I guess one perspective is to try juice a bullet with as much speed as possible by stuffing the the biggest thing that will fit in your mag. It's like skinny jeans logic. But it all doesn't have to be tight and constrained, you can just get a bigger pair of pants.
Another perspective is perhaps you want to drive a particular bullet weight and caliber at a given speed range and you pick a case that will get it there. Then you just put it in a frame that will get it out of a mag and into the barrel.
I think this has been the overwhelming majority of people's approach. Guys have been shooting 7 SAUMs, 7WSMs, and 300WSMs out of long actions for years. It's kind of wild to me that there's people on this thread acting like this hasn't been the case for over a decade. "It's ghey!" " Monkeypox!" In fact the issues involved with trying to fit 180gr bullets in a short action has created a cottage industry of special SAUM/ WSM magazines, and medium length actions/mags/chassis. People are constantly trying to solve it with cartridges like the 7 SS. I would also go as far as to say that issues with it all allowed the space for the 6.5 PRC to become successful. If there wasn't anything wrong with SAUMs and WSMs in short actions everyone would still be shooting them and they wouldn't be dying out.
I've been guilty myself of hyper focusing on short action rifles. Like it would kill me to shoot a long action. And it all revolves around two differences. Ostensibly overall rifle weight and definitely magazines. But the difference between a long action Anti and a short action Anti is something like 3 oz. And long action mag options are a lot better these days. Your options aren't just gigantic obnoxious 338 Lapua AICS mags. Hawkins makes long action WSM mags for hunter DBMs.
Yeah, I've cut the front out of AR mags, paid people to machine binder plates out, fucked with ARC mags. You can do that shit if you want. I'll pass these days.
So basically on this thread we have people who want to get the most out of a cartridge so they put it in an action that will let them and then we have people that want to get the most out of their action length so they stuff shit in it. And the difference of opinion has us trying to push each other's buttons? Seems like a giant waste of time.
Another perspective is perhaps you want to drive a particular bullet weight and caliber at a given speed range and you pick a case that will get it there. Then you just put it in a frame that will get it out of a mag and into the barrel.
I think this has been the overwhelming majority of people's approach. Guys have been shooting 7 SAUMs, 7WSMs, and 300WSMs out of long actions for years. It's kind of wild to me that there's people on this thread acting like this hasn't been the case for over a decade. "It's ghey!" " Monkeypox!" In fact the issues involved with trying to fit 180gr bullets in a short action has created a cottage industry of special SAUM/ WSM magazines, and medium length actions/mags/chassis. People are constantly trying to solve it with cartridges like the 7 SS. I would also go as far as to say that issues with it all allowed the space for the 6.5 PRC to become successful. If there wasn't anything wrong with SAUMs and WSMs in short actions everyone would still be shooting them and they wouldn't be dying out.
I've been guilty myself of hyper focusing on short action rifles. Like it would kill me to shoot a long action. And it all revolves around two differences. Ostensibly overall rifle weight and definitely magazines. But the difference between a long action Anti and a short action Anti is something like 3 oz. And long action mag options are a lot better these days. Your options aren't just gigantic obnoxious 338 Lapua AICS mags. Hawkins makes long action WSM mags for hunter DBMs.
Yeah, I've cut the front out of AR mags, paid people to machine binder plates out, fucked with ARC mags. You can do that shit if you want. I'll pass these days.
So basically on this thread we have people who want to get the most out of a cartridge so they put it in an action that will let them and then we have people that want to get the most out of their action length so they stuff shit in it. And the difference of opinion has us trying to push each other's buttons? Seems like a giant waste of time.