• Frank's Lesson's Contest

    We want to see your skills! Post a video between now and November 1st showing what you've learned from Frank's lessons and 3 people will be selected to win a free shirt. Good luck everyone!

    Create a channel Learn more
  • Having trouble using the site?

    Contact support

Bergara HMR Bolt Handle Broke Off Twice.....

chromebonez

Private
Full Member
Minuteman
Apr 5, 2017
17
3
Hey guys, the bolt handle on my Bergara HMR .308 broke off two times and is currently at Bergara! 1st time at around 450rds and the 2nd at around 500rds, both times happened as I took my shot and proceeded to lift the bolt handle to extract the spent casing, no resistance, it just snapped right off at the brazing. I LOVED this rifle but after having the handle break off twice makes it an automatic disqualification in my book, if I'm going to own one good precision rifle, I need it to be reliable. Was just wondering if this has happened to any of you guys that own the HMR?

Mini Review: Between my 3 choices for my first Bolt action (HMR / 700 5R / T3x CTR) The HMR stock is what sets it apart from the 700 5R and CTR, the HMR Stock's adjustability just makes the world of a difference. The accuracy from this rifle was more than enough for a beginner like me to grow into (It far exceeded my expectations.) My rifle and I could do half MOA with the right load and consistently shot .5-.7 moa 5 shot groups with Federal GMM 168gr SMK. Another reason I loved this rifle is because it shot factory ammo with the accuracy I wanted to achieve, not to mention that Federal GMM is one of the lesser expensive factory match ammo which means more shooting. I seriously loved this rifle and it has became my favorite platform.

I did have to apply blue loctite to the cheek piece screw because it kept backing after about a 100rds, (I let it dry on the screw before putting it into the stock so it would still be easy to unscrew.)

After about 600 rounds I had to re-tighten the two screws that hold the block underneath the cheekpiece, needless to say it was an easy fix and didn't change my mind about the rifle, but having the bolt handle break off not once, but twice, I'm pretty devastated about it. Just wanted to share and get some feed back and advice on my situation.

Just want to do a quick update: Bergara took care of me big time, took a little patience on my end but this is definitely a good company that stands behind their product with good customer support.
UnaasNo.jpg
H1ZbQZZ.jpg

0MwcFI5.jpg
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2394.JPG
    IMG_2394.JPG
    418.3 KB · Views: 173
  • IMG_2673.JPG
    IMG_2673.JPG
    472.3 KB · Views: 225
  • IMG_2727.JPG
    IMG_2727.JPG
    459.3 KB · Views: 381
Last edited:
Just have it repaired by someone who knows how to attach a bolt handle properly. No reason the joint should be failing. Depending on the materials involved, you may be able to have it welded. Call LRI and get their opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bradu
Hate to hear that. I'd say pick up a T3 and move on. Throw it in a KRG Bravo if you need adjustability on a budget.

That stock you recommended looks pretty good for the price, thanks. Also noticed the tikka t3x bolt handle goes into a dovetail on the bolt which seems like a more durable design vs the 700s and the B-14 Bolts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigTex
One tiny little photo would have made this issue a lot clearer.
Think you can post one.
I don't know how many Remington 700 actions are out there, or, for that matter Bergara but something was wrong, twice. This just flat should not happen.
 
That stock you recommended looks pretty good for the price, thanks. Also noticed the tikka t3x bolt handle goes into a dovetail on the bolt which seems like a more durable design vs the 700s and the B-14 Bolts.

The Tikka has a similar Achilles heel. The bolt stop pin is very easily broken. After breaking several and seeing friends break theirs I gave up on Tikka's for competition use. They are fine as hunting rifles. Not as big of a problem as the bolt handle breaking off, as the rifle is still usable, but requires a field fix nonetheless.
 
The Tikka has a similar Achilles heel. The bolt stop pin is very easily broken. After breaking several and seeing friends break theirs I gave up on Tikka's for competition use. They are fine as hunting rifles. Not as big of a problem as the bolt handle breaking off, as the rifle is still usable, but requires a field fix nonetheless.

I've never seen a Tikka bolt stop break; knock on wood, saw a Bergara Premier break bolt stop snap off in a match.
 
Sounds like they copied Remington too closely.

When I searched up broken Bergara bolt handle, there were a few threads about broken rem 700 handles and it seemed like a common occurence, if you look at the B-14 Bolt design it looks very similar to the broken bolt handles on the rem 700s. I believe they built the action off of rem 700 blue prints.
 
Pictures attached, anyone with a Bergara B-14 have any issues, seems like I'm the first to experience this with the HMR, User error? or is this a manufacturing defect? Still waiting to here from Bergara about this.
 
OK I contacted the Bergara factory in Spain a while ago as I thought the bolt handle was a weak joint and I could slide a piece of paper between the bolt handle and bolt body.

The bolt handle is welded only on the rear of the bolt , front is not welded.

Here is the response.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This is Bergara Europe, probably our dealer in USA (BPI) could you offer better after sales service. I will add a copy of this email.

Your query is totally compressible, and fortunately is has a technical answer:

The bolt handle is laser welded, forming an “L” shape that surrounds it at the rear, it’s not brazed. Our abusive tests (250 kg force applied on the knob) concluded that most of the times the bolt itself will break prior the welding fails.

The inclined front wall is functional. It prevents the cocking piece kicking the sear HARD when pushing the bolt assembly forward, and also it acts like the primary extraction CAM (pulling the fired case rearward slightly, in case it’s stuck to the chamber). This surface is critical for rifle perfect performance, those dimensions must be under strict tolerances, so welding this angle isn´t best idea.

After ensuring that the “L” shape was strong enough to fix the handle, we decided not to weld the inclined functional wall.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I have around 800 rounds through my 6.5 HMR and the extractor spring just failed, contacted Bergara and they are shipping me a new one.

Other than that I have had no issues.

How did Bergara repair the bolt the first time? Did they reweld the bolt or did they send a new bolt that only lasted 50 rounds.
 
OK I contacted the Bergara factory in Spain a while ago as I thought the bolt handle was a weak joint and I could slide a piece of paper between the bolt handle and bolt body.

The bolt handle is welded only on the rear of the bolt , front is not welded.

Here is the response.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This is Bergara Europe, probably our dealer in USA (BPI) could you offer better after sales service. I will add a copy of this email.

Your query is totally compressible, and fortunately is has a technical answer:

The bolt handle is laser welded, forming an “L” shape that surrounds it at the rear, it’s not brazed. Our abusive tests (250 kg force applied on the knob) concluded that most of the times the bolt itself will break prior the welding fails.

The inclined front wall is functional. It prevents the cocking piece kicking the sear HARD when pushing the bolt assembly forward, and also it acts like the primary extraction CAM (pulling the fired case rearward slightly, in case it’s stuck to the chamber). This surface is critical for rifle perfect performance, those dimensions must be under strict tolerances, so welding this angle isn´t best idea.

After ensuring that the “L” shape was strong enough to fix the handle, we decided not to weld the inclined functional wall.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I have around 800 rounds through my 6.5 HMR and the extractor spring just failed, contacted Bergara and they are shipping me a new one.

Other than that I have had no issues.

How did Bergara repair the bolt the first time? Did they reweld the bolt or did they send a new bolt that only lasted 50 rounds.

The first time the bolt broke at around 450rds, I contacted Bergara and they sent me a bolt within a couple days, Excellent customer service so I thought i'd give it another try as the HMR was still a new rifle at the time i purchased it, The second bolt lasted around the 500 round mark and thats when the handle broke exactly the same way it did the first time.

Do you guys think Bergara's premier series one piece bolt design will prevent this problem from happening?

Thanks for your response btw. I've read a few threads about people with extraction issues as well and witnessed it in person with a brand new premier stalker and a 6.5 HMR, but Bergara had the guys ship it back and fixed it within 2 weeks both times.
 
Last edited:
The first time the bolt broke at around 450rds, I contacted Bergara and they sent me a bolt within a couple days, Excellent customer service so I thought i'd give it another try as the HMR was still a new rifle at the time i purchased it, The second bolt lasted around the 500 round mark and thats when the handle broke exactly the same way it did the first time.

Do you guys think Bergara's premier series one piece bolt design will prevent this problem from happening?

Thanks for your response btw. I've read a few threads about people with extraction issues as well and witnessed it in person with a brand new premier stalker and a 6.5 HMR, but Bergara had the guys ship it back and fixed it within 2 weeks both times.[/QUOTE

Bergara's premier series is heavily influenced by Ed Shilen...
 
I've got several Tikkas, and I have to wonder just how hard people are yanking the bolt back to break the bolt stop/bolt stop pin? Jesus folks, we're not ejecting a 155mm round here...
Lots of folks around here run Tikkas. I've never seen a bolt stop break, or a bolt handle for that matter. I am having an ejection issue with mine right now...but that seems to be very uncommon.
 
I have around 800 rounds through my HMR and I haven't had any issues with the bolt breaking. I have had some trouble with extraction of an empty case after firing though.
 
I have around 800 rounds through my HMR and I haven't had any issues with the bolt breaking. I have had some trouble with extraction of an empty case after firing though.

Check the extractor, if it moves easily in the slot or is loose the spring is probably bad.
I was shooting mine a couple of days ago and while pulling the bolt rearward the case would extract and drop onto the magazine.
 
Check the extractor, if it moves easily in the slot or is loose the spring is probably bad.
I was shooting mine a couple of days ago and while pulling the bolt rearward the case would extract and drop onto the magazine.
That's pretty much the same that happens with mine. I'll have to check it out once I get back stateside.
 
Lots of folks around here run Tikkas. I've never seen a bolt stop break, or a bolt handle for that matter. I am having an ejection issue with mine right now...but that seems to be very uncommon.


I hate to hijack this thread, but if you are mostly shooting prone, slow fire, etc. you probably won't break one. It didn't seem to be a problem until my local matches started running rooftop stages. I think whether you realize it or not, you must be "hanging" on the bolt while holding yourself in position. Sure it's more that most people will do with their rifles, but then again other rifles don't have this problem. I'm confident I'm not going to break anything on my Mausingfield bolt.
 
For all you guys with the HMR posting here, how's the rifle shooting for you accuracy wise? Post pics if possible.
I can't post my pictures from where I am, but the best group I have saved on my phone is right at .53 MOA from 100 yards. This is my first bolt action after a long line of AR15's and pistols, so I'm still teaching myself how to properly use the rifle.
 
I'll have to give that a go once I'm back. I'm really starting to miss my rifle and shooting.
Shot mine this weekend seems to shoot good. The middle shots were sight in,the left and right dots were me tring. I was happy with results
 

Attachments

  • 20180715_154327.jpg
    20180715_154327.jpg
    397.6 KB · Views: 84
  • 20180423_133722.jpg
    20180423_133722.jpg
    365.1 KB · Views: 105
I've got several Tikkas, and I have to wonder just how hard people are yanking the bolt back to break the bolt stop/bolt stop pin? Jesus folks, we're not ejecting a 155mm round here...

I bet it has more to do with the bolt stop itself, and whether the cross pin is bearing some of the impact from stopping the bolt.
 
A $1K precision rifle is never going to be 100% reliable, the chance of dealing with hiccups is pretty high. It's just the nature of the beast although I'd say that what you've experienced isn't typical.

Since it seems you're entertaining selling it anyway, instead of upgrading to another mid grade rifle I'd suggest looking for a gently used AI AE instead. You can pick them up well under $2K, sometimes just over $1K and they're dead nuts reliable. They'll make the HMR seem like a cheap toy and will last generations.
 
^ It is laser welded on three sides the front is not welded.
^ It is laser welded on three sides the front is not welded.
I see what you mean now,I meant front and rear of the handle. where it attaches at the bolt. I tried to put a piece of paper under it , I couldn't get it under,may have just been a bad handle and wasn't true to the bolt who knows ,even the best company's have products slip through Quality control sometimes