• Frank's Lesson's Contest

    We want to see your skills! Post a video between now and November 1st showing what you've learned from Frank's lessons and 3 people will be selected to win a free shirt. Good luck everyone!

    Create a channel Learn more
  • Having trouble using the site?

    Contact support

Maggie’s Motivational Pic Thread v2.0 - - New Rules - See Post #1

1730181331687.png
 
I just read a little bit about it. I didn't see anything to indicate that they intentionally beached it. They threw out a second anchor and it didn't do any good. There were about 50 ships anchored in the area when the storm advisory was issued. All but nine of the ships pulled anchor and beat cheeks out of the storm's path. This ship was one of the nine that didn't heed the advisory.

They were empty and had almost zero ballast. As a result, it was riding very high in the water. There was significant prop and rudder surface area out of the water, so they had very little effective propulsion or steering.
That is 100% on the person who made the decision to try and ride out the storm on the hook (anchor). My last cutter was 82’ long and displaced 60 tons and under normal conditions an 80 pound Danforth type anchor held us in place just fine. Six months after I joined the DD-214 club a hurricane was headed for St Thomas when both engines were offline waiting for parts to arrive from the US so the group commander told the CO to tie off to a mooring ball in the harbor that was held in place by a 6000 pound concrete anchor. This is a newspaper photo of that 60 tons of steel and how well the 6000 pound anchor held it in place.
1730215393888.jpeg

The whole crew was onboard at the time and they could have all died because the group commander lacked an understanding of the forces involved when the ocean is in a mood.

On a semi related note the USCG in their infinite wisdom paid a marine salvage company to bring in a barge crane and put the cutter on a barge and tow the barge to New Orleans to a shipyard who rebuilt the hull. After the hull was rebuilt the USCG decommissioned it and towed it up to Ocean City MD and sunk it to be an artificial reef. The Whitehorn was slated for decommissioning BEFORE the hurricane… 🙄
 
That is 100% on the person who made the decision to try and ride out the storm on the hook (anchor). My last cutter was 82’ long and displaced 60 tons and under normal conditions an 80 pound Danforth type anchor held us in place just fine. Six months after I joined the DD-214 club a hurricane was headed for St Thomas when both engines were offline waiting for parts to arrive from the US so the group commander told the CO to tie off to a mooring ball in the harbor that was held in place by a 6000 pound concrete anchor. This is a newspaper photo of that 60 tons of steel and how well the 6000 pound anchor held it in place.
View attachment 8534408
The whole crew was onboard at the time and they could have all died because the group commander lacked an understanding of the forces involved when the ocean is in a mood.

On a semi related note the USCG in their infinite wisdom paid a marine salvage company to bring in a barge crane and put the cutter on a barge and tow the barge to New Orleans to a shipyard who rebuilt the hull. After the hull was rebuilt the USCG decommissioned it and towed it up to Ocean City MD and sunk it to be an artificial reef. The Whitehorn was slated for decommissioning BEFORE the hurricane… 🙄
It’s a good thing they put a mooring line on the pier so the cutter didn’t go anywhere.
1730215808333.png
 
That is 100% on the person who made the decision to try and ride out the storm on the hook (anchor). My last cutter was 82’ long and displaced 60 tons and under normal conditions an 80 pound Danforth type anchor held us in place just fine. Six months after I joined the DD-214 club a hurricane was headed for St Thomas when both engines were offline waiting for parts to arrive from the US so the group commander told the CO to tie off to a mooring ball in the harbor that was held in place by a 6000 pound concrete anchor. This is a newspaper photo of that 60 tons of steel and how well the 6000 pound anchor held it in place.
View attachment 8534408
The whole crew was onboard at the time and they could have all died because the group commander lacked an understanding of the forces involved when the ocean is in a mood.

On a semi related note the USCG in their infinite wisdom paid a marine salvage company to bring in a barge crane and put the cutter on a barge and tow the barge to New Orleans to a shipyard who rebuilt the hull. After the hull was rebuilt the USCG decommissioned it and towed it up to Ocean City MD and sunk it to be an artificial reef. The Whitehorn was slated for decommissioning BEFORE the hurricane… 🙄
I think this is the article that I read. I may have gotten it wrong about them having dropped the second anchor, but that's what I thought I read.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Barneybdb and lash