AI AT Bolt Stuck 6.5 CM

A

ACK

Sergeant
Full Member
Minuteman
Nov 20, 2004
409
249
So. Ca
#1
Just got back from the range.
Brass Hornady
Bullet 140 ELD
Powder H4350
OAL: 2.693

Was working a load (average of 5)
40GR /2592 FPS
40.3/2652 FPS
40.6/2663
40.9/2673 (nice group)
41.2/2693 (OH CRAP)

At 41.2 the case yielded, and the bolt is now stuck (it moves a small amount). I have used 41.5 Gr with the 147 ELD without any issues.

I removed the barrel, no binding and the case is blown on one side.

Tried the mallet method on the bolt; it will not budge. Next recommendation?

Thank you and Happy New Year.
 
Last edited:
#2
That charge and velocity seems mild enough...how many times have you reloaded that case? Time to switch to Lapua!

And I have never touched an AI so can't really help you there. But it won't even unlock with the barrel off?
 
#4
Trigger is removed. Barrel is removed. Very minor movement on the bolt. Sprayed lubricant everywhere, no joy.
This is puzzling. Don't want to go Neanderthal (yet)
 
#5
Post a pic of the action looking into the boltface.
When you puled off the barrel where is the case?
Did the case head separate or is it still attached to the bolt?
 
#6
Ok, this is fun (NOT) barrel came off very easily, case was on the bolt, wiggled it free. I may have found the issue, the blown fragment (or portions of it ) is under the extractor inhibiting the bolt's rotation. I am removing the skins, scope and see if I have better access to the extractor surfaces. Thanks to everyone.

These were Hornady cases with three or four loadings, all passed the "paperclip" test (case separation test. This is a new one on me
 
  • Like
Reactions: jd138
#8
You need to first check the headspace on that rifle and if it comes back good then you need
to review your reloading practices to make sure you are not doing something wrong.

3 or 4 firings should not cause the case to fail.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huskydriver
#9
Will do. I have gages and the AT barrels are prefit. I started with an AI AE back in 2000; reloading for rifles and pistols for several decades; never seen a case fail like this.
 
#12
ACK said:
Ok, this is fun (NOT) barrel came off very easily, case was on the bolt, wiggled it free. I may have found the issue, the blown fragment (or portions of it ) is under the extractor inhibiting the bolt's rotation. I am removing the skins, scope and see if I have better access to the extractor surfaces. Thanks to everyone.

These were Hornady cases with three or four loadings, all passed the "paperclip" test (case separation test. This is a new one on me
Click to expand...

How much were you bumping the shoulder of the case? Did you measure the shoulder length before and after sizing?
 
#19
918v said:
Hornady brass isn’t crappy. Your logic is crappy.
Click to expand...
Having load 308, 6.5 SAUM (first gen)and 6.5CM in Hornady brass, you can load published max loads which isn't all that fast and Hornady would barely last a couple of firings. Also remember people were getting stuck cases when Hornady brought out their .338LM offering a while back. Never my first choice in brass, it's just worth it to buy better brass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BCX and Eddystone
#20
918v said:
Hornady brass isn’t crappy. Your logic is crappy.
Click to expand...
Not crappy? The case heads are like butter. I have lapua brass fired over 100x and still going. Hornady is lucky to get 10. Usually I get problems like the pics below before they even get to 10x fired. Stopped using that garbage long ago.
880A654B-491E-4AA8-9737-BED519AF3306.png
03AC79BF-B65F-4337-B2DD-0CC721E4C101.png
 
#23
Bacarrat said:
Having load 308, 6.5 SAUM (first gen)and 6.5CM in Hornady brass, you can load published max loads which isn't all that fast and Hornady would barely last a couple of firings. Also remember people were getting stuck cases when Hornady brought out their .338LM offering a while back. Never my first choice in brass, it's just worth it to buy better brass.
Click to expand...

I load Hornady brass in 308, 300WM, and 6.5CM to full potential and the brass lasts 10-12 reloads. No it is not as durable as some premium brands but it is good brass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ledzep, reubenski and deersniper
#24
FreddyG said:
Not crappy? The case heads are like butter. I have lapua brass fired over 100x and still going. Hornady is lucky to get 10. Usually I get problems like the pics below before they even get to 10x fired. Stopped using that garbage long ago.
View attachment 7517198View attachment 7517203
Click to expand...

You can find defects with any brass. I have a bunch of 1x Peterson 6.5 brass from factory ammo with loose primer pockets.
 
#25
918v said:
You can find defects with any brass. I have a bunch of 1x Peterson 6.5 brass from factory ammo with loose primer pockets.
Click to expand...
Peterson brass is not great either. Hornady is one of the worst. There is nothing wrong with shooting it in factory ammo, but reloading it leads to threads like this.
 
#26
I pick up all the free Hornady brass I can from my ranges and load them in my AR10s....to never be seen by me again ;-)

I have also been disappointed with Peterson brass from Prime ammo, case volume deviation was terrible.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: deersniper
#29
FreddyG said:
I posted pics. No BS here. The truth sucks for fanboys. The sad part is my loads in the above pics were mild. Not eleven close to max.
Click to expand...

K I'm not a huge fan of Hornady brass either but that first picture you posted.... That primer is so flat with a massive ejector flow..... That primer pocket didn't fail just because it was a Hornady case.... That primer screams over pressure
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pvt.Donut, jlficken, Defender3 and 4 others
#30
Huskydriver said:
K I'm not a huge fan of Hornady brass either but that first picture you posted.... That primer is so flat with a massive ejector flow..... That primer pocket didn't fail just because it was a Hornady case.... That primer screams over pressure
Click to expand...
It failed because of a soft case head. The load was a mild load, that the rest of that particular lot of brass handled fine for the rest of their lives. BTW, that same lot of powder/primers/bullets/rifle went almost 200 fps faster in lapua brass with not one problem.
You guys are welcome to use hornady brass, I like the OP, am just sharing my brass failure story.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deersniper
#33
FreddyG said:
It failed because of a soft case head. The load was a mild load, that the rest of that particular lot of brass handled fine for the rest of their lives. BTW, that same lot of powder/primers/bullets/rifle went almost 200 fps faster in lapua brass with not one problem.
You guys are welcome to use hornady brass, I like the OP, am just sharing my brass failure story.
Click to expand...

Your mild load blew the primer. Tell us what the load was?
 
#34
FreddyG said:
It failed because of a soft case head. The load was a mild load, that the rest of that particular lot of brass handled fine for the rest of their lives. BTW, that same lot of powder/primers/bullets/rifle went almost 200 fps faster in lapua brass with not one problem.
You guys are welcome to use hornady brass, I like the OP, am just sharing my brass failure story.
Click to expand...

A mild case head doesn't explain the primer flow into the firing pin channel, ejector, or cup evidenced by your provided photo... again I don't use Hornady brass either hero
 
#36
There was no brass flow into the ejector. There is a swipe, but it must be due to the case failure, as all of the other brass from that lot was fine, including no flat primers. The bolt had to be hammered open due to complete failure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cav1993
#39
918v said:
Factory chamber? How close to the lands?
Click to expand...
Yes factory gun, way off lands. There is no conspiracy theory to be found here dude. I’ve ran thousands of lapua cases, most fired 50x or more. No problems.

It’s not like the internet isn’t full of hornady brass horror stories already. They suck period. It would be nice if they didn’t, but you get what you pay for in life.

Ironically the better more expensive brass is way cheaper in the long run.
 
#41
FreddyG said:
Yes factory gun, way off lands. There is no conspiracy theory to be found here dude. I’ve ran thousands of lapua cases, most fired 50x or more. No problems.

It’s not like the internet isn’t full of hornady brass horror stories already. They suck period. It would be nice if they didn’t, but you get what you pay for in life.

Ironically the better more expensive brass is way cheaper in the long run.
Click to expand...

People don’t need to buy Lapua brass in order to run safe and reliable loads. Hornady brass is perfectly good and safe. To suggest otherwise is retarded. And I don’t believe your H414 story or the number of loads you get on Lapua brass. 50??? Please...

FYI Federal, Remington and Winchester brass are softer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: midgetorama
#42
918v said:
People don’t need to buy Lapua brass in order to run safe and reliable loads. Hornady brass is perfectly good and safe. To suggest otherwise is retarded. And I don’t believe your H414 story or the number of loads you get on Lapua brass. 50??? Please...

FYI Federal, Remington and Winchester brass are softer.
Click to expand...
I don’t care if you believe me. It’s not like I’m the only one getting unreal life out of good brass. It does sound like you need to shoot a bit more to experience some of this yourself. Reading online only takes you so far.
 
#43
Last edited:
  • Haha
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: MarinePMI, Changed, Holliday and 2 others
#48
Max published loads are in a clean pampered pressure test barrel. The load data is not watered down. Barrel to barrel variance in pressure, rifling geometry etc... Are real things...

That said. My experience with Hornady brass is that it's fine up to 60-63ksi. If you get low primer pocket life, IMO most of the time it's a sign of >65000psi loads in YOUR rifle. That being said my experience is mostly with 6.5 Creedmoor. Every cartridge is made on different tooling, maybe even starting with different material/condition and everyone has a bad lot here and there. I had some trash 260 Lapua brass once. So my statements above are generalized and I'm sure exceptions exist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stoweit and Steel head
#49
I remember reading someone’s post in the reloading section where he talked about how he mixed IMR 4350 H4350 and that caused a blown primer. Maybe the OP did the same, unintentionally.


Maybe the OP should pry on the extractor with a screwdriver to try to get it back inside the bolt and maybe then the bolt will turn? I dunno I haven’t blown up a rifle before.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

stevieb92
Bergara HMR Pro 6.5 Creedmoor Load Development
Replies
6
Views
2K
stevieb92
stevieb92
C
Ladder Test 6.5 CM
Replies
13
Views
1K
Centerfire01
C
S
6.5 Creedmoor - am I on the right track?
Replies
22
Views
2K
DeathBeforeDismount
DeathBeforeDismount
B
6.5 CM Ladder/OCW Test Advice
Replies
8
Views
1K
Ledzep
Ledzep
L
6.5 CM load development - Satterlee or something else
Replies
25
Views
2K
dzander
dzander
Top Bottom
Back
Home
Forums
Merch
Alerts