-
Having trouble using the site?
Contact support
cleaning rods
- Thread starter micmo
- Start date
Re: cleaning rods
I picked up a Dewey because I had a gift card. But given the option I would have gone with Tipton's Carbon Fiber Rods. Either way they both work great.
I picked up a Dewey because I had a gift card. But given the option I would have gone with Tipton's Carbon Fiber Rods. Either way they both work great.
Re: cleaning rods
Dewey Coated.
As often as I clean, I am sure a stainless one piece would not be a problem. I just don't like running steel on steel.
Dewey Coated.
As often as I clean, I am sure a stainless one piece would not be a problem. I just don't like running steel on steel.
Re: cleaning rods
The CF rods are known for dropping the thread sections or not being lined up. It's not like only one or two have had the issue either.
Stainless does no harm. Coated if you must but it picks up abrasives.
Use a bore guide!
The CF rods are known for dropping the thread sections or not being lined up. It's not like only one or two have had the issue either.
Stainless does no harm. Coated if you must but it picks up abrasives.
Use a bore guide!
Re: cleaning rods
Why isn't brass or aluminum or some other softish metal used for these? Brass or copper coated would seem to be ideal, no? I would still use a bore guide, cause when I finally clean the bore, I want to take the copper out, not put more in there..
Why isn't brass or aluminum or some other softish metal used for these? Brass or copper coated would seem to be ideal, no? I would still use a bore guide, cause when I finally clean the bore, I want to take the copper out, not put more in there..
Re: cleaning rods
Dewey coated with a good bore guide. I have been told that the softer metals like brass and aluminum hold some grit and act as more of an abrasive than the dewey steel rods with the black plastic coating. Better bore protection.
Dewey coated with a good bore guide. I have been told that the softer metals like brass and aluminum hold some grit and act as more of an abrasive than the dewey steel rods with the black plastic coating. Better bore protection.
Re: cleaning rods
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: PGS</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Bore Tech coated. </div></div>
+1, Thier bore guides are great also.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: PGS</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Bore Tech coated. </div></div>
+1, Thier bore guides are great also.
Re: cleaning rods
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Unknown</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Dewey coated with a good bore guide. I have been told that the softer metals like brass and aluminum hold some grit and act as more of an abrasive than the dewey steel rods with the black plastic coating. Better bore protection. </div></div>
Ah, good to know.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Unknown</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Dewey coated with a good bore guide. I have been told that the softer metals like brass and aluminum hold some grit and act as more of an abrasive than the dewey steel rods with the black plastic coating. Better bore protection. </div></div>
Ah, good to know.
Re: cleaning rods
Well, coated still embed just like the other soft ones. IF you wipe it a lot and don't drop it then it may not matter.
Boresnakes are shit, pushing an abrasive rope through the barrel is not a good idea. If anyone wants to know about cleaning have a look at what the accuracy guys do and step backk from that point to find your happy medium. For many that happy medium is more about feeling they are doing something instead of actually doing it
Well, coated still embed just like the other soft ones. IF you wipe it a lot and don't drop it then it may not matter.
Boresnakes are shit, pushing an abrasive rope through the barrel is not a good idea. If anyone wants to know about cleaning have a look at what the accuracy guys do and step backk from that point to find your happy medium. For many that happy medium is more about feeling they are doing something instead of actually doing it
Re: cleaning rods
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Unknown</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Dewey coated with a good bore guide. I have been told that the softer metals like brass and aluminum hold some grit and act as more of an abrasive than the dewey steel rods with the black plastic coating. Better bore protection. </div></div>
How would brass and aluminium hold grit and plastic not? That said I do use a Dewey coated rod for my .22 and think it's a great rod but I also wipe the rod after each pass just in case. Going to try one of the Tipton carbon rods next for the new .308
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Unknown</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Dewey coated with a good bore guide. I have been told that the softer metals like brass and aluminum hold some grit and act as more of an abrasive than the dewey steel rods with the black plastic coating. Better bore protection. </div></div>
How would brass and aluminium hold grit and plastic not? That said I do use a Dewey coated rod for my .22 and think it's a great rod but I also wipe the rod after each pass just in case. Going to try one of the Tipton carbon rods next for the new .308
Re: cleaning rods
IMHO On cleaning unless you are going for super accuracy then dont worry about what kind of rod to use or bore snake. Just clean the rifle when needed and be sure to get all the dirt and crude out. I have used a bore snake for years and brass cleaning rods and steel ones just be careful not to ram it down the inside of the barrel dragging against the riflings. I have yet to miss a shot yet on any hunts i have been on... and my 10fp still groups better than i can shot
IMHO On cleaning unless you are going for super accuracy then dont worry about what kind of rod to use or bore snake. Just clean the rifle when needed and be sure to get all the dirt and crude out. I have used a bore snake for years and brass cleaning rods and steel ones just be careful not to ram it down the inside of the barrel dragging against the riflings. I have yet to miss a shot yet on any hunts i have been on... and my 10fp still groups better than i can shot
Re: cleaning rods
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: DP425</div><div class="ubbcode-body">In actual fact, the downside to brass and aluminum is oxidation which is harder than the steel in your barrel. It has nothing to do with holding grit.</div></div>
Interesting...
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: DP425</div><div class="ubbcode-body">In actual fact, the downside to brass and aluminum is oxidation which is harder than the steel in your barrel. It has nothing to do with holding grit.</div></div>
Interesting...
Re: cleaning rods
Maybe I'm missing the point but if you're cleaning properly using a bore guide, the rod should not contact the barrel anyway.
Maybe I'm missing the point but if you're cleaning properly using a bore guide, the rod should not contact the barrel anyway.
Re: cleaning rods
Yes, you are missing something. The Rod will still contact. Bore guides protect the throat.
If you have an accurate barrel clean it with good equipment.
Anyone here think Carbon is harder than oxidation?
It is
Glass is also reasonably abrasive don't you think?
All of them are used for abrasives so either way you don't want an embedding rod do you?
When you clean, clean properly.
Bore Snakes have a place and it's not for regular cleaning.
Yes, you are missing something. The Rod will still contact. Bore guides protect the throat.
If you have an accurate barrel clean it with good equipment.
Anyone here think Carbon is harder than oxidation?
It is
All of them are used for abrasives so either way you don't want an embedding rod do you?
When you clean, clean properly.
Bore Snakes have a place and it's not for regular cleaning.
Re: cleaning rods
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: AUJohn</div><div class="ubbcode-body">
Anyone here think Carbon is harder than oxidation?
It is
</div></div>
Aluminum Oxide (what forms on the outside of an aluminum cleaning rod) is actually considerably harder/more abrasive than carbon fouling. Cannot tell you for sure what the results of copper oxide are for hardness. After-all, it is the copper oxidizing in the brass.
But that doesn't seem to really matter to your ultimate point- use the correct, and best tools for the job.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: AUJohn</div><div class="ubbcode-body">
Anyone here think Carbon is harder than oxidation?
It is
Aluminum Oxide (what forms on the outside of an aluminum cleaning rod) is actually considerably harder/more abrasive than carbon fouling. Cannot tell you for sure what the results of copper oxide are for hardness. After-all, it is the copper oxidizing in the brass.
But that doesn't seem to really matter to your ultimate point- use the correct, and best tools for the job.
Re: cleaning rods
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: furtaker_.223</div><div class="ubbcode-body">+1 for tipton... </div></div>
+2 for tipton and a Lucas bore guide.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: furtaker_.223</div><div class="ubbcode-body">+1 for tipton... </div></div>
+2 for tipton and a Lucas bore guide.
Similar threads
Gunsmithing
Oil Cleaning Rod Bearings?
