Re: LE Sniper Rifle - Department Use
Since I was "called out" by Graham,
"Would you care to substantively answer any one question directed your way by any of us, without changing the subject or posting generalities?"
here you go, the "Cliff Notes" summary:
Post 1 – in response to the OP
“I am not going to really get into the “Bolt Gun vs. Gas Gun” debate primarily because I don’t think that there really is one. They both have their Pros & Cons, and IMHO they both can serve as needed as a LE Sniper Rifle.”
- I CLEARLY state that both platforms are acceptable and have their place.
- I then proceed to provide recommendations / specifications for a gas gun as requested by the OP.
*That would be an on topic, FACTUAL response
Post 2 – I respond to Graham’s Post of “Defend the choice of rifle how? From what?”
- I responded with the FACTUAL information that I have acquired from classes, briefings, and articles provided by agencies such as ASA, NTOA, and IACP.
*That would be a DIRECT RESPONSE, as factual as I can make it, based on my knowledge of the subject, but I don’t pretend to be a Lawyer, I just pull triggers.
Post 3 – in response to a number of posts questioning the validity of a gas gun as a LE Sniper Rifle
- I provided a FACTUAL summary of gas gun performance in the recent Urban Sniper Class that I assisted with.
- I provided a summary of Tom Beckstrand’s take on gas gun performance at 2 top tier sniper competions. If you don’t think that is FACTUAL, sorry take it up with Tom.
- I provided a FACTUAL summary of the USASOC Sniper Comp participants and rifles used.
*Take it all as a sales pitch for gas guns if you want, but I was simply posting FACTS that document a gas gun’s capabilities.
Post 4 – in response to KraigWY’s Post of: "To the OP, I'd recommend finding a copy of the USAMU Counter Sniper's guide, high lite the rifle section and drop it on your boss's desk.”
- I highlighted the fact that it was a 30 year old manual, the majority of it contained outdated material, and there were better / more recent documents available.
- Quoting me: “Not saying that some of it is still not applicable, but the majority of it, especially anything that has to do with equipment selection is way out of date.
*NOTE – I did NOT say that it was COMPLETELY void of usable information, which I was repeatedly accused of doing in later posts.
Post 5 – in response to numerous posts on various topics
- In response to KraigWY’s Post on the AMU Manual again, I recommended that more current information from AMU and other nationally recognized LE Sniper resources should be utilized instead of a 30 year old manual.
- In response to Graham’s post of “There's nothing wrong with .308 AR's (except that, as of this writing, the .308 semi AR platform has not yet been perfected in either its design or its manufacture)”, I basically lost my freaking mind, and responded that maybe he could tell all of the significantly successful manufacturers and competitors that they were building or using a rifle that had not been perfected in its design or manufacturer.
Post 6 – responded to Phylodog’s post of “You have yet to point out why police agencies on limited budgets NEED a fucking gas gun.”
- Go back to my Post #1, where I once again stated “They both have their Pros & Cons, and IMHO they both can serve as needed as a LE Sniper Rifle.”
- Also reiterated that point in my response
Post 7 – responded in general to the posts questioning the need for LE Snipers to employ a gas gun with multi-shot quick follow up capability.
- Provided FACTUAL historical cases where “numerous bad guys” were carrying out terrorist or criminal acts which would in turn require the responding agencies to address multiple threats as quickly as possible.
Post 8 – having lost my mind, responded to Graham
- Admittedly nothing of value here!
So out of 8 posts:
- I provided the OP with recommendations on a gas gun, something he asked for.
- I provided FACTUAL information on the performance of gas guns, based on my own personal perspective, and the perspective of some Tier 1 Operators.
- I provided a reference to current and nationally recognized LE Sniper TTD.
- I provided FACTUAL historical perspectives for the justification of a LE sniper rifle with multi-shot quick follow up capability.
I am good with that track record of RESPONDING with FACTUAL information, obviously some of you are not, oh well enjoy your "facts" as you like to see them!
Best of Luck,
M Richardson