Reviewers needed: BC and Gyroscopic Stability

Michael Courtney

Sergeant
Full Member
Minuteman
May 25, 2012
102
0
57
www.btgresearch.org
Reviewers needed: Aerodynamic Drag and Gyroscopic Stability

Please send an email to [email protected] if you'd like to review the full paper.

Abstract: This paper describes the effects on aerodynamic drag on rifle bullets as the gyroscopic stability is lowered from 1.3 to 1.0. It is well known that the bullet can tumble for stability less than 1.0. The Sierra Loading Manuals (4th and 5th Editions) have previously reported that ballistic coefficient decreases significantly as gyroscopic stability, Sg, is lowered below 1.3. These observations are further confirmed by the experiments reported here by comparing measured ballistic coefficients with gyroscopic stabilities computed with the Miller Twist Rule for nearly solid metal bullets with uniform density and computed with the Courtney-Miller formula for plastic-tipped bullets. The experiments reported here also demonstrate a decrease in aerodynamic drag near Sg = 1.23 ± 0.02. It is hypothesized that this decrease in drag over a narrow band of Sg values is due to a rapid damping of coning motions (precession and nutation). Observation of this drag decrease at a consistent value of Sg demonstrates the relative accuracy of the twist formulas used to compute Sg. It may be used to test the applicability of existing twist formulas to given bullet designs and to evaluate the accuracy of alternate formulas in cases where the existing twist formulas are not as accurate.
 
Re: Reviewers needed: BC and Gyroscopic Stability

I feel smarter just having read OP's post.I don't know what it means though. Kinda like going to a compny christmas party where I work the dock but the CEO's have to be in the same room.:)
 
Re: Reviewers needed: BC and Gyroscopic Stability

The Litz book gives a great explanation of stability and the Miller formula, as well as many other important topics in exterior ballistics. It is highly recommended.

But with all technical issues, there are subtleties that can't be fully explored in the space available in a book offering a broad topic coverage. The Litz book and the Sierra manuals give excellent introductory treatments, and even begin to hint at many of the more subtle questions. However, we've explored things very carefully and never seen a case where a bullet tumbles with Sg > 1.05 as predicted by the applicable Miller twist formula.

The risk of shooting bullets with Sg < 1.3 is reduced BC (increased air drag). Suggestions that Sg needs to be >= 1.4 seem to be just building in a bit more margin for error regarding bullet dimensions, actual barrel twist, and environmental conditions.