Sidearms & Scatterguns Staccato C2 or CS

NewGuy308

Private
Minuteman
Sep 10, 2020
37
4
I torn between a C2 and a CS. I just got a XC and I have an STI Edge so looking for something small to carry concealed. As LEO I can get a good discount on a C2 with 6 mags and optic plates. I still get a discount on the CS, it’s not as good as the C2, but it doesn’t come with the 3 extra mags and optic plates. So is the smaller size on the CS worth that much?
 
Just looking for more inputs. I’m still wondering what the next gen that’s supposedly coming out soon is going to be, hopefully someone has incite on that here.
I hear ya on that. I’m almost in the same boat as you. Recently picked up a P, and threw a PMM comp on it. Breaking all my PRs, so im naturally thinking of what else I can replace.

I carry an xmacro right now. It shoots great, but I’m thinking c2 or cs. Leaning towards the c2, and sending it out to monsoon or skipz for a comp.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 30calDeath
I hear ya on that. I’m almost in the same boat as you. Recently picked up a P, and threw a PMM comp on it. Breaking all my PRs, so im naturally thinking of what else I can replace.

I carry an xmacro right now. It shoots great, but I’m thinking c2 or cs. Leaning towards the c2, and sending it out to monsoon or skipz for a comp.
I have a 43x with a PMM comp and barrel and shield mags that I’m currently carrying, I just like to have options plus I like 1911/2011 triggers way better.
 
I watched a video on youtube and they were saying the CS is a very snappy gun, with lots of recoil. No personal experience but probably go C2. Maybe other posters can talk about the recoil differences between the two? Ive been going back and forth between the 2 guns also. I've come to the conclusion I don't want a 3k carry gun.
 
I’ve had a C2 for a couple years now and when I shot the CS I couldn’t tell the difference at all and immediately ordered one. I’ve always felt the c2 was just a little big for concealed carry, but it’s a great “if you can only have one” gun. I also have a P now so I’m not sure if I’ll keep the c2 once my CS arrives.
 
just as an aside, and i love 1911 pistols….i sure see alot of these pistols for sale on the local used market.

and springfield prodigy’s lately too.
They're not 1911 's, but what's your point? Springfield prodigy is not in the same conversation as staccato either
 
I can't see a nickle's difference in the C2 vs CS.
For any point that the CS is an improvement, the C2 could be considered more shootable IMO.
But it's all negligible. Handgun Hero do t com has a great size comparison feature.
I just can't see enough difference to pick one over the to other.

So for approx $500 delta, nod may go to C2 IMO.

$.02
 
I’ve had a C2 for a couple years now and when I shot the CS I couldn’t tell the difference at all and immediately ordered one. I’ve always felt the c2 was just a little big for concealed carry, but it’s a great “if you can only have one” gun. I also have a P now so I’m not sure if I’ll keep the c2 once my CS arrives.
If you part with the c2 let me know lol
 
I carried a C2 for a couple of years and gave it to my son when he turned 21. I’ve been carrying a P229 Legion but it doesn’t have an optic plate and I really prefer an optic so looking at another pistol.

I have an Atlas Nyx but it’s hard to conceal, especially in the summer, but it’s a great shooting gun. I just looked at a CS today and really like the size and leaning towards the CS over the C2. But, I have not shot the CS yet but willing to sacrifice a little if necessary for a smaller size gun.
 
1911 single stack. 2011 double stack. Frames are completely different
From the tits down, maybe... From the slide stop up, they're literally the same. The different parts between any "normal" 2011 and a 1911 are: trigger, magazine release, magazine, grip panels and bushings (1911 only), or grip module, screws, and bushings (2011 only). The newer metal grip modules may require specific mainspring housings and grip safeties - I don't know - not part of the original 2011 design.

When the CS came out, I was not interested - I'd seen other "innovations" from "the company now known as Staccato" where they'd tried to improve upon the 1911 (witness the glorious feed "wall" they put on the Trojan, for instance), so I was hesitant to look at something they were doing as an improvement on the platform. The CS seems to be working well, though - a couple shooters I know and trust have had them for over a year, and put a decent amount of ammo through them (10k+ each), and they're still running. So... for me, it's a toss up. Wish the CS took normal Staccato/STI/SV pattern mags, though,