Disclaimer: I will apologize up front for this going long. I know we all like short posts, but this will not be one of those.
Don’t really want to reload anymore but I have so much once fired brass now that reloading is pulling back me in!
Dispensers are not necessarily time savers (some take 45-seconds to dispense a load), nor necessarily more accurate than other methods, but there is some worth just for convenience.
I’m old. Been shooting since I was eight, probably before a lot of you were born. Back in my reloading days we all used beam scales. They worked just fine. Accuracy was great. I did tens of thousands of reloads back then, one at time for rifle accuracy and progressive presses for volume shotgun competition shooting.
The title says it all. However, being “anal”, as in an analyst by profession, and having searched the site for all posts relating to this topic, I still don’t have valid answer to my questions:
We now have dispensers going from say $300 to $2000. Do they really make a difference? I’d say yes for convenience sake so let’s say they do. However, is the price difference between them worth a .05 or so grain accuracy?
Lots of questions.
How good is good enough? What is the difference in a .05 grain charge variability in actual vertical dispersion results? Except for aerodynamic jump, at 100 yards, where we all initially test, the powder charge should have no other influence. So how much vertical dispersion will a .05 grain charge have? Is it worth a $2K? $700? or a $300 machine?
And I have a lot to say about powders. I’ll leave it at this: Extrusion powders have a variance in the length of the stick. Ball powders have a variance in the size of the ball. What happens when you throw a charge that happens to have only the smaller sticks or balls? It burns quicker. Does that affect results. You bet ya.
Am I wrong to assume that? Don’t think so…
Is 100th of a grain (.01) significant in accuracy? Forget that, I’ll say no until proven otherwise,
How about a 10th of a grain.(.1)? That’s a more valid question. Does anyone know for a fact that this makes a difference? As in LOTS of shots to prove that?
See what am I getting at? There are so many other variables in reloading, rifles, and the person behind the trigger that it makes me think those small variations would be lost in the “noise”. And right out of my pocket… If so I’ll go for the $300 dispenser…
I’d love to see valid data if any of you have any. If you don’t then it’s no issue. just disregard this post. I will eventually find the truth on my own. Just trying to save time, at 68 years of age, my extremely valuable time!
All the Best, and Happy New Year!
Don’t really want to reload anymore but I have so much once fired brass now that reloading is pulling back me in!
Dispensers are not necessarily time savers (some take 45-seconds to dispense a load), nor necessarily more accurate than other methods, but there is some worth just for convenience.
I’m old. Been shooting since I was eight, probably before a lot of you were born. Back in my reloading days we all used beam scales. They worked just fine. Accuracy was great. I did tens of thousands of reloads back then, one at time for rifle accuracy and progressive presses for volume shotgun competition shooting.
The title says it all. However, being “anal”, as in an analyst by profession, and having searched the site for all posts relating to this topic, I still don’t have valid answer to my questions:
We now have dispensers going from say $300 to $2000. Do they really make a difference? I’d say yes for convenience sake so let’s say they do. However, is the price difference between them worth a .05 or so grain accuracy?
Lots of questions.
How good is good enough? What is the difference in a .05 grain charge variability in actual vertical dispersion results? Except for aerodynamic jump, at 100 yards, where we all initially test, the powder charge should have no other influence. So how much vertical dispersion will a .05 grain charge have? Is it worth a $2K? $700? or a $300 machine?
And I have a lot to say about powders. I’ll leave it at this: Extrusion powders have a variance in the length of the stick. Ball powders have a variance in the size of the ball. What happens when you throw a charge that happens to have only the smaller sticks or balls? It burns quicker. Does that affect results. You bet ya.
Am I wrong to assume that? Don’t think so…
Is 100th of a grain (.01) significant in accuracy? Forget that, I’ll say no until proven otherwise,
How about a 10th of a grain.(.1)? That’s a more valid question. Does anyone know for a fact that this makes a difference? As in LOTS of shots to prove that?
See what am I getting at? There are so many other variables in reloading, rifles, and the person behind the trigger that it makes me think those small variations would be lost in the “noise”. And right out of my pocket… If so I’ll go for the $300 dispenser…
I’d love to see valid data if any of you have any. If you don’t then it’s no issue. just disregard this post. I will eventually find the truth on my own. Just trying to save time, at 68 years of age, my extremely valuable time!
All the Best, and Happy New Year!