Gen 3 Razor vs Mark 5

fvalmostthere

fvalmostthere

Private
Full Member
Minuteman
Mar 27, 2014
163
44
#1
Looking into upgrading from my sig tango 6. I love the scope and sig customer service has been great but I find myself seeing the need for .2 or .25 wind holds. I have a euro optic vortex cert so I could get the razor for 2250 after tax but I could also sell that and get the mark 5 for cheaper. Is the razor any better? I have 2 strike eagles on my 22 and practice gun so razor kinda makes sense but I like the pr2 reticle a little more myself. Is the glass and quality comparable? Thanks in advance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SD3Gunner
#5
Love my gen 3. I liked my mk5 a lot but the razor is optically better. I had the 5-25 though. I’ve heard the 7-35 is pretty darn good. The turrets are definitely something that vortex needs to fix. I’ve had a couple problems with it slipping down on me and the feel on the gen 2 is superior….to me anyway.
 
Last edited:
#8
DeathBeforeDismount said:
Until vortex fixes the turret issues with the Gen 3, its not even tier 2, which is where it would be. Lots of good optics in the 2-3K price range.
Click to expand...
The turrets are definitely not great but the glass alone makes it at least tier 2 basically tier 1. Last 3 matches in actual use the turrets haven’t held me back. Running turret dialing tests vs my TT, mk5, ZCO, and Kahles DLR the timing was about the same. Sure the feel isn’t great but it doesn’t actually hold you back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5RWill, Lunchbox27 and Glassaholic
#10
DeathBeforeDismount said:
Thats the problem. Unit to unit variation is all over the place. Some are garbage and some are acceptable. Even the good ones and the "fixed" ones that had to be sent back to vortex, don't feel as good as the Gen 2 razor's turrets.

For a $3K optic, that is unacceptable.
Click to expand...
Yea but the fact that you can get these for far less than that without really trying it’s the best optic under $3k. I mean shit the 30% euro certs are out there like Candy. For $2100 there’s no optic close to the razor at that price.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SD3Gunner
#13
Covertnoob5 said:
Yea but the fact that you can get these for far less than that without really trying it’s the best optic under $3k. I mean shit the 30% euro certs are out there like Candy. For $2100 there’s no optic close to the razor at that price.
Click to expand...
Burris XTR Pro?
Probably not enough of them in the wild yet for the comparison to have been made.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: D_TROS and 1911hombre
#16
Seems like the gen 3 glass is better reading the comments, but the turrets kind of
suck. How bad are they? Have a club match this weekend hoping I can find one of each on the line and take a peak through them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Islas82
#17
fvalmostthere said:
Seems like the gen 3 glass is better reading the comments, but the turrets kind of
suck. How bad are they? Have a club match this weekend hoping I can find one of each on the line and take a peak through them.
Click to expand...
They were bad enough for me to sell it but am a bit of a turret slut so take that into consideration. Optically is very very good though, very close to my ZCO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeathBeforeDismount and 5RWill
#19
Islas82 said:
They were bad enough for me to sell it but am a bit of a turret slut so take that into consideration. Optically is very very good though, very close to my ZCO.
Click to expand...
Agreed, they're lacking. Better once I sent it off to Vortex and now got it mounted. I just posted a video in the razor thread but it's a step backwards from the Gen II. It's comparable to my NXS, which is not bad by any means but not up to today's standard for a $3000 optic.

Optically speaking it's the best glass for the money on the market bar none, even more so when you pick up the phone for what they can be had at.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeathBeforeDismount
#20
5RWill said:
Agreed, they're lacking. Better once I sent it off to Vortex and now got it mounted. I just posted a video in the razor thread but it's a step backwards from the Gen II. It's comparable to my NXS, which is not bad by any means but not up to today's standard for a $3000 optic.

Optically speaking it's the best glass for the money on the market bar none, even more so when you pick up the phone for what they can be had at.
Click to expand...
Sounds good, I have a cert so 2250 after tax and shipping. But my original thought was to sell the cert and use that to make the mark 5 even cheaper but it seems it’s not really a contest. And for what I already have invested into this sport what’s another $600
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5RWill and Im2bent
#21
Covertnoob5 said:
Yea but the fact that you can get these for far less than that without really trying it’s the best optic under $3k. I mean shit the 30% euro certs are out there like Candy. For $2100 there’s no optic close to the razor at that price.
Click to expand...
So this is not a derailment as the op has made his decision let me ask whats up with this I see these certs in the px a lot. Where is everybody gettting these things asking for a friend.
 
#23
fvalmostthere said:
Sounds good, I have a cert so 2250 after tax and shipping. But my original thought was to sell the cert and use that to make the mark 5 even cheaper but it seems it’s not really a contest. And for what I already have invested into this sport what’s another $600
Click to expand...
I think you’re making the right choice. I’ve had a mark 5 and i truthfully love the mark 5. Matter of fact I’m waiting on leupold to put the PR2 in the 3.6-18x44. But leupold is gonna leupold. But it’s not in the same realm as the Gen III. Turrets are better than the Gen III but that’s it.
 
#24
I've shot my gen3 rzr in 4 matches this year with plenty of movement on 2 min par times. I dial elevation and since switching from mk5hd to gen3, I dial wind. Never have the turrets been an issue. 90 second stage perhaps. But I wouldn't Dial wind there. Mk5hd windage turret hash mark, knowing where you're at is a fn joke. Basically it's a wind hold ONLY scope in any kind of time constraints, MY OPINION. Gen3 razr glass is as good/maybe better than zp5 minox, and 7-35 atacr in my personal scope comparisons. The depth of field, eyebox and field of view Smoke the mark5. You also get way more dial available. In my 20moa base, i have 25 mils of elevation on tap. Clarity is excellent. I owned and sold 3 xtr3, and never found a lot that i liked about them, maybe pro has glass with less blueish color tint, I never could quite get the diopter/parallax set correctly to perfectly focus reticle/target with no parallax present on either 3.3-18, the 5.5-30 I was able to. The Burris xtr3 does have good glass clarity though its sharp. The compactness of the 3.3-18, clarity, locking diopter, and available elevation with good scr2 reticle were the only good points of it I found. I paid close to 1200-1400 for them, and i felt the glass competed a lil better than price point, but the rest is what you paid for mid level optic with meat grinder knobs/turrets.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BigRiver2016
#25
Mk5hd windage turret hash mark, knowing where you're at is a fn joke. Basically it's a wind hold ONLY scope in any kind of time constraints
Click to expand...

I have a Mk5 3-18 and I like it for what I paid (1600 from BDU), but I completely agree with this. Putting the wind hash indicator off-center was a fucking stupid "look at me! I'm different!" thing to do and whoever signed off on it should get their ass handed to them.
 
#26
Covertnoob5 said:
It’s not even close. Mk5 is good for its price range at sub $2k. But the razor 3 is definitely tier 1.
Click to expand...
the only Leupold i'd buy is the Mark 8 becasue it the only one that has exposed tactical turrents including windage, all the rest are capped, i can't figure it as only them and Nightforce do that, and i don't buy the BS about oooohhh bumping it in the woods, my ass, i've never had my windage off, That said I own all Vortex, plus their warranties are insane, I tripped and dropped a brand new optic on the tile floor and messed up two of the turrets, I called for price they said none, emailed an overnight label to me, fixed in 1 day and overnighted back free of charge. and personally i think leupold and nightforce are living on namesake, the high end Vortex stuff is everybit as good, the only other scope i'm drooling for is a March, as they supposedly have about the best glass of any manufacturer or at the least as good as any big buck offering. and they have the highest magnification in the world to date and it would be way cool to have an 8x-80x56, since i can't see shit at max distance with the ever popular 5-25x50 or 56 offerings of others. and not bad at $3100
 
  • Like
Reactions: aku
#27
ebbiv said:
the only Leupold i'd buy is the Mark 8 becasue it the only one that has exposed tactical turrents including windage, all the rest are capped, i can't figure it as only them and Nightforce do that, and i don't buy the BS about oooohhh bumping it in the woods, my ass, i've never had my windage off, That said I own all Vortex, plus their warranties are insane, I tripped and dropped a brand new optic on the tile floor and messed up two of the turrets, I called for price they said none, emailed an overnight label to me, fixed in 1 day and overnighted back free of charge. and personally i think leupold and nightforce are living on namesake, the high end Vortex stuff is everybit as good, the only other scope i'm drooling for is a March, as they supposedly have about the best glass of any manufacturer or at the least as good as any big buck offering. and they have the highest magnification in the world to date and it would be way cool to have an 8x-80x56, since i can't see shit at max distance with the ever popular 5-25x50 or 56 offerings of others. and not bad at $3100
Click to expand...
The mark 8 isn’t optically what the mark 5 is. The mark 5 is the best scope Leupold makes. The capped Wind is a a competitor request because on barricades or other things it can happen. I’ve seen it. And not many people need or want exposed windage cause especially in PRS most people aren’t dialing wind.
The March high master glass is their top of the line. If it’s a non high master scope then it’s not their top glass. 8-80 sounds cool, but 40x-80x is gonna be tough to use in mirage. I suppose it depends on where and what kinda shooting you do with it though.
The mark 5 and NF 7-35 are legitimately good scopes. There’s not really a full featured 5-25 scope in the same weight category as a MK5. And the 7-35 is very good at most everything. TT and Kahles are also uncapped windage as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tperry, Paradox and SepticDeath
#29
That was per leupold they said if you have the means get the 8 especially since capped turrets are just an afterthought for those that run into stuff. So maybe ill just get all the major scopes and have one for every day of the week, last time it was motorcycles and managed 10 so technically lol
 
#30
ebbiv said:
the only Leupold i'd buy is the Mark 8 becasue it the only one that has exposed tactical turrents including windage, all the rest are capped, i can't figure it as only them and Nightforce do that, and i don't buy the BS about oooohhh bumping it in the woods, my ass, i've never had my windage off, That said I own all Vortex, plus their warranties are insane, I tripped and dropped a brand new optic on the tile floor and messed up two of the turrets, I called for price they said none, emailed an overnight label to me, fixed in 1 day and overnighted back free of charge. and personally i think leupold and nightforce are living on namesake, the high end Vortex stuff is everybit as good, the only other scope i'm drooling for is a March, as they supposedly have about the best glass of any manufacturer or at the least as good as any big buck offering. and they have the highest magnification in the world to date and it would be way cool to have an 8x-80x56, since i can't see shit at max distance with the ever popular 5-25x50 or 56 offerings of others. and not bad at $3100
Click to expand...

So leave the cap off? It's not like they put a slot adjustable turret under the cap, you can leave it off and dial all you want.
I had a vortex roll a few revs catching the edge of the gun case. That was the end of it for me. They will all lock or be capped if they go on my rifle.



I got to play with a 6-36 Gen 3 the other day. It's damn nice but the contrast was excessive. It looks good for a minute, then my eye gets tired of it.
If they had a cooler look to the glass I'd be looking for one. The super warm image just isn't what my eyes/brain like.
 
#31
i was just seeking a reason i can only assume those that run capped windage rely soley on the reticle to compensate after the initial zeroing at setup. That said i know its top notch stuff just wondered why they’re the only two olayers doing it with know ability to explain why. They did send me a buch of photos of the uncapped look complete with measurements if cap thickness etc. that said i just thought it should be an option when buying a component that gererslly can be 2x the price of the gun.
 
#32
ebbiv said:
i was just seeking a reason i can only assume those that run capped windage rely soley on the reticle to compensate after the initial zeroing at setup. That said i know its top notch stuff just wondered why they’re the only two olayers doing it with know ability to explain why. They did send me a buch of photos of the uncapped look complete with measurements if cap thickness etc. that said i just thought it should be an option when buying a component that gererslly can be 2x the price of the gun.
Click to expand...
They’re not the only 2 without capped windage.
 
#33
Covertnoob5 said:
They’re not the only 2 without capped windage.
Click to expand...
To clarify i was referring to the most well known and Tactical only, I know hunting stuff is most always capped, its more simple curiosity as neither Leupold nor NF can tell you, the is I don't know lol. for quality compared to the other big players, US Optics, Steiner, March, Kahles or anything else when you get in the 3-6000 range. and can anyone honestly say they can see a measurable difference at that level, heck Paul Phillips made that world record 7070 yard shot with a NF ATACR 7-35x56, not sure what that pic looks like, hell i've got uncorrected 20x20 and can't see shit at a thousand, i just wonder for the average enthusiest were the line between a sensible quality optic and another thats based on a price tag to impress. Whats your opinion?
 
#37
b6graham said:
if you're paying $3k for a gen 3 you're dumb
Click to expand...
That wasn't the point, point was where do you think the line is between price vs performance, My assumption is providing the optic is in line, that a skilled shooter won't shoot any better with a $4000 Steiner than he will with a $1800 NF, the question is what do you think is the best scope regardless of price. I'm guess more isn't always better
 
#38
ebbiv said:
That wasn't the point, point was where do you think the line is between price vs performance, My assumption is providing the optic is in line, that a skilled shooter won't shoot any better with a $4000 Steiner than he will with a $1800 NF, the question is what do you think is the best scope regardless of price. I'm guess more isn't always better
Click to expand...
right but compare a $1200 XTR3 to a $2400 razor gen 3

i'd still take the razor...

but that $2400 razor competes with $2500-$3600 scopes (Leopold, Kahles, NF) all day

you have to damn near double the cost or more of a razor gen 3 to get to ZCO and TT level
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5RWill, 4O6shootist and kampr
#40
ebbiv said:
To clarify i was referring to the most well known and Tactical only, I know hunting stuff is most always capped, its more simple curiosity as neither Leupold nor NF can tell you, the is I don't know lol. for quality compared to the other big players, US Optics, Steiner, March, Kahles or anything else when you get in the 3-6000 range. and can anyone honestly say they can see a measurable difference at that level, heck Paul Phillips made that world record 7070 yard shot with a NF ATACR 7-35x56, not sure what that pic looks like, hell i've got uncorrected 20x20 and can't see shit at a thousand, i just wonder for the average enthusiest were the line between a sensible quality optic and another thats based on a price tag to impress. Whats your opinion?
Click to expand...
Kahles and TT are not capped.
 
#41
True, I read an article and it broke down what scopes the top pros use and the NF ATACR 7-35x56 was first by a large margin, then Kahels, with Vortex third and Scmidt & Bender 4th what surprised me is that Leupold was 3rd to last and 6 spots below bushnell which I always thought was a bargain brand. I own Vortex stuff and like it, I always searched around and got open box deals to save a buck, but i'm any NF owner will alwasy bust your balls. You know the attitude, your vette might spank some Ferrari but at the end of the day its still a Vette. Any heres the link its interesting.

precisionrifleblog.com

Best Scope – What The Pros Use

I recently surveyed the top ranked shooters in both the Precision Rifle Series (PRS) and the Nationa...
precisionrifleblog.com precisionrifleblog.com
 
#42
ebbiv said:
True, I read an article and it broke down what scopes the top pros use and the NF ATACR 7-35x56 was first by a large margin, then Kahels, with Vortex third and Scmidt & Bender 4th what surprised me is that Leupold was 3rd to last and 6 spots below bushnell which I always thought was a bargain brand. I own Vortex stuff and like it, I always searched around and got open box deals to save a buck, but i'm any NF owner will alwasy bust your balls. You know the attitude, your vette might spank some Ferrari but at the end of the day its still a Vette. Any heres the link its interesting.

precisionrifleblog.com

Best Scope – What The Pros Use

I recently surveyed the top ranked shooters in both the Precision Rifle Series (PRS) and the Nationa...
precisionrifleblog.com precisionrifleblog.com
Click to expand...
2018...
 
  • Like
Reactions: SepticDeath, 1791PrecisionArmory and CSTactical
#43
ebbiv said:
True, I read an article and it broke down what scopes the top pros use and the NF ATACR 7-35x56 was first by a large margin, then Kahels, with Vortex third and Scmidt & Bender 4th what surprised me is that Leupold was 3rd to last and 6 spots below bushnell which I always thought was a bargain brand. I own Vortex stuff and like it, I always searched around and got open box deals to save a buck, but i'm any NF owner will alwasy bust your balls. You know the attitude, your vette might spank some Ferrari but at the end of the day its still a Vette. Any heres the link its interesting.

precisionrifleblog.com

Best Scope – What The Pros Use

I recently surveyed the top ranked shooters in both the Precision Rifle Series (PRS) and the Nationa...
precisionrifleblog.com precisionrifleblog.com
Click to expand...
It’s from 2018 and a terrible way to judge scopes lol the landscape has changed a lot since then. ZCO for example would be very well represented high on that list today.
That list is more about who has the largest marketing budget because all those shooters are sponsored. In terms of marketing power it isn’t too far off.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JakeM, b6graham, kampr and 1 other person
#44
Covertnoob5 said:
It’s from 2018 and a terrible way to judge scopes lol the landscape has changed a lot since then. ZCO for example would be very well represented high on that list today.
That list is more about who has the largest marketing budget because all those shooters are sponsored. In terms of marketing power it isn’t too far off.
Click to expand...

Yeah 2019 when ZCO came out definitely changed the scope market big time...
 
#45
Covertnoob5 said:
It’s from 2018 and a terrible way to judge scopes lol the landscape has changed a lot since then. ZCO for example would be very well represented high on that list today.
That list is more about who has the largest marketing budget because all those shooters are sponsored. In terms of marketing power it isn’t too far off.
Click to expand...
Do they use off the shelf unmodified units or purpose built with the better glass etc or is it like the old moto cross days when your honda was $1500 and the factory guys bike was Hand built $80000 exotic.
 
#48
ebbiv said:
Do they use off the shelf unmodified units or purpose built with the better glass etc or is it like the old moto cross days when your honda was $1500 and the factory guys bike was Hand built $80000 exotic
Click to expand...
I mean they’re using the same ones you can buy. Are their’s double spot checked by 3 different people before it leaves? Sure probably. Last thing you want is a sponsored guy with a scope that doesn’t track or the glass isn’t up to standard. But I’ve seen it happen too lol kinda funny when it does.
 
#50
Covertnoob5 said:
I mean they’re using the same ones you can buy. Are their’s double spot checked by 3 different people before it leaves? Sure probably. Last thing you want is a sponsored guy with a scope that doesn’t track or the glass isn’t up to standard. But I’ve seen it happen too lol kinda funny when it does.
Click to expand...
Yeah im sure i was just curious as its amazing the money a company will spend on a pro for an advantage, i was going to do the Mexican 1000 and ultimately Baja before blowing my knees out, for probably 20 years now Honda has dominated with the CRF 450X which is a trail bike so bought the last 17 model in the country for $5500, and the factory bike is all stock components with a cam change and some tweaks which are around $500 in parts, then I contacted some former riders and while yes virtually stock the prep raises the price tag to over 40k. Stock suspension yes, nut $6000 for custom valving. Stock motor but blueprinted, balanced ported etc. so another 5k there all the way to a xraying the frames so what happened to the stock bike, and dont forget the 20man support team and son. So thsts why i asked. Thought maybe it was a gutted scope chassis filled with exotic stuff what do you have for rifles and optics
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

S
Rifle Scopes Razor gen 3 upgrade
Replies
11
Views
635
4O6shootist
4O6shootist
T
Optics Sig Tango6 5-30x56 MOA scope for sale
Replies
2
Views
195
thall2020
T
J
SOLD Mark 5HD 5-25x56 M5C3 Illum. FFP Tremor 3 w/ MPA BA Bolt Action Mount
Replies
0
Views
142
jmrod0720
J
YotaEer
SOLD Vortex Razor Gen 3, 6-36x MRAD with NLE mod
Replies
3
Views
383
bluebu70
bluebu70
bgoda3
SOLD Gen 2 Razor 4.5-27 Mil
Replies
0
Views
271
bgoda3
bgoda3
Top Bottom
Back
Home
Forums
Merch
Alerts