brass bullet is less dense than lead. As such to make an equal mass you need to add more material. You are limited by the bore diameter for a given caliber so the only way to get more copper in is to make it longer.I´m a reloader.
It is law in some areas here, that you must shoot solids (no lead allowed) when hunting.
So, if I´m right, solids need a faster twist, isn´t it?
A solid copper or brass bullet is less dense than lead. As such to make an equal mass you need to add more material. You are limited by the bore diameter for a given caliber so the only way to get more copper in is to make it longer.
Length is really what twist rate is fighting, not mass. The longer the bullet the more the center of gravity and air resistance can move away from the center and thus it starts to pitch and yaw and if it yaws too much and catches the air resistance it starts to tumble. Spinning it faster let’s it’s rotational velocity cause the bullet to fall back into its center of gravity/axis of travel and thus not tumble as easily, or at least as soon. The forces sorta cancel each other out.
View attachment 7671218
Yaws too much and it turns into a sail but if it spins back to the opposite side fast enough it will right itself and cancel out staying stabile in flight.
Spin it faster and it will have less time to yaw before it spins and the force turn the opposite direction so basically you just keep it falling into itself.
So that’s why solids are generally needing a faster twist rate than a lead bullet at a given weight. If you took a copper and lead bullet that are the same length and profile they will take the same twist, it’s just the copper won’t be as heavy.
It is really going to depend on the specific solids you want to shoot. Either will work for lead bullets but you will get better performance from the 20 inch.So, regarding this, what confirms what I was guessing, back to topic and to the starting question.
Should I go with the 18" barrel in a 1:8" twist or with the 20" barrel in a 1:12" twist?
This are the two options I have, which way should I go?
Im sure. Thats generally why people say to start development over at the bottom when switching to a solid.Does the length of the bullet become an issue with a twist so fast that you begin to impart different twist forces at the front and rear of the bullet bearing surfaces?
Im guessing the the rifling would have to resemble machine screw thread to have the front of the bearing surface entering a whole different stage of rotation than the rear.
At some point pressure is going to win and just skid the bullet over the rifling.
Apologies for my thoughts if non applicable to the OPs question.
Just learning shit through smarter people.
My little experiment is not going to be on an ultra short barrel at 21 inches, nor is my twist drastic. with gain twist I guess Im hedging my bet and with only 21 inches to get the gain in how much will it matter?
So, regarding this, what confirms what I was guessing, back to topic and to the starting question.
Should I go with the 18" barrel in a 1:8" twist or with the 20" barrel in a 1:12" twist?
This are the two options I have, which way should I go?
You had said "Jacketed from around 150 to 180grs., solids from 130 to 165grs. I guess."
What velocity are you putting in? You should be fine up to 185 grain lead bullets in a 1:12. Or are you talking about solids.Well, that´s what I have guessed what´s common, isn´t it?
It is actually my first hunting rilfe and my first .308 Win..
I would love to hear other experiences.
Regarding the twist rate calculator from Berger, a 20" barrel in a 1:12" twist everything above 168gr. is "Marginal Stability" or "Unstable".
But that´s just a calculator, practice beats theory, so it would be a blast for me to learn from you guys.
I built a 20" .308 a few years ago with an 8 twist, and my best group to date (only three rounds) was 0.42" edge to edge at 100yds and was pushing 185gr bergers at 2730fps. You will be happy with it.
In the case of overtwisting tearing the bullet apart, it's the length of the bearing surface, not overall length of the bullet. The bearing surface on a high BC bullet isn't all that different from a standard length bullet, i.e. a 147 FMJBT. A 220-250gr. standard ogive will have a long bearing surface. Which shouldn't be an issue at subsonic speeds.Does the length of the bullet become an issue with a twist so fast that you begin to impart different twist forces at the front and rear of the bullet bearing surfaces?
Im guessing the the rifling would have to resemble machine screw thread to have the front of the bearing surface entering a whole different stage of rotation than the rear.
At some point pressure is going to win and just skid the bullet over the rifling.
Apologies for my thoughts if non applicable to the OPs question.
Just learning shit through smarter people.
My little experiment is not going to be on an ultra short barrel at 21 inches, nor is my twist drastic. with gain twist I guess Im hedging my bet and with only 21 inches to get the gain in how much will it matter?
This. I can shoot 175-8gr pills fine at ~2630fps and 225gr subsonicThe Desert Tech 16” .308 barrels for the SRS are 1:8 twist and shoot well.
I have had experience with a rifle very similar, 1:8 twist tack driver bolt gun(pic below)I don't know, but I sound like a nerd hinting around shit so I will just stop.
I will say about the CSR I shot for a period of about a year it was an awesome rifle. There were actually 3 different types. An OBR with a 14.5" 1:8", a Remington MSR 14" 1:8", and the Surgeon 14.5" 1:8". I had the Surgeon and it was far better than the rest. The OBR had some significant accuracy issues. The MSR was heavy, the fit was loose all over on multiple parts, and it didn't return to zero well. The Surgeon shot M118LR about 3/4" moa and it was good enough for me to jump it in a HAHO, PLF land, assemble the scope and suppressor, and certify on a 300m coldbore headshot CTE. It's RYZ was impeccable and when I shot subsonic through it was FAF(fun as fuck). This version was in a Remington RACs. The good version with the fully skeletonized butt stock and tooless adjustment. The forend was custom cut so it could be removed right in front of the action. It used wrench flats on the neck of the barrel under the handguard to torque and break torque so the user could simply unscrew the barrel to break the gun down to conceal it. A titanium 338 suppressor screwed on right in front of the fore end. It used a jewell trigger. It was badass. Much lighter and refined than the bulky AX chassis version Surgeon now uses.
Wait you shoot 178 gr pills at 2600 fps out out a 16" DTA ?This. I can shoot 175-8gr pills fine at ~2630fps and 225gr subsonic
2000mr will do itWait you shoot 178 gr pills at 2600 fps out out a 16" DTA ?
Yes. .308 winchester. 168SMK, 175 OTM, 175 SMK, 169SMK and 168 Tipped Tactical Bonded.