Rifle Scopes Steinter T5Xi > Burris XTR2?

I am new to the forum but read this post and recently purchased a steiner t5xi 5-25 to provide more magnification and update an excellent Leupold mk 4 3.5 to 10 that has served me very well through field and range activity. I had been out of the glass market since purchasing my mk 4 back in the late 90s 2000 timeframe. Therefore I consider all of us lucky to have access to high quality optics manufacturers with feature rich products. My budget, like many, is midrange at best because I still have yet to win that darn lottery lol. I looked through several scopes and purchased my steiner based upon the price point, reputation, warranty and price point. I got a good deal on what has been called a law enforcement demo... figured it would be just fine after mounting on a rifle for a class and I was right... scope was mint... also figured since it was a demo model someone took some extra qa time prior to putting it out for officers to consider for purchase in their departments. Anyway, got the scope from a great vendor with excellent customer service (sportoptics) and could not be more pleased with the quality and features of the product for my purposes. While I have not looked through S&B scopes or other higher end scopes because they were outside my budget and I have wondered realistically what kind of performance difference is present for those extra couple of percentage points in brightness and clarity for my use not requiring my life on the line. I am not knocking purchasing the best just realistically wonder if I personally would truly benefit from what they offered for my intended use for the scope. Anyway, long story short, steiner t5xi is a great scope, and the scr reticle is fine enough for target work at max magnification given its an ffp for me. Hope my .02 helps in your journey as it is not easy choosing from ingest great options.
Rate
 
While I have not looked through S&B scopes or other higher end scopes because they were outside my budget and I have wondered realistically what kind of performance difference is present for those extra couple of percentage points in brightness and clarity for my use not requiring my life on the line. I am not knocking purchasing the best just realistically wonder if I personally would truly benefit from what they offered for my intended use for the scope. Anyway, long story short, steiner t5xi is a great scope, and the scr reticle is fine enough for target work at max magnification given its an ffp for me. Hope my .02 helps in your journey as it is not easy choosing from ingest great options.
Rate

Welcome to the forum, but the OP already decided on "none of the above" if you read the last reply.

Also, you do get what you pay for. Nothing wrong with cheaper optics, as the SWFA fixed 10x and 3-15x are still two of my favorites... but my NF and S&B blow them out of the water and into space in every single way. My Kahles was visually more pleasing than the NF honestly, and I wish I could compare the Kahles to the S&B side by side..
 
I had a 4-20 XTR2 and loved the turrets, zero stop, and RTZ. I've had (2) of the T5XI 5-25 scopes. Both tracked well, I really liked the scr reticle, and I really liked the extra goodies that came with them. I ended up getting rid of all of them because to me the CA just bugged the hell out of me! They're each good scopes and they work for lots of folks out there. If I was shopping for a scope in the T5XI price range, I'd go Gen1 Razor HD 5-20 over the Burris or Steiner. I'm on my 2nd one of them now and they are just a solid, dependable scope! Tracks dead on, good glass with barely any CA to my eyes, better reticle and better illumination IMHO.
 
Is the glass on the Weaver Tactical 3-15 (only decent scope I've owned) going to be better than the Burris XTR II 3-15? I've found the Burris with the SCR reticle for $750ish without illumination.


 
Thanks. Looks like I'm back to trying to decide if the Bushnell DMR II is worth the extra money compared to the $750 Weaver Tactical 6-30.

The DMR II looks to be the better fit for a 18" Grendel, still undecided though.
 
Thanks. Looks like I'm back to trying to decide if the Bushnell DMR II is worth the extra money compared to the $750 Weaver Tactical 6-30.

The DMR II looks to be the better fit for a 18" Grendel, still undecided though.

I don't think you will be disappointed with the Weaver but the reticle is the IMDR and I think it'll leave you wanting something else.

If you were considering the Burris XTRII I would consider the Steiner T5Xi from EuroOptics, Natchez Shooters Supply, or the PX. They can be found for $1400-1500 used, referb, blem and have the upgraded turrets.

The DMRII is a hell of a scope and I think you would be happy with it or the T5Xi.

I was in the same situation a couple months ago when Bushnell had their rebate and the DMRII and T5Xi were about the same price. I eventually chose he T5Xi because I found such a good deal on one
 
I got a Steiner T5Xi to backup my Minox ZP5 which is my go to scope. I haven’t spent nearly the time behind the Steiner as I have with the Minox, but it is well worth the savings and I would definitely choose the Steiner over the Burris. There is a huge difference in the glass between the Steiner and Minox; but compared to the Burris, the Steiner is better. FWIW, on a ‘tall target test’ the Steiner was perfect. Absolutely no error.
I’m probably going to sell my T5Xi simply because I don’t use it. But if I didn’t already have the Minox, I’d be okay with the Steiner.
 
Just a heads up for anyone considering the Burris. I was in my local Cabelas this weekend and they had the 3-15 version with the SCRMIL reticle for less than $750 ($73X if I recall?). I almost bought one just to check out at that price.