I'm in your same boat, experience wise.
Apart from reflex/red dots....
In my magnified optics stable I have 3 scopes with illumination, 2 without.
1. Trijicon TA31 RCO-M4. Because its easy to use on a 16" AR, and... nostalgic
2. is a Leupold Mark AR Mod 1 with a green fire-dot. Its a 1.5-4x, second focal plane which, for me does everything I want it to. Its basically a duplex reticle a bright green center dot, with hashes at 2.5 mils then a 10 mil diameter circle. Its great because 10 mils at 200y is 6 feet. Good times. Thats on another AR.
3rd up is my hunting scope which is a Vortex Viper PST Gen II 3-15x44 with illum. I wasn't looking for illum specifically with this optic, but its nice to have so when the colors of the area make it kinda tough to see the reticle, I can crank on the illum to make it stand out compared to the scenery in the shaded areas, or other times/situations of needing to contrast the reticle with the surrounding environment.
I dont have any NV at this time.