Re: Deer Capable Caliber for a Small Child
Hi tepeter1: based on what you can find a Remington 7 for, I would suggest 243, 7mm-08, and 308:
- 243 is the obvious, low recoil, flat trajectory, cheap ammo
- 7mm-08 is a great all-around round, cheap ammo too, with more recoil than the 243, so I am not sure how good it would be for the 8-year old: my 12 year old is small, a good shooter, and the 7mm-08 is just right for him, but I could not have given him a 7mm-08 at age 8. So it depends upon how experienced a shooter the boy is, and how big he is. The round is a much better all around cartridge than the 243 though.
- 308 is not outright bad, because there are reduced loads for the 308, and of course you cannot do much better than 308 for a real versatile round. But - even the reduced loads in 308 month be too hot? He would have a try a few at the range first.
Now - everyone is entitled to his own opinion. I understand we all have different experiences. My opinion is that one would be very misguided to buy a 223 caliber rifle for a boy's deer gun: yes, you can kill a deer, but you have to have good shot placement, and the round cannot go up-weight well into bigger targets, beyond the fact that it is not allowed in many states of the nation. This is simply an improper round choice for the purpose. It is an excellent vermin round which, in the hands of an experienced shooter, can be used to take deer. Putting it in the hands of an inexperienced shooter, in my opinion, is simply unethical. If 223 can do the job, why not 22LR then - people have taken lots of deer with 22LR - they have also wounded many... If it was my boy, I'd get him one of the three calibers above (243, 7mm-08, 308 w/ reduced loads), and be sure that he will be able to keep and enjoy his deer rifle for the rest of his life if he wishes to. But my feeling is that, unless he is big and experienced shooter, 243 is likely to be the only caliber that fits.
As for 260, 6.8, and most of the others mentioned - they will do the job but the ammo is much more expensive and hard to find. If you are in the boonies and suddenly need a box of ammo, what are you likely to find at the neighborhood store? The five most likely calibers are 223, 243, 270, 308, and 30-06. 7mm08 is not as common but very findable. Of course, 270 and 30-06 are totally unsuitable due to recoil.