Rifle Scopes Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

[wannabullet]

Those who own them are you happy with them? How do they hold up under normal field use? (hunting and milk jug shooting)

I have also thought of going with an Acog as my eyes are getting bad the older I get just dont know if I want to drop 1K on one or not.

 

[ZLBubba]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

It all boils down to what you're going to use the optics for. I own both an Aimpoint M2 and an ACOG TA01NSN and love them. You won't be disappointed in them.

I'm not a huge EoTech guy unless I'm only doing CQB. I've seen a good number have battery issues though I've read that the latest models have fixed those problems.

 

[ggmanning]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

I have an Eotech and 3x magnifier on my M4. I use it as a coyote fun here because I am often in the woods. without 3x it is ideal for a coyote charging in...on field edges the 3x makes it a decent mid range optic. I just leave the magnifier flipped to the side unless I have some range. I like the set up.

 

[samnev]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

I own all 3 you mentioned. Which one you use depends on how you will use it. I have 4 models of the ACOG TA31F, TA31RCOM4, TAO1 and TOA1NSN. Only Downside 1.5" eye relief that takes some getting use too. Another good choice would be the 33R at 3.5X and 1.9" eye relief. I have 1 Aimpoint the ML-3 2nd choice and 2 EoTechs, the 552 & 512. All perform well their intended job CQB for the Aimpoint and EoTechs and 20 to 200 yards for the ACOG's. Any longer distance I use 2 Leupy 6.5-20x40 EFR's vari-X3's and a Nightforce NXS 8-32X56. As my eyes get worse I tend to use the higher power scopes more often.

 

[HD1911]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

I have an Aimpoint CompM4 and love the shit out of it. I've left it turned on for over a year on the same double A battery, can't beat that. It should last for several more years too lol. Has held zero through all the rough handling and dropping. Very robust.

 

[SnkBit]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

I think it depends on the intended usage. I've got an Eotech on an AR platform that I love. I use it for hog hunting primarily. It is excellent for fast shot placement. My only gripe is around sunset. I don't have a magnifier on it and when the sun begins to set it is difficult to see anything much further than 50yds well enough to take an ethical shot. When your in chest high brush with piggies snorting all around you its the bees knees though!

 

[Sapper524]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

I agree with the above statements that its all about application. I personally run a M2 with tripler on a twist off. There are numerous variations of all the listed optics and you can configure multipule ways. With tripler on the Aimpoints and Eotechs, different magnifications on the Acogs. The Range you will be shooting and the speed you want to put the rounds on target would determine the choice, in my opinion.

Short range and fast on target and on the trigger = Eotech
Short to medium range = Aimpoint
Longer range = Acog

The caliber you will be shooting and if you can get/want a BDC in the Acog for the cartridge you will be using. Both the EoTech and Aimpoint are both eyes open optics ... until you put a 3x tripler behind it. I run the Aimpoint because its what I used in the Army, I am comfortable with it, and I trust it. I tried an EoTech and destroyed the thing. Granted this was in Iraq and smashing it against a Armored vehicle is not normal civilian wear and tear. The biggest advantage to the Tripler setup behind the Aimpoint or Eotech is the Backup Iron Sight option is always there as well. All 3 you mentioned have an application, choose accordingly.

 

[TrooperBrian]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Sapper524</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I agree with the above statements that its all about application. I personally run a M2 with tripler on a twist off. There are numerous variations of all the listed optics and you can configure multipule ways. With tripler on the Aimpoints and Eotechs, different magnifications on the Acogs. The Range you will be shooting and the speed you want to put the rounds on target would determine the choice, in my opinion.

Short range and fast on target and on the trigger = Eotech
Short to medium range = Aimpoint
Longer range = Acog

The caliber you will be shooting and if you can get/want a BDC in the Acog for the cartridge you will be using. Both the EoTech and Aimpoint are both eyes open optics ... until you put a 3x tripler behind it. I run the Aimpoint because its what I used in the Army, I am comfortable with it, and I trust it. I tried an EoTech and destroyed the thing. Granted this was in Iraq and smashing it against a Armored vehicle is not normal civilian wear and tear. The biggest advantage to the Tripler setup behind the Aimpoint or Eotech is the Backup Iron Sight option is always there as well. All 3 you mentioned have an application, choose accordingly.</div></div>

Pretty spot on. I personally love EOTech, but for your use you might need to add a magnifier or something with factory magnification.

 

[wannabullet]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

Thanks for all the in depth replies folks.

Right now I think the Aimpoint is the best choice with the ability to add magnification to it or take it off.

I really dont want a BDC on it as it is a 6.8 Upper and seems most are for .223 or .308.

I will just have to check them all out when the time comes.

 

[Maxwell]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

I will warn you that if you buy the 512 which uses the AA batteries do not store the unit with the batteries even tho the Eotech is not powered up. I did and the unit connections became discolored. When I turned it on, nothing. I was told by Eotech that the AA batteries 'leak' a gas and cause problems. To be fair it was repaired for free even tho it was out of the warranty period. Excellent customer service.

Like you, my eyes are not the best as being 61 and getting older is no fun. That said, while I have no experience with the other optics, the 512 is great at allowing my eyes to focus quickly on the target.

Maxwell

 

[TrooperBrian]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Maxwell</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I will warn you that if you buy the 512 which uses the AA batteries do not store the unit with the batteries even tho the Eotech is not powered up. I did and the unit connections became discolored. When I turned it on, nothing. I was told by Eotech that the AA batteries 'leak' a gas and cause problems. To be fair it was repaired for free even tho it was out of the warranty period. Excellent customer service.

Like you, my eyes are not the best as being 61 and getting older is no fun. That said, while I have no experience with the other optics, the 512 is great at allowing my eyes to focus quickly on the target.

Maxwell</div></div>

That is user error however, not a cause of the EOTech. All batteries are designed with small holes to vent hydrogen gas when they drop below a certain voltage level, usually 1.3V for AAs. Its so you dont open your battery box and get a face full of sulfuric acid.

If you're looking to add and remove magnification, EOTech has the same capability. Just have to try them both and decide for yourself.

 

[scotharr]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

Had an ACOG: sold it. Have an Aimpoint Comp M4s: would not consider changing it. IMHO, the ACOG is a way overpriced 4x scope. For that kind of money get a variable Leupold or Nightforce. The Aimpoint rocks for 1X mag shooting disciplines. Now I do think those 3x magnifiers for the Aimpoint and Eotech are kind of lame. You take a simple, beautiful, lightweight product and turn it into a kludgy bulky Franken-scope. Get a variable power rifle scope with a 1.5 or 2x low-end if you really need a scope. The Aimpoint is perfect as-is.

 

[MBass300]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: HD1911</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I have an Aimpoint CompM4 and love the shit out of it. I've left it turned on for over a year on the same double A battery, can't beat that. It should last for several more years too lol. Has held zero through all the rough handling and dropping. Very robust. </div></div>

+1. I just picked one up from another Hide member for a great price and I love it. I really wanted a Comp M4, but was having trouble justifying the cost, since I'm not military or LE.
I was able to come up with the asking price (very reasonable), and now that I have it, I wouldn't want to use anything else (except maybe the Acog, but most of my shooting is <100yds).
80,000 hours of batery life is insane! There is no "off". It's always on, always ready, all the time.
I mentioned to a friend of mine who is a police officer in town that I had gotten it, and had 2 other cops stop by the house last week wanting to know if they could check it out!

 

[HD1911]

Re: Eotech VS Aimpoint Comp Models and Acog

^^^^Exactly...CompM4 or ACOG for me.