Re: Barrett MRAD or AI AX308
I'm biased - I have owned AI rifles for getting on for 10 years...currently 6 years into my AW .308. Never had it go wrong, built like a tank and just keeps on doing it's thing. I'd not hesitate to recommend them.
Some thoughts added to your post below;
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Alitis</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I appreciate the help. The AI rifles seem to be pretty top notch and changing out barrels seems to be simple.
Is it safe to assume zero is maintained unless I change caliber and/or barrel length?
<span style="color: #3366FF">Check out Scott's demo vid( a bit old and AW related) but still impressive:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKrLnxRxNAI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yByVGTPZvoE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=decFcYCTH28</span>
I've opted for the 20" barrel on the AX as I plan to add a Surefire suppressor down the line once I escape to a free state and I want to keep the rifle somewhat compact. I like the ability of the MRAD to change barrels quickly without needing a vise or additional specialized tools other than a torque wrench, and when Barrett does release the kits, then I can add 308. The problem is when they'll release them and I'll be restricted to 3 calibers only so I'd still need a custom barrel to add something like 260. I can deal with the cost of ammo for now as I do plan to start reloading as well but I like to have more options available. Can anyone using the MRAD comment regarding its reliability, accuracy and return to zero? I'm trying to narrow down the pros and cons of both and decide whether I should stick with my AX order or switch to the MRAD.
AX 308
Pros
Cheaper caliber
accurate and reliable
relatively easy barrel change
quick adjust LOP, Cheek piece and butt spike
slightly lighter than MRAD (but in different caliber)
Cons
more expensive rifle (Over 6k with LE discount versus around 5k for MRAD)
extra tools and custom barrel needed to change to other short action calibers
restricted to short action calibers only
expensive magazines
Barrett MRAD
Pros
cheaper rifle
torque wrench to change barrels (faster than the AX) <span style="color: #3333FF">If this is not for duty/service use, is speed an issue?</span>
long and short action calibers (when available).. <span style="color: #3366FF"> </span> adjustable LOP and knob for cheek piece <span style="color: #3333FF">AI also provide push adjustment on both as an option</span>
Cons
Expensive caliber
No caliber kits available yet (308 in short action only) <span style="color: #3333FF">..again "yet"? </span>
No butt spike
<span style="color: #3366FF">Unknown </span>reliability
<span style="color: #3366FF">Unknown</span> accuracy
<span style="color: #3366FF">Unknown</span> repeat zero if barrel is removed and reinstalled. </div></div>
For me you've pretty much built the case for the AI right there.......available now, no vague promises without definite due dates...and proven beyond doubt to be a reliable and accurate. The list of "unknowns" you mention for the Barrett are (IMHO) the most important deciders when buying a rifle.
And I'd guess the resale value of an AI would hold up very well against a Barrett? Not that you'd really want to sell it once you have it
I know I've not lost money against my AW, in fact I could probably sell it for more than I paid for it right now.....
Whatever you choose, good luck!
If it was me I'd stick with the AX or look for a good second hand AW if the budget is a little tight.