I've tested the Sidewinder and Hellfire back to back on a Dasher. Just threw it on a barricade and fired a few shots for a seat of the pants impression, swapped back and forth between the brakes a few times. Sidewinder did have a touch less recoil and jump, not a drastic difference thouch. Also had more back pressure and felt louder.
I shot one match with the Sidewinder and didn't do great, I got kinda jumpy and slapped the trigger a lot. Went back to the Hellfire and did much better the next two matches. Might have been the brake, maybe just my mental state. I can be a touch sensitive to blast/noise and I have to work to maintain a true zero movement trigger pull with no anticipation or flinch, so that's why I'm exploring different brake options. I've not given up on the Sidewinder yet either, will probably give it another try when I compare Hellfire and Heathen brakes.
I also don't really like muzzle blast etc.. I've swithed between my 419, APA and Heathen several times on the same rifle trying to figre out what I like the best.
• I like the looks and small size the best of the Heathen especially on my hunting rifle
• The reticle - free-recoiling to test stays on target a bit better with the Hellfire than both
* Hard to go wrong with the APA -- Had some weird groups with the 419 not sure what that was about