First of all bud, for HOW MANY folks?
Secondly, have ya'll "hired peons" to do the serving, or is this everyone else's NYE celebration, and you'll get yours on Thursday or so, when you've recuperated?
My vote:
Welli's
Cheese taters
wispride and crackers, I can only imagine that that is Wisconsin Pride ergo "cheese" and crackers. Which, if I'm accurate, then that is a mainstay/staple and always a hit. No matter the level of sobriety of the imbiber.
Pear cider, of course.
Swedish Meatballs slathered in lingonberry sauce.
Herring (rollmops)
Olives
Iberico Jamon
Smoked Salmon
Crackers
Crackers spread with cream-cheese
capers (for those so inclined)
Jalapeno Poppers wrapped in bacon even, for those so inclined.
Set this out buffet-style, with some Sultan ice-sculpture as a centerpiece (helps keep things cool) and you're golden. Relax, enjoy the evening, and just appreciate the camaraderie.