Re: Field Test: SS 5-20 HD vs. Vortex Razor HD 5-20
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: boone</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Per your review I actually agreed with most of it. The only thing "we" didn't agree with was the glass. We use the same charts while comparing scopes, set at 100, 200, 300, and 400. We didn't think to write are findings down while comparing the scopes. However off the top of my head the SS, NF, and Razor all look about the same on 10x. On 20x it was a different story. The Razor and NF gave a cleaner crisper image in afternoon daylight and evening lowlight. At 400 yards. The turrets on the SS are truly badass, positive and very audible. While most people will say the Razor lacks in this being a 5 mil per turn scope I find myself on the otherside prefering 5 mil turn scopes. I tend to over shoot or under shoot my dope. That's just me not a dig at any 10 mil rev scope. On S&B scopes with 13 mil revs I really have to pay attention.
While I believe the SS is a good scope for $1500 I can not say it stacked up across the board to compare to the $2000+ scopes. This past weekend we compared the NF, Razor, and S&B without a doubt the S&B won hands down. the NF we used was 3 weeks old. Let me say NF uped their game in the glass department again. The Razor was the weak link in this comparison.
Soon we will have a HDMR to throw in the mix with the Razor, S&B, and NF. I'm very excited about the HDMR. It will be judged in the same manner. I actually wished I would have kept one of the SS to compare against the HDMR.
</div></div>
I haven't been able to get behind a SS 5-20 yet but while you guys are talking about tactical scopes I thought I'd throw in my .02 in case optics designers are watching this thread and looking for more suggestions.
For close to their current price....
Take a Vortex Razor, upgrade the glass "a little", design a lower profile wide-ish 10 mil elevation knob system retaining their proprietary ZS "IMO best in the scope world" retain the illume system although I'd rather it be else ware and have 10Y parallax. This would make it really fantastic and versatile Gen 2 Razor.
Nightforce, create a F1 5.5-22 version staying in the F1 price range, widen the elevation HS knob, modernize the illume system and rework the parallax for 10Y. Include option for H-59 reticle. I don't especially care for the whole ocular turning but really only with wearing BC caps is it a pain. I'm well aware that NF is coming out with their new "monster" but 2 things are a issue for me, price and weight.
My HDMR's are great scopes for the money and showing no or little CA, I haven't noticed any and the glass is better than the 2 IOR's I've owned. They could use some more features but the price would probably go up.
Another feature I'd like to see happen, although this might be impossible, is to have the parallax separate from the focus. Seems like half the time the 2 are not in sinc.
If we could all afford $3000+ scopes on all our rifles life would be peachy, wouldn't it?