rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

black_ump

Gunny Sergeant
Full Member
Minuteman
Jul 16, 2007
1,054
0
40
erie,pa 16334
i watched a video of each of these on youtube, the only advantage i seen to the rcbs is its alot more quite when dispensing the powder other then that the lymen sounded a bit better.

your thoughs ?
any other powder dispencer i should look into other then these two ?
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

MVC-001S-4.jpg
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

in all fairness, the comparison above is outdated. They compare the CM1500 to the Lyman DPSII. The curent unit Lyman offers is the DPS III which is supposed to be faster. But by all reports, its still not as good as the CM1500.
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

ok well what matters to me is accuracy and how quite the unit is when its despensing the powder. that is what matters to me any way

seems the rcbs is quiter then the lyman are their any other units out their like this by other companies ?

seems though that the lyman can store your load data as far as the powder charge goes
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

RCBS stores your data also. One other major drawback to the Lyman is its 30 minute warm-up time. Not that it matters, because most people I know dont turn off their units. My CM1500 has not been turned off since the last power outage.
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

i had this same discussion with Lyman CS and RCBS CS not telling the other i was interested in other products and the lyman does require 30 min to warm up..... RCBS not requiring that....although RCBS is making a lot of crap (presses for sure) in Red China not sure about this but i would probably <span style="text-decoration: underline">get the RCBS </span>ANYWAYS with there CS track record and me sending atleast 15 things back to them just in the last 2 years (they said I have a damn file HAHA).
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: USMCj</div><div class="ubbcode-body">RCBS all the way! Its a better unit, and is faster. </div></div>

Hell yes. I bought the Lyman 1200 first. Had issues with holding its zero point. My weight fluctuates anywhere from 0.2 grains to 0.5 grains. Not good if you are loading at the top of your powder curve. Switched to the RCBS Chargemaster 1500 and never look back.
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

First off, let me preface this with saying I have no experience with the Chargemaster scale. I do own an RCBS 750 electronic scale, which isn't the same.

I do, on the other hand, own a Lyman 1200 DPS 3, and it has been a PITA since the day I took it out of the box. It is extremely sensitive to static electricity, and has a propensity for the zero to wander as much as a couple of tenths to 10gr or more. Occasionally, I have been fortunate enough to get the scale to remain zeroed, but it still isn't quite on. What I mean is, it will generally throw 0.1-0.2gr more than the input weight. So, if you want 24.5gr thrown, you'd better enter 24.3 or it will be off just about everytime. Now, the scale is accurate, and will read the weight correctly. Its just the dispenser drops .1-.2gr too much at times, and you must take this into consideration.

I have been in contact with Lyman customer service, and have tried every recommendation and trick they have suggested. Some fixes work temporarily, but nothing has been a cure all. To say it has been frustrating is an understatement, and the unit is currently at Lyman being checked on.

If I had it to do again, I would avoid it all together. I've found I can use Lee dippers and a powder trickler almost as fast, without the warm up period, and without the aggrivation. In fact, outside of working up loads for a round robin or OCW, the dispenser is borderline useless for me.
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: black_ump</div><div class="ubbcode-body">LOL RCBS IT IS I GUESS </div></div>


+1. Had a 1200. Wouldn't hold zero. RCBS no problems.
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

I've had good luck with other Lyman products, including dies, trimmers, and beam scales. In fact, I have two of their trimmers set up with power adapters for the cordless drill. It seems that all of their products are very good, with the exception of the 1200.

What confuses me is, I have two other electronic scales that never give me any problems. No wandering zeros, no issues with static, nothing. Why is it the Lyman is so sensitive, yet other scales are not?
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

For what it's worth I recently got a DPS 3 and it works great for me so far. As long as you keep it calibrated after moving it even slightly it holds a zero fine and is typically within ± .1 grains if not dead on. I wish you could reprogram it to throw faster like you can for the RCBS, but oh well...
 
Re: rcbs chargemaster 1500 vs lyman 1200

My chargemaster just showed up last night, right as I was finishing case prep for a batch of 308. A quick read of the instructions and I was ready to go...
BEST $300 I EVER SPENT!!!
The new auto mode is awesome - as soon as you put the tray back on the scale and it zeros it starts trickling the next load. There is just enough time to resize, ream, and prime the case and then the charge is ready to drop...I see this DRASTICALLY speeding up my reload process - love it!