I am one of the "is a fan" folks ...
For me there are 3 fundamental classes of reticle ...
01 - Duplex - dial for elevation and wind, or else use the critter as the reticle, with the center of the cross hairs to aim with.
02 - Mil/MOA - dot/hash - dial for elevation, hold for wind, or else use the critter as the reticle (as above)
03 - Holding reticles - hold for elevation and wind (can also use critter as above).
The advantage of the 02 over the 01 is speed. No need to take the time to dial for wind.
The advantage of the 03 over the 02 is speed. No need to take the time to dial for elevation.
==
Now within the 03, class, there are two other classes which extend the 03 class.
The tremor-3 has MPH wind dots built into the reticle, so you make your wind call in MPH and hold in MPH. For me, this enables fast first round hits out to 800yds (as far as I can shoot on my land currently) off tripod (RRS) shooting at IPSC (2/3) steel.
I hit 4 out of 4 on the torso on this day .. with cross wind varying from 8-10 MPH and made the correction based on hearing and without taking my eye off the target. Just think "now hold for 10 MPH" and do it.
Also hit 2 out of 3 on the face (6x6) that day. I don't usually even try for face at that distance, but was feeling lucky that day.
So the T3 reticle works for me, with how I shoot. I realize, I doesn't work for everyone with how they shoot, but just wanted there to be at least one person posting in the thread who is using them. I started using T3 reticles in Feb 2018 and still use them now. I have 3.
T3 is a "no dial" reticle. And this is also an advantage if you use rifle mounted range finders on your rifles, which I do.
With the rifle mounted range finders up there, you want to range with the scope dialed to 100yds (your zero distance). With T3 reticles, I only dial when I am zeroing. With dialing reticles, like the 02 class, I have to dial up the elevation to shoot, and then dial back down 100yds to range and then dial back up to shoot and then dial back down to range. With a holding reticle, I don't have to do that.
==
The final variation of reticle class I'm aware of is the DTR (David Tubbs Reticle). This one also has wind dots (some say David had them before Horus, and I believe it), so like the T3, no ballistic calculator required to hold for wind. But the DTR goes further and includes factors like DA and aerojump in the ballistic reticle, so the DTR IS your ballistic calculator and no need to us a ballistic calculator for either wind or elevation. I haven't gotten the guts to try the DTR yet, but its definitely on my "bucket" list
http://www.davidtubb.com/dtr-scopes?product_id=189