Yes, it depends upon your goals. I want EVERY piece of brass that I reload to fit into the gun I am shooting- no questions asked. I found that was not the case when using the hornady custom die I have, even with not-insbustantial cam-over on my RCBS rock chucker press. I bought the case gauge after finding that some loaded rounds chambered with excessive force, and the fired cases extracted with even more excessive force.
Running through 100 rounds of full length sized (with cam-over), but not loaded hornady brass I had on hand, in excess of 10% of them chambered with excessive force in my rifle, and a few I could not close the bolt on. This is in a Ruger precision rifle- a factory rifle I would not expect to have an overly tight match chamber. A larger fraction did not fully seat into the case gauge. Switching to the RCBS die, which I had bought prior to buying the hornady die, alleviated the issue- everything fits in the gauge and everything chambers easily in my rifle. Using the case gauge insures that EVERY piece of brass will chamber and extract, and is much easier than running the brass through the rifle to find the same thing. I don't anneal and accept short brass life as a product of MY reloading process. And, I am reloading brass reclaimed from hornady factory match ammunition- so I have already eaten the cost.
The issue brought up in the thread (by a different member) I alluded to earlier was as I've described above. A Hornady custom die was not sizing brass sufficiently, even with cam-over on the press. This is a die issue. It is also an issue that I have read Hornady will readily fix, so I'm not bagging on Hornady or trying to elevate the RCBS die above it's station (its not a custom match uber die)- it was in my stash of stuff so it is getting used.
I accept that I am not sizing brass "the right way," ie the way that maximizes brass life. It is, however, the way described in every die user manual and reloading manual I've read- though I haven't read them all. That's good enough for me.
PRS Shooter: Spends $1000s on a rifle, $1000s on a scope, $1000s on match entry fees and airfare and hotel accommodations. Spends 45 minutes on every stage to find 1 $0.50 piece of brass...