Force gauge almost maxing out.

Halfnutz

Halfnutz

Sergeant
Full Member
Minuteman
Supporter
    • Jan 14, 2008
    1,980
    2,007
    Peoria County, Illinois
    #1
    Not sure what's causing this.

    I just started annealing with an Annealeez and using 750 tempilaq inside the case neck to set the timing.
    Removed the expander from Hornady Custom Grade 6.5 CM dies, so I am only sizing the neck down and bumping the shoulder. Then run them over a 21st Century Mandrel die (tin coated).
    Checked the necks with a .262 pin and the pin is stopping at the shoulder and case neck junction. A .261pin drops straight through. .263 pin is snug and takes a bit of pressure to start.
    Tried seating a few bullets and they start at about 30-40lbs on the gage. Then it takes all they way up to 150+ to seat all the way.
    Trimmed case length is 1.910.
    140gr Bullet length is 1.340
    COAL is 2.820.
    I have the boat tail past the neck slightly.
    Tried this on both Hornady and Nosler brass. With and without powder and am having the same issue.

    I haven't found a bushing die for 6.5CM in stock.
     

    Attachments

    • 16225876809331860859437375649182.jpg
      16225876809331860859437375649182.jpg
      325.3 KB · Views: 70
    #5
    918v said:
    When u anneal an oxide forms on the neck and interferes with bullet seating. You have to use dry lube on the inside of the neck to return to normal seating pressure.
    Click to expand...

    Tried that too. No love with imperial dry neck lube.

    The inner donut is there for sure. I can push the .262 pin through but it takes some extra pressure.
     
    #9
    No no no

    You don’t use a q-tip for this. You can use the ceramic media or dunk the neck in the graphite and tap the neck on a hard surface to get the excess out. Then you run the mandrel through, then back into the graphite before seating the bullet.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Holliday and Halfnutz
    #15
    AllenOne1 said:
    What size mandrel are you pushing through the neck? I have been assuming it is a .262
    Click to expand...

    I can honestly say I have not measured it. But I will.
    I bought the only 6.5 tin coated that 21st Century sells. I didn't know what to expect for spring back so I didn't get into the custom sizes to start.

    I just received a Sinclair for .30 cal but haven't tried it yet. I haven't ordered a seater for .308 (.308 or 300WM) yet. I wanted to see how this first 6.5 went.
     
    #20
    Halfnutz said:
    Not sure what's causing this.

    I just started annealing with an Annealeez and using 750 tempilaq inside the case neck to set the timing.
    Removed the expander from Hornady Custom Grade 6.5 CM dies, so I am only sizing the neck down and bumping the shoulder. Then run them over a 21st Century Mandrel die (tin coated).
    Checked the necks with a .262 pin and the pin is stopping at the shoulder and case neck junction. A .261pin drops straight through. .263 pin is snug and takes a bit of pressure to start.
    Tried seating a few bullets and they start at about 30-40lbs on the gage. Then it takes all they way up to 150+ to seat all the way.
    Trimmed case length is 1.910.
    140gr Bullet length is 1.340
    COAL is 2.820.
    I have the boat tail past the neck slightly.
    Tried this on both Hornady and Nosler brass. With and without powder and am having the same issue.

    I haven't found a bushing die for 6.5CM in stock.
    Click to expand...
    Your bullet is hitting the doughnut at the shoulder junction causing the heavy seating.
    Try a little test, push the mandrel in and out of the neck 3 or 4 times to iron out the doughnut then try seating the bullet.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Holliday and Halfnutz
    #21
    You say you can't find a bushing die (look at Whidden's site). I think you are sizing the neck down too far and then expecting the mandrel to force it back out to the correct size. In my opinion a mandrel can only open you back up a couple of thousands without having issues. Try it with the original sizing ball in it and see what happens. You could also size it with the die, anneal it again and then use the mandrel to finish size it. I think you need to find a bushing die or have your standard die honed out so that you are not sizing down so far.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Halfnutz
    #22
    Halfnutz said:
    .262-.2625, with calipers.
    Click to expand...
    And what’s your outside sized vs loaded neck diameter?

    I think more lube during the mandrel process would be warranted almost always. I purposefully stand them up and spray lube in the necks from four directions before spraying the sides and shaking and then sizing and expanding. It just works better for everything.


    And since then I’ve only had issues with the oxide residue crap. Have you run a brush through the case necks? It made a world of difference for me. Just a cheap nylon brush before seating makes it smoother and easier.

    Very well could be a donut if your pin gauges are catching die to that and not plains thickness inconsistencies.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Halfnutz
    #24
    spife7980 said:
    And what’s your outside sized vs loaded neck diameter?

    I think more lube during the mandrel process would be warranted almost always. I purposefully stand them up and spray lube in the necks from four directions before spraying the sides and shaking and then sizing and expanding. It just works better for everything.


    And since then I’ve only had issues with the oxide residue crap. Have you run a brush through the case necks? It made a world of difference for me. Just a cheap nylon brush before seating makes it smoother and easier.

    Very well could be a donut if your pin gauges are catching die to that and not plains thickness inconsistencies.
    Click to expand...
    I suspect he is collapsing the neck shoulder area slight when he is using the mandrel. More lube and brushing is good advise.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Halfnutz
    #26
    Thanks for all the input.

    I have ran a brush through.
    I have dry lubed before the mandrel and before seating.

    Via the pin gage there is an obvious internal donut and it shows when seating.

    I will start looking for a bushing die so as to not oversize the neck down when bumping the shoulder. The Hornady takes it well under. Probably not conducive to brass life either.

    I have 2 6.5CM rifles, the one I'm loading for now is a Nucleus, the other an AR platform. Looks like the Hornady dies will be dedicated to the AR and a seperate set for the Nuke. My goal here was to minimize ES that I have been seeing with the Nucleus loads.
    One thing I haven't tried yet is using the Hornady size die with the expander post annealing.

    Bushing dies have been out of stock everytime I think to look.
     
    #29
    When I began using the honed die and mandrel method, my results were great. However, I am beginning to see the internal donut more and more with brass sized this way. I plan to do a couple of control groups of once fired brass using the honed die with expander ball installed and with and without using the mandrel after.

    A friend of mine has experienced the same and has since went back to just using the standard expander ball, skipping the mandrel, and his neck size/seat forces are very consistent now. He believes the donut problem has resolved as well. Just my .03.
     
    Last edited:
    • Like
    Reactions: Halfnutz
    #30
    flyright said:
    When I began using the honed die and mandrel method, my results were great. However, I am beginning to see the internal donut more and more with brass sized this way. I plan to do a couple of control groups of once fired brass using the honed die with expander ball installed and with and without using the mandrel after.

    A friend of mine has experienced the same and has since went back to just using the standard expander ball, skipping the mandrel, and his neck size/seat forces are very consistent now. He believes the donut problem has resolved as well. Just my .03.
    Click to expand...

    Could it be that the expander ball in conjunction with an oversized neck irons out the donut?

    I never get donuts but I use my Lee collet neck die and maybe it squishes them out before they have a chance to form.
     
    #31
    flyright said:
    When I began using the honed die and mandrel method, my results were great. However, I am beginning to see the internal donut more and more with brass sized this way. I plan to do a couple of control groups of once fired brass using the honed die with expander ball installed and with and without using the mandrel after.

    A friend of mine has experienced the same and has since went back to just using the standard expander ball, skipping the mandrel, and his neck size/seat forces are very consistent now. He believes the donut problem has resolved as well. Just my .03.
    Click to expand...

    See post 42

    www.snipershide.com

    Internal Donut on new brass?

    I have some new ADG 6.5 PRC brass that has a slight internal donut or raised rim at the bottom of the neck. These were prepped with a turning mandrel, trimmed/chamfered and lubed with HbN prior to loading. Loads fine until the 156gr EOL hits that donut. Anyone run into this? Possible...
    www.snipershide.com www.snipershide.com
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Halfnutz
    #32
    whatsupdoc said:
    See post 42

    www.snipershide.com

    Internal Donut on new brass?

    I have some new ADG 6.5 PRC brass that has a slight internal donut or raised rim at the bottom of the neck. These were prepped with a turning mandrel, trimmed/chamfered and lubed with HbN prior to loading. Loads fine until the 156gr EOL hits that donut. Anyone run into this? Possible...
    www.snipershide.com www.snipershide.com
    Click to expand...

    Thanks for that link. I had read most of that thread when it was first started and thought it applied to my situation but hadn't taken the time to find it again yet.
     
    #35
    Steel head said:
    🍩

    A tight spot at the neck shoulder junction isn’t normal,
    It’s a donut.
    Click to expand...

    Not necessarily. If you invest in sensitive bullet seating equipment you will realize that bullet seating pressure is not uniform from start to finish. It always increases as the bullet shank penetrates the neck/shoulder junction.
     
    #36
    918v said:
    No no no

    You don’t use a q-tip for this. You can use the ceramic media or dunk the neck in the graphite and tap the neck on a hard surface to get the excess out. Then you run the mandrel through, then back into the graphite before seating the bullet.
    Click to expand...
    You might also want to check the neck wall thickness for consistency. Remember brass flows forward and may produce inconsistent thickness
     
    #37

    This is a pretty cheap investment and I like mine about as well as my Gradient Lens borescope. It may or may not help see the issue inside the neck, but it's also a good excuse to have one for bore inspection and other needs for visualization inside tight spots. Handy for verifying actual AR15 gas block hole alignment, etc. (disclaimer: I'm not associated with Teslong in any way)
     
    #40
    Halfnutz said:
    Update. My Redding type S die and .290 bushing showed up and made a huge difference. I am no longer getting the constriction at the base of the neck and seating force extremes are now 40 to 55 lbs on the ones I have tested.
    Click to expand...
    Dies make a difference, I went through 3 sizing dies before I got one that sized everything correctly for my chamber. Glad you're able to move forward now and feel good about what is happening.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Halfnutz
    You must log in or register to reply here.

    Similar threads

    Basic user
    Almost no neck tension on new brass?
    Replies
    23
    Views
    982
    Basic user
    Basic user
    T
    Question on components per application
    Replies
    7
    Views
    302
    straightshooter1
    straightshooter1
    L
    30-06 COAL and CBTO with 178 ELDX
    Replies
    12
    Views
    257
    LambChoppa
    L
    scc0005
    Reloading Equipment Clean out, 6.5x47, 260, TL3 Barrel
    Replies
    9
    Views
    748
    scc0005
    scc0005
    F
    Rough "single stage" bullet seating on 6.5 Creedmoor (with Arbor Press and force gauge)
    Replies
    7
    Views
    424
    FrenchPewPiou
    F
    Top Bottom
    Back
    Home
    Forums
    Merch
    Alerts