I find it disgusting. But so many people seem to think it’s normal. What’s the consensus
Does ketchup go on hotdogs
- Thread starter Jigstick
- Start date
Yes.
This is a hill I'll die on.
As a matter of fact, my hotdog consists of following:
Toasted Baguette
2 dogs
Tomatoes
Onions
Pickles
Coleslaw
Dijon Mustard
Ketchup
Garlic sauce
Crunchy fried onion topping
This is a hill I'll die on.
As a matter of fact, my hotdog consists of following:
Toasted Baguette
2 dogs
Tomatoes
Onions
Pickles
Coleslaw
Dijon Mustard
Ketchup
Garlic sauce
Crunchy fried onion topping
Was in NY and decided I'd eat a hotdog stand hotdog. Guy asks what I wanted on it. Told him whatever was supposed to be on it. He asked if I wanted ketchup. Said whatever you think.
I hate ketchup.
Dude thought I'd want that shit cause I obviously didn't belong there.
Think we both squinted eyes like we were going to throwdown.
I ate most of the shitty hotdog.
I hate ketchup.
Dude thought I'd want that shit cause I obviously didn't belong there.
Think we both squinted eyes like we were going to throwdown.
I ate most of the shitty hotdog.
Yss. I mostly only eat regular hot dogs as chilli cheese dogs and the ketchup goes well. I also eat johnsville better cheddar dogs(?) with cheddar, honey mustard, and ketchup. The only time I eat plain hot dogs is when they're cooked over a fire and I put just ketchup on them.
No to ketchup. Spicy mustard with chili and cheese is the Best way. Otherwise mustard, onions, relish, and cheese.
Considering what's in hot dogs , the Ketchup would be the most healthy part to eat !
Think ketchup and mustard are both acceptable.
The one I don't get is the people that put about two cups of mayo on a hotdog or corndog...
The one I don't get is the people that put about two cups of mayo on a hotdog or corndog...
Personally, I can take it or leave it. After a lifetime of working construction with guy's living on the road, from all over America. I have seen those little, tear open packages of ketchup, mayo, Taco sauce, mustard come out of a lunch bucket and put on every food imaginable. Condiments know no boundaries and there are no food police in the construction world.
But, that is a great question.
But, that is a great question.
I am indifferent to ketchup. On the other hand though mayonnaise should be forbidden on hot dogs. Not only is the imagery of such a combo not cool, it's just gross all around.
Anyone that would put mayo on a hotdog, burger or sandwich should be hanged. But I'll dip artichoke and other veggies in it.
I’m a mayo and mustard on hotdogs kind of guy. If I can only have one it would be mayo. I also like tomato sauce on hard tacos. I thought it was normal growing up. Ketchup goes with french fries.
I will eat it on a sandwich but nothing at all meant to be eaten warm.
A turkey sandwich made the day after Thanksgiving with some left over deep fried turkey... oh yeah. But never on a hot dog or a hamburger.
What do you put on a burger then? I put extra mayo on sandwiches and burgers. Both pieces of bread and thick. Dukes mayo is the best.
Hot dogs get ; chili , cheese , relish ,mustard and French's French Fries Onions .
Burgers get either mayo and ketchup or BBQ sauce .
I love food threads . People come together , some dog in their heels , one of the last vestiges of agree to disagree . Very American .
Burgers get either mayo and ketchup or BBQ sauce .
I love food threads . People come together , some dog in their heels , one of the last vestiges of agree to disagree . Very American .
Nothing should go on hotdogs, they’re fucking gross. What are you, fucking 5? Grow up and eat a damned hamburger
| Vienna beef frank Poppyseed bun Yellow mustard White onion Neon green pickle relish Sport peppers Chopped tomatoes Kosher pickle spear Celery salt |
Nevermind the condiments, you guys eat lips and assholes?
Hell, gents, you paid for it. As long as you don't eat it disgustingly--like a nine-month-old in a highchair--put whatever you want on it. Or when in Rome.... Chicago dogs are unique. New York dogs the same. As the Aussies are wont to say...at least the few I've met...each cat to his own rat.
I think it was about a year ago I tossed an unopened bottle of ketchup that was over 2 years beyond its sell-by date.
Last time I probably ate a hot-dog was when I heated some for my daughter's birthday party probably around 20 years ago. I do like brats, however.
Last time I probably ate a hot-dog was when I heated some for my daughter's birthday party probably around 20 years ago. I do like brats, however.
A true "Loaded" hot dog can have a tiny amount of ketchup on it. A tiny amount. But must be vastly over powered by onions, relish, cheap yellow mustard, kraut, chili, etc. Ketchup must NEVER be the primary hot-dog garnish. It's sort of ghey.
And when I say yellow mustard... a hot dog must be swimming in mustard! It's a religion.
Sirhr
And when I say yellow mustard... a hot dog must be swimming in mustard! It's a religion.
Sirhr
Ketchup and mustard with onions.
One of the most disgusting things on this planet is pickle relish.
I automatically think less of folks that put ketchup on steak. Those that use "steak sauce" are only slightly less revolting.
One of the most disgusting things on this planet is pickle relish.
I automatically think less of folks that put ketchup on steak. Those that use "steak sauce" are only slightly less revolting.
- Nov 3, 2010
- 10,514
- 23,026
if your 12 and no one ever showed you any difference yes taste wise it's the difference between Sauteing onions and dumping salt on . Grilling a hot dog vrs boiling one you can change the taste of your food to your liking using anything you want to if tomato ketchup is your thing then enjoy it .. .
This thread just proves that some people will put just about anything in their mouth 
A real hot dog gets mustard, grilled onions, Carolina style hot dog chili, and maybe some slaw. The only real hot dog is made by Carolina Packers under Bright Leaf label, in Smithfield NC.
All them other pale ass weiners are just "franks" or weiners. Thats a good name for them too.
You need some ketchup on those shitty things. The more shit you can pile around them the better. One step above a damn Vienna sausage.
All them other pale ass weiners are just "franks" or weiners. Thats a good name for them too.
You need some ketchup on those shitty things. The more shit you can pile around them the better. One step above a damn Vienna sausage.
As a hot dog aficionado and lover of the classic Chicago Dog, ketchup on a hot dog is disgusting. The places I have purchased Chicago Dogs (some of them) do not have ketchup available and if you ask for it they will refuse to serve you and send you down the street to grab a ketchup packet at a local fast food place.
IMO, no ketchup on 'Dogs. Not ever. Never.
VooDoo
IMO, no ketchup on 'Dogs. Not ever. Never.
VooDoo
I like hotdogs 4 ways.
Chicago how they come.
Dog, bun, ketchup, mustard
Dog, bun, ketchup, mustard, chili, cheese, onion, dill relish
Dog, bun, brown/dijon mustard, lots of kraut.
Chicago how they come.
Dog, bun, ketchup, mustard
Dog, bun, ketchup, mustard, chili, cheese, onion, dill relish
Dog, bun, brown/dijon mustard, lots of kraut.
