To answer your original question
I have one with the MIL-C reticle. It is one of my favorite scopes.
- Is the extra 10X usable? It is sometimes when mirage is under control.
- I have never had a problem with the scope. It has seen its share of oopsies and just works.
- I love the fact that the ZS can be adjusted to whatever you want. I run a multi-caliber rifle so this helps a lot.
- They offer a good selection of reticles
- Turret legibility and feel are really nice. I think that the Tangent Theta that I played with has the best turrets out there but these are better than the DT or MTC turrets on my S&Bs.
- Glass is great....good contrast, good color balance and no CA. I don't make a big deal about glass as it is really subjective
- NF customer service is awesome. I have never had to send the scope in for repair but I have had questions and CS was all over it.
- Dialing in the Diopter/Parallax is more difficult than on my S&Bs and Khales but NF customer service and the threads here made it a snap.
- The ocular rotates as magnification is changed. If you have a scope cover on the ocular, it also rotate which drives some people crazy...LOL
When you consider what you can buy them for relative to MSRP, they are a great optic. Value is awesome.
Previous TT Gen2XR owner here now using a 7-35 MIL-C. I agree with most of your comments but have a couple to add:
1.) I miss the TT turrets. The NF turrets are good, but the TT are great. The tactfulness and audibility are next level.
2.) I miss the TT tool-less zero, but it isn't a deal breaker with being able to set the zero stop where-ever you want on the NF. I run a 6.5CM zero and all other calibers are offset from that.
3.) I have yet been able to take advantage of the NF's 25-35 mag range living in the Southeast.
4.) NF's glass is on par w/ Alpha scopes, although I feel the TT had superior mirage control compared to the NF and this is what I miss the most.
5.) I really dig the MIL-C. I really wanted/needed 0.2 MIL windage subtensions w/ the Gen2XR. If TT ever made a GEN2XR w/ 0.2mil windage sub-tensions it would be my favorite reticle. The Gen2XR is super clean and unobtrusive.
6.) Above x25-27 magnification the CA starts to present itself on the NF. I have tested this in a number of conditions and it always comes out somewhere above x25 and is really apparent at x35.
7.) Points 8-9 I agree
8.) I havn't had to use CS and this scope has not been abused yet.
In summary, the NF 7-35 isnt going anywhere, the prices you can get the for now are awesome, and I would have a hard time paying $1800 more for a TT. I would still like to pick up another TT, later down the road when funds permit.