A number of people saw it the way I did, including our own revered Glasshole - many threads about it over the years, so I doubt it was my sample. If, however, they had a silent Gen2 roll out, like the 2.5-20, then my comments only apply to Gen1, and I would be interested in seeing the Gen2.
Otherwise, I think it's simply that most people don't have a bunch of glass lined up looking out to 4K yards of mountains, like I did for many years, and the NX8 looked great for the first couple of hundred yards, warm contrast and good resolution. The differences became glaring once you stretched them out, especially in less than ideal conditions.