Re: New gun opinions....glock gen 4 full size
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: GMR</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I am up in the air about buying a new Gen 4 or the XDM. I really cannot make up my mind. I like a few items on the full size XDM but have always been a glock fan.
The biggest thing I dislike about the XDM is the palm safety. </div></div>
I'm completely biased, but this seems like a super-simple decision. I would pick the Glock every time. Every time. I think the XD is a good solid pistol. It is quality, and they are reliable.
That said, the trigger is mush. It does NOT let off clean, it does not positively reset, and once reset, there is a bunch of takeup before you hit the link. The powder river trigger is an improvement, but it doesn't come anywhere near the Glock.
Obviously, trigger feel is a hugely subjective thing. For me, the key elements of a trigger are that it is CONSISTENT from first shot to last (XD does this fine), needs to let-off reasonably cleanly (Glock isn't amazing - but much better than XD), have an obvious reset (Glock's reset is the most positive, obvious, slap-you-in-the-face reset out there), and be "on the link" AT the point of reset.
I like that I can buy Glock mags from Botach tactical for $20/each. XD mags are $35-40.
Another thing I can say about Glock vs. XD is the bore center. The Glock has scrunched the bore down as low as really can be achieved. The XD places the bore pretty high. This DOES make a perceivable difference. My compact Glock 30 has noticeably less muzzle flip than my fullsize XD45 Tactical.
I am also a believer in the Glock grip angle. A 1911 or XD essentially causes you to have your wrist at a 90º angle to your forearm, so that the recoil impulse has the MOST leverage over your wrist joint as possible. Because a Glock forces you to tip your wrist down, this minimizes the leveral the recoil has on your wrist.
Lastly, the grip fatness of the Glock... What can I say? When I first picked up a Glock 30, it felt fat. I have big hands, and even then the G30 felt thick. I felt that I had a much more "commanding" grip on my XD45. Alas, when I analyzed my natural XD grip, I noted the bore was not perfectly inline with my forearm. The natural grip I take on the G30 DOES put the bore inline with my forearm.
Of course, the right pistol for you is a very subjective thing. These are the reasons the right pistol for me is Glock. Maybe keep some of these points in mind and see if they apply to you as well.
All the time, I hear people advise others to "see how the pistols feel in your hand". I contend you can NOT properly choose the pistol for you by simply laying it in your hand and seeing if it feels "good". You MUST shoot them - a fair amount. For me at least, the pistol that "felt best" laying in my hand was NOT the best pistol for me.
I'm fortunate I only had to go through 3 or 4 different pistols before realizing Glock was "it".