So, I love my 5-25 ATACR as well... it is super sharp and the contrast and color on mine is great as well.... I have had a few 4-16s, a 7-35 and I currently run a 4-20 on my work rifle, and my 5-25 is not behind my 4-20 in any way that I have noticed.Yeah man it does look almost like some kind of filter, unfortunately that’s pretty close to exactly what it looks like. I will say this, it’s sharp as hell, it literally has extreme resolution on par with anything I have and that’s pretty extensive, it also has a great dof and the eyebox is pretty forgiving.
My only issue is the color and contrast, it just kind of kills the rest of the good attributes. Again, it’s the bland/flat yellowish view that’s more reminiscent of looking through a car window with a fine film of pollen or dust.
The nx8 by comparison torches it on color and contrast and is a noticeably and immediately brighter scope.
I also have several 5-25 PMIIs, a 5-25 TT, 5-27 ZCO and now a 5-25 Mark 5HD that has yet to get out into the field... My 5-25 is leaps ahead of one of the scopes it replaced a Gen 2 Razor... don't get all the hate it is receiving.