Rifle Scopes NF ATACR, S&B, or Leupold?

4-16 atacr is the ultimate gas gun scope.
I'd buy one off the classifieds.

You won't lose a dime if you don't like it, plus it's arguably the most versatile scope NF makes, so you'll always find a home for it somewhere.

I personally hate really big scopes on gassers- it does strange things with the balance IMO.

16x is plenty for your purposes.

I’m pretty sure the ATACR 4-16, or MK5 3.6-18 will be the direction I’m going to go. The M110 scope was a 3.5-10x40 Leupold MK4, and the ATACR 4-16 and MK5 3.6-18 are an upgrade in every way.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: CaptArab
I currently run and SB 5-25 on my range gun and a SB 5-20 ultra short on my hunting rifle.

SB scopes are really nice. Optical quality is great. However, before I had the SB 5-20 US on my hunting rifle I ran the NF atacr 4-16 x 42 for a couple of years. I don't think the NF gives up much up against the SB 5-20 except in the mag range. Optical qualify is pretty close, but the NF was really easy to get behind and just flat out worked. I hate the rotating eye piece, but that is a minor complaint.

just my experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hammer_Man
Look for reviews and comments by resident optics master @koshkin, aka Dark Lord of Optics, aka ILya. He works with optics for a living and has a good YouTube channel. He recently had a big high-end optics review.

edit: forgot his website: https://opticsthoughts.com/?page_id=52 (also has link to his paid site. I’m not a member.) and he posts here too: http://www.opticstalk.com/

I would give you comparative advice if it had merit, but I’ve never used a S&B or NF.

My random experience: I had a Leupold Mark 5 5-25 with the CCH reticle. Nice scope, nice turrets (like the locking method) but disliked the CCH reticle. Sold it. Have Vortex Razor 4.5-27s because the eyebox and I like the older mrad 2c reticle.

Good luck!
 
Last edited:
Thank you for the shoutout @carbonbased

Just about all scopes mentioned here are good options. Reticles are an individual thing. For someone fairly new to this, I would probably not start with Horus. Aside from my personal dislike for them, when you are new, less is more.

For gas guns, unless it is something really substantial, I tend to stick with scopes that are a little bit on compact side of things. For most long range applications, I think the need for a lot of magnification is a bit overstated. That having been said, if you have a 15 pound gas gun (I have one of those and it has a 5-25x56 TT on it most of the time), it does not matter. If it is something a little more handholdable, I would go with a more compact design.

In the grand scheme of things, something that tops out around 20x or so is a good option and of those the ZCO 4-20x50 is the best one currently available, I think.

S&B has three good options: 3-20x50, 3-20x50US and 5-20x50US, although it tunneling does not bother you much, the original 4-16x44 and 4-16x50 are really nice. The 4-16x44 was one of my favourite scopes ever made.

Nightforce has the excellent 4-16x42 and 4-16x50

March has 3-24x52 and 3-24x42 (I have the 52mm version). There is also a 4.5-28x52, but it is not out yet

Leupold has the Mark 5 3.6-18x44

Steiner's upcoming M7Xi 2.9-20x50 looks promising, but I doubt we will see it in the US before SHOT.

TT has the 3-15x50

Given the mil discount and sub-$3k (I think) budget limitations, both Leupold and Nighforce have a lot to offer. Personally, for a gas gun, it is hard to do better than Mark 5 3.6-18x44 with illuminated TMR if you want a simpler reticle or ATACR F1 4-16x42 with Mil-XT if you want a tree reticle.

ILya
 
  • Like
Reactions: carbonbased
Ive got 2 full seasons on my leupold mark 5 without a single issue. It is a quality optic. that being said, Nightforce and S&B should be the next tier up. Buy once cry once if youve got the resources.
I have over 2000 rounds on my Mark 4 ER/T 4.5-14X50 strapped to my Scar 17S and have had no issues. Just bought a Nightforce due to a great deal. Honestly I think the answer is whoever gives the OP the best deal.
 
You must be at least 18 years of age to use this site
You confirm that you are at least 18 years of age by continuing to use the site.