Re: Wilson vs. Brown vs. Baer vs. Nighthawk
Before you commit, you might want to ask yourself what you are going to use the pistol for and how much you want to spend as both will give you completely different answers to which pistol you want to buy.
The Baer is a great pistol if you are going to get a full size .45, but I would not buy one in a Commander size as they don't use Commander frames for their Commander pistols. This creates reliability issues. The TRS is a great gun for the price if you want a reliable accurate gun.
Browns are nice but they aren't as special as the price would suggest. If you have the money to spend, nothing wrong with them except that Ed Brown is known to be cocky about his guns.
Wilson's are reliable and have a good resale value. They are pricey though, but you usually get your money back out of them. They make a lot of pistols, so of course they have a few bad apples, but their customer service is great and they will take care of their product.
It is no secret that Nighthawk was started from Wilson employees. For this reason, they are built very similar to a Wilson. I have had problems with their Commander size gun, but their full size guns are pretty good. They have done a great marketing job, but they are known for having a few bad apples in the barrel. Some people swear by them, and others have had problems with them. I'm in the second category.
Full customs are great, but they are expensive. If you are on a budget look for a used full custom as they don't hold their value except for a few smiths (usually in the $4k plus range). If you are really into the 1911 platform, you will probably buy a full custom some day. They are nicer, but it depends what features you want and how much you are willing to spend. They are not going to be more accurate or much more reliable then the Baer, but they are easier to shoot and have a lot of pretty machine work.
I've had my hands on or owned almost every major brand, model, or custom smithed 1911 in the market and they all have negatives and positives. If you have any further questions, feel free to PM me.