What caliber would you go with for a Coyote AR to use out west? Wide open - can shoot as far as you can see. Windy. Probably want to stick to the AR15 platform and avoid the heavy AR10. Would also like to be able to slap a 5.56 upper on it for defense.
6.5 Grendel has been on my radar for some years. 224 valk and 22 creedmoor are interesting as well.
Can a quality built AR have accuracy on par with a bolt gun?
What are some manufacturers you would suggest? Don't want to spend $3k, but would consider some more boutique manufacturers.
If I'm investing a good bit of money into the rifle, it might be nice to take it on a deer or antelope hunt, but I have plenty of guns that can fill that role as well if the caliber is not ideal.
Thanks!
Am I wrong in guessing that you're getting into, or wanting to get into, coyote hunting in the vast wide open spaces? I'm asking because it seems like some things haver been overlooked in this discussion - like the feasibility of making really long shoots on coyotes, or any predator. I'm not doubting anyone's shooting ability but, as someone that hunts predators as part of my job, I can tell you that coyotes don't like to stand around waiting to be ranged and calculated and dialed for. Usually, in the time it takes you to range a coyote and get onto your rifle he's already 50-75 yards closer to you; assuming you're calling him. I'm not saying you can't kill some coyotes at pretty extended ranges (I absolutely know you can and have done it myself) but those opportunities are few and far between. Usually, your shots are going to be inside 250yds, in my experience. Particularly if you've called in multiple dogs because you'll want them to come in as close as possible, to give yourself as much time to chase the 2nd and 3rd coyote. Also, if you start shooting at distance and you miss or have to chase another dog, they're increasing that distance (making the followup shots even more difficult) at a high rate of speed. My point is... Designing a "coyote AR" with the specific purpose of shooting them at distance is sort of backwards. It makes more sense to build around the bulk of your shots and then figure out how adapt that setup for those occasional longer shots. Besides, if you feel like calling a coyote with the specific intention of shooting him 'way out there,' just so you can you've done it, you'd be better off with a bolt gun; so just grab whatever (caliber) bolt gun you have that's already set up for LR shooting. If you're into calling predators, build a semi-auto that's terrific to 300yds (then it'll at least be 'good' to 500) and kill a LOT of coyotes. Personally, it's the "calling" that I like the best - getting them to come to me; and the closer I get them, the more fun it is! There's nothing like having a coyote come to a skidding stop 8-10yds in front of you, with a look of pure shock on their faces! Lol!
Personally, I like the .223 just because its CHEAP and available in SO many different configurations. I have very few "runners" with .223; although I
do have more than with my Win SX3 shotgun and some "Dead Coyote" loads! I use a 69gr or a 77gr most of the time but, honestly, I've had essentially the same success with 55gr v-max. I get.223 ammo when I find a deal and I'm not overly picky. I use a lot of guns, though - predators are a way for me to play with (and justify to the wife) the guns I've collected over there years. I use a .204 quite a bit and I really like my CZ 527 for both coyotes and bobcats. Another day I may be using my mother's first rifle that's a Sako-Anschutz .222 or my custom 6.5 Creedmoor. More often than not, though, I'm caring a suppressed SBR that I built with a Noveske barrel along with my 12ga. There hasn't been a caliber mentioned in this thread that I
wouldn't use; but I just don't see the practical advantage to building a predator gun on a more expensive caliber. .223 is cheap enough to allow most folks to buy a lot of it, which means you can shoot a lot - a bigger factor in your success rate than one calibers 4.86184% improvement over an affordable and widely available caliber. Now, if you are looking to justify building a new rifle in a particular caliber just to 'do something different' (and you need an excuse for the wife),
that's a different story. <---I totally 'get' that. Just not sure what
your personal objectives are
WSSM calibers. I have a Win 25wssm bolt rifle I bought when the caliber first came out and I love both the rifle and the caliber -it's a terrific deer cartridge and is devastating on coyotes. Winchester did the shooting world a real disservice by failing to properly promote and then dropping support of the cartridge series THEY introduced before it was able to garner the attention is deserved. BUT.... finding any wssm caliber ammo is usually a tough prospect and so is locating brass. If I didn't own this rifle already, there's NO way I buy anything wssm today. I'd love to turn it into something else but the overly short action that Winchester used isn't well suited for many calibers and nothing I'm interested. The WSSM is just too much hassle for too little return, IMO. It's almost a wildcat these days so, if you're going to hand load
anyway, why not build a true wildcat with blazing speed and accuracy and true novelty, without any possible feeding issues? Do you reload? If you don't, or are thinking about getting into it, I don't think I'd build anything you HAVE to reload.
Generally speaking, a bolt gun tends to be more accurate than an AR; but that doesn't mean you can't get terrific accuracy out of a semi auto. Plenty of accuracy for the task you laid out and any normal predator hunting.
Your budget... If you're willing to spend $2k-ish on a rifle, what's your optic budget? Honestly, optics are WAY more important to me than the particular caliber. I usually spend far more on optics than on my rifles. If I built a $2k semi-auto I'd be spending around the same on my glass
plus an offset micro red dot for close in fast-movers, when I don't have a shotgun. However, that's a crazy amount to spend on a "coyote gun." Hunting predator is a significant portion of my income and there's just NO way I would blow that kind of money on a rifle just for predators. Not when I kill as many as I do with cheaper setups or pretty much whatever I felt like pulling out of the safe . Again, if coyotes are just the excuse to build a fancy, best-of-the-best rifle, then that's a different story. I totally understand that justification and have used similar ones myself. I just didn't want you to think you HAD to build a $2k AR just to 'get it done' at some pretty good distance. You can put together a darn nice AR yourself, capable of shooting Sub MOA groups out to 500-600yds, for $1200 or even less- with the help of some of the armorers here in SH.
Sorry for the long post. Hope it helps in some way.