Just picked up the Athlon today. Way better than the lower cost Athlon scopes. I also have a PST Gen 2.
For my eyes.
Glass clarity is the same with a bit brighter color in the PST Gen 2.
Turrets are stiff on the Vortex out of the box but loosened up after a month. Turrets on the Athlon are slick. Many YouTube videos show the fix for this. Clean off the excess grease. Haven’t done it yet, so I can’t say.
Zero stop is great on both. Better than the NF SHV that I have.
Gridded reticle is cleaner in the PST Gen 2. The Athlon reticle looks way better in person than on the web.
Markings on the PST Gen 2 turrets are clearer, but not to the point of the Athlon being worse.
PST Gen 2 came with a sunshade. Athlon did not ($30).
I got my PST Gen 2 for $800ish, happy with that price. Would not pay full retail for that optic.
$550ish for the Athlon and could not be happier.
Can’t box test till this weekend. Barring poor tracking, hands down the Athlon at this time over the PST Gen 2.