-
Having trouble using the site?
Contact support
Sidearms & Scatterguns If you could only have one...
- Thread starter warpig602
- Start date
Re: If you could only have one...
I would have to say my One and only gun would be G22. It just fits pretty much anything from large game to small critters, and also does a hell of a job on the worst our country has to offer.
I would have to say my One and only gun would be G22. It just fits pretty much anything from large game to small critters, and also does a hell of a job on the worst our country has to offer.
Re: If you could only have one...
It would be a 1911 the tough choice for me would be...
my 10mm or Coonan .357mag 1911
the Coonan can shoot a wide range of ammo but the 10mm is great to!
It would be a 1911 the tough choice for me would be...
my 10mm or Coonan .357mag 1911
the Coonan can shoot a wide range of ammo but the 10mm is great to!
Re: If you could only have one...
4" 627 Smith if it was truly an only one sort of situation with low to no likelihood of maintenance. If I thought I would have the ability to do any sort of maintenance on the gun, it would be my carry 1911.
If we are talking the much fabled "zombie-pocalypse" or end of the world or whatever story you like to tell yourself, easly the 627. Low required maintenance, stainless, no magazines to lose, maintain, or fail, tons of ammo rolling around in floorboards throughout the U.S., and a gun that lends itself to being shot very well.
If I knew I could get mags and do maintenance, my 5" carry 1911. Just broke the 15k mark on it and no problems I cant attribute to ammo, shooter, or a bad couple of mags I had early on. It isn't pretty (anymore), but man does it shoot.
4" 627 Smith if it was truly an only one sort of situation with low to no likelihood of maintenance. If I thought I would have the ability to do any sort of maintenance on the gun, it would be my carry 1911.
If we are talking the much fabled "zombie-pocalypse" or end of the world or whatever story you like to tell yourself, easly the 627. Low required maintenance, stainless, no magazines to lose, maintain, or fail, tons of ammo rolling around in floorboards throughout the U.S., and a gun that lends itself to being shot very well.
If I knew I could get mags and do maintenance, my 5" carry 1911. Just broke the 15k mark on it and no problems I cant attribute to ammo, shooter, or a bad couple of mags I had early on. It isn't pretty (anymore), but man does it shoot.
Re: If you could only have one...
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Force_Multiplier</div><div class="ubbcode-body">if I could only have one...
suppressed Ruger 22/45 </div></div>
You have chosen wisely my son.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Force_Multiplier</div><div class="ubbcode-body">if I could only have one...
suppressed Ruger 22/45 </div></div>
You have chosen wisely my son.
Re: If you could only have one...
Pistol would be by Wilson in 10mm. I prefer .45 for everyday but 10 would be nice for larger critters.
Pistol would be by Wilson in 10mm. I prefer .45 for everyday but 10 would be nice for larger critters.
Re: If you could only have one...
In the real world it often comes down to what is available. Oddly enough, I have been in that situation a few times: Once it was a Glock 17 with subgun ammo; the other time it was a 1911 in .45ACP with 230gr ball. I would be happy with either one, and was happy with both.
In the real world it often comes down to what is available. Oddly enough, I have been in that situation a few times: Once it was a Glock 17 with subgun ammo; the other time it was a 1911 in .45ACP with 230gr ball. I would be happy with either one, and was happy with both.
Re: If you could only have one...
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Graham</div><div class="ubbcode-body">In the real world it often comes down to what is available. Oddly enough, I have been in that situation a few times: Once it was a Glock 17 with subgun ammo; the other time it was a 1911 in .45ACP with 230gr ball. I would be happy with either one, and was happy with both. </div></div>
I am afraid of you Graham
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Graham</div><div class="ubbcode-body">In the real world it often comes down to what is available. Oddly enough, I have been in that situation a few times: Once it was a Glock 17 with subgun ammo; the other time it was a 1911 in .45ACP with 230gr ball. I would be happy with either one, and was happy with both. </div></div>
I am afraid of you Graham
Re: If you could only have one...
I asked myself this question a while back, and as much as I like my G17, a combination of factors led me to decide on one of these beauties as my one-choice side arm:
Puts a smile on my face everytime I pull the trigger...
I asked myself this question a while back, and as much as I like my G17, a combination of factors led me to decide on one of these beauties as my one-choice side arm:
Puts a smile on my face everytime I pull the trigger...
Re: If you could only have one...
i would agree with you as a survival gun but as a defense gun i would prefer a heavier caliber...
i would agree with you as a survival gun but as a defense gun i would prefer a heavier caliber...
Re: If you could only have one...
depends on what fits your hand. I didnt do well with Glocks but shoot well with a M&P 4" 45. Self defense...45. Also has an options ambi safety if you have kids etc.
http://www.smith-wesson.com/webapp/wcs/s...81_757781_image
depends on what fits your hand. I didnt do well with Glocks but shoot well with a M&P 4" 45. Self defense...45. Also has an options ambi safety if you have kids etc.
http://www.smith-wesson.com/webapp/wcs/s...81_757781_image
Re: If you could only have one...
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: skep_tic1</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I am afraid of you Graham </div></div>LOL!
Don't be: If people were afraid of me I wouldn't need a gun to protect myself.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: skep_tic1</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I am afraid of you Graham </div></div>LOL!
Don't be: If people were afraid of me I wouldn't need a gun to protect myself.
Re: If you could only have one...
Only one?? How sad.
It would have to be my 1911, assuming we are only talking about sidearm options.
Only one?? How sad.
It would have to be my 1911, assuming we are only talking about sidearm options.
Re: If you could only have one...
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: lash</div><div class="ubbcode-body">assuming we are only talking about sidearm options. </div></div>Good point, because if at all possible I would choose to have a rifle.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: lash</div><div class="ubbcode-body">assuming we are only talking about sidearm options. </div></div>Good point, because if at all possible I would choose to have a rifle.
Re: If you could only have one...
Glock 30...
Plenty of .45 ACP ammo up for grabs after the 1911 fanboys (and old farts) get popped!
lol
Glock 30...
Plenty of .45 ACP ammo up for grabs after the 1911 fanboys (and old farts) get popped!
lol
Re: If you could only have one...
If I could only have one sidearm as my do-all, it would have to be my Glock model 34.
If I could only have one sidearm as my do-all, it would have to be my Glock model 34.
Re: If you could only have one...
Tough call between my Sig229 .40 and my G19 but the G19 wins for me
Tough call between my Sig229 .40 and my G19 but the G19 wins for me
Re: If you could only have one...
WOW! 1911s, Sigs, S&Ws, Glocks, but No SF XD/XDms with 19+1 9mm!?!? It's like having a MP5 as a Sidearm!
WOW! 1911s, Sigs, S&Ws, Glocks, but No SF XD/XDms with 19+1 9mm!?!? It's like having a MP5 as a Sidearm!
Re: If you could only have one...
While I love the 1911. If only one pistol it would be a Ruger security six in .357. Why a .357? Ammo can be found everyplace and .38 Spl works in it also.
While I love the 1911. If only one pistol it would be a Ruger security six in .357. Why a .357? Ammo can be found everyplace and .38 Spl works in it also.
Re: If you could only have one...
Really like my Sig 220combat but I haven't owned as many handguns as some of you guys to really know. Its only my 3rd handgun but feels so good in my hands.
Really like my Sig 220combat but I haven't owned as many handguns as some of you guys to really know. Its only my 3rd handgun but feels so good in my hands.
Re: If you could only have one...
Noveske AR SBR
otherwise my G17 - just over 35,000 DOCUMENTED rounds thru it and still humming
Noveske AR SBR
otherwise my G17 - just over 35,000 DOCUMENTED rounds thru it and still humming
Re: If you could only have one...
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: taseal</div><div class="ubbcode-body">many will say Glock 19 I think </div></div>
Agreed. Not much in life the average person can't get done with a Glock 19.
TTR
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: taseal</div><div class="ubbcode-body">many will say Glock 19 I think </div></div>
Agreed. Not much in life the average person can't get done with a Glock 19.
TTR
Re: If you could only have one...
One pistol would be my low-end Kimber 1911. I've used this pistol since '99 for every class I've taken, every shooting event and everywhere I've had to wear some sort of sidearm. It's been shot, rained on, knocked out of my hands, sometimes cleaned, tweaked by an awesome gunsmith, half the parts have worn out/broken (on my 2nd safety and 3rd slide lock) and/or been replaced and it's been refinished twice... sunscreen + sweat on worn bluing = RUST!
No night sights, just the Jardine hook rear and stock front. No expanded mag well, no ambi-safety, no enlarged mag release, no fancy grips, no checkering. The only modern convenience I kinda long for is a rail, my Harries technique is weak.
I've even hung up my dedicated .22 and just have a .22 upper for this frame. I tried hunting with a .22 ruger single-six but it just felt so wrong to not have the 1911 along.
I'm sure if I could CCW I might dig my G23 or G27 out of storage from back when I lived in a free state, but until that day comes this is my one and only.
Yes, that is a rabbit fur gun doily. Those rabbits died for my dinner and to give my Kimber a bed. That's being green.
One pistol would be my low-end Kimber 1911. I've used this pistol since '99 for every class I've taken, every shooting event and everywhere I've had to wear some sort of sidearm. It's been shot, rained on, knocked out of my hands, sometimes cleaned, tweaked by an awesome gunsmith, half the parts have worn out/broken (on my 2nd safety and 3rd slide lock) and/or been replaced and it's been refinished twice... sunscreen + sweat on worn bluing = RUST!
No night sights, just the Jardine hook rear and stock front. No expanded mag well, no ambi-safety, no enlarged mag release, no fancy grips, no checkering. The only modern convenience I kinda long for is a rail, my Harries technique is weak.
I've even hung up my dedicated .22 and just have a .22 upper for this frame. I tried hunting with a .22 ruger single-six but it just felt so wrong to not have the 1911 along.
I'm sure if I could CCW I might dig my G23 or G27 out of storage from back when I lived in a free state, but until that day comes this is my one and only.
Yes, that is a rabbit fur gun doily. Those rabbits died for my dinner and to give my Kimber a bed. That's being green.
Re: If you could only have one...
Kind of hard to beat the trusty Ruger GP100 as a utility sidearm.
-Versatile; a load can be found to get the job done from cheap, low recoil plinking and small game to hunting larger game effectively, or middle-weight bullets pushed fast can be used with good effect in self-defense or combat applications.
-Powerful enough for most threats though not ideal for larger game species.
-Easy to shoot well (post-trigger job).
-Reliability and durability second to none.
-High likelihood of ammo availability.
-Ammo cost less than many other chamberings.
G19 would be my other choice and is arguably a superior combat weapon than GP100 due to:
-Increased capacity
-Reduced reload speed.
-Superior ease of carry and concealment.
-Ammo availability is just as likely as with any other cartridge.
-Ammo cost less than many others.
Just my thoughts after a couple years of hunting with/carrying a GP100 extensively and a G19 to a lesser degree. I'm approaching this from the perspective of a potential survival SHTF scenario, but I don't know that this was necessarily the OP's intent.
Good thread.
Kind of hard to beat the trusty Ruger GP100 as a utility sidearm.
-Versatile; a load can be found to get the job done from cheap, low recoil plinking and small game to hunting larger game effectively, or middle-weight bullets pushed fast can be used with good effect in self-defense or combat applications.
-Powerful enough for most threats though not ideal for larger game species.
-Easy to shoot well (post-trigger job).
-Reliability and durability second to none.
-High likelihood of ammo availability.
-Ammo cost less than many other chamberings.
G19 would be my other choice and is arguably a superior combat weapon than GP100 due to:
-Increased capacity
-Reduced reload speed.
-Superior ease of carry and concealment.
-Ammo availability is just as likely as with any other cartridge.
-Ammo cost less than many others.
Just my thoughts after a couple years of hunting with/carrying a GP100 extensively and a G19 to a lesser degree. I'm approaching this from the perspective of a potential survival SHTF scenario, but I don't know that this was necessarily the OP's intent.
Good thread.
Re: If you could only have one...
My G21 SF with robar package, surefire x300 and AAC ti-rant 45, oh yeah, xs big dots too.
My G21 SF with robar package, surefire x300 and AAC ti-rant 45, oh yeah, xs big dots too.
Re: If you could only have one...
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Jayne</div><div class="ubbcode-body">
One pistol would be my low-end Kimber 1911. I've used this pistol since '99 for every class I've taken, every shooting event and everywhere I've had to wear some sort of sidearm. It's been shot, rained on, knocked out of my hands, sometimes cleaned, tweaked by an awesome gunsmith, half the parts have worn out/broken (on my 2nd safety and 3rd slide lock) and/or been replaced and it's been refinished twice... sunscreen + sweat on worn bluing = RUST!
No night sights, just the Jardine hook rear and stock front. No expanded mag well, no ambi-safety, no enlarged mag release, no fancy grips, no checkering. The only modern convenience I kinda long for is a rail, my Harries technique is weak.
I've even hung up my dedicated .22 and just have a .22 upper for this frame. I tried hunting with a .22 ruger single-six but it just felt so wrong to not have the 1911 along.
I'm sure if I could CCW I might dig my G23 or G27 out of storage from back when I lived in a free state, but until that day comes this is my one and only.
Yes, that is a rabbit fur gun doily. Those rabbits died for my dinner and to give my Kimber a bed. That's being green.
</div></div>
Enough Said! That is a sweet Gun/Companion!!!
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Jayne</div><div class="ubbcode-body">
One pistol would be my low-end Kimber 1911. I've used this pistol since '99 for every class I've taken, every shooting event and everywhere I've had to wear some sort of sidearm. It's been shot, rained on, knocked out of my hands, sometimes cleaned, tweaked by an awesome gunsmith, half the parts have worn out/broken (on my 2nd safety and 3rd slide lock) and/or been replaced and it's been refinished twice... sunscreen + sweat on worn bluing = RUST!
No night sights, just the Jardine hook rear and stock front. No expanded mag well, no ambi-safety, no enlarged mag release, no fancy grips, no checkering. The only modern convenience I kinda long for is a rail, my Harries technique is weak.
I've even hung up my dedicated .22 and just have a .22 upper for this frame. I tried hunting with a .22 ruger single-six but it just felt so wrong to not have the 1911 along.
I'm sure if I could CCW I might dig my G23 or G27 out of storage from back when I lived in a free state, but until that day comes this is my one and only.
Yes, that is a rabbit fur gun doily. Those rabbits died for my dinner and to give my Kimber a bed. That's being green.
</div></div>
Enough Said! That is a sweet Gun/Companion!!!
Re: If you could only have one...
Another Glock 19 (RTF2!!!!) followed closely by the 22
Rifle: my '43 Inland M1 Carbine. If it gets sold, it means I've shuffled off this mortal coil lol
Another Glock 19 (RTF2!!!!) followed closely by the 22
Rifle: my '43 Inland M1 Carbine. If it gets sold, it means I've shuffled off this mortal coil lol
