What you state above is an excellent example of low resolution thinking/reasoning. The problem at hand is more complex that the simple analogies you bring forward.
Please read
this summary and ask yourself whether it does the issue more justice.
Whether and when it makes sense to get vaccinated or not and whether and when it makes sense to wear a mask or not depends on specific and personal circumstances and should be a personal choice. There is no single 'right' or 'wrong' answer that applies to all people and situations.
Most people in our society are either incapable or unwilling to deal with complexity. They want a simple, comfortable life. They want to feel good - contradictory facts and unresolved questions be dammed. Our 'representatives' know this and they sell 'easy fixes' for complicated issues, which will always create more problems than it solves. This cycle is the real problem, whether you look at Covid-19, environmental issues, the economy, racial issues, etc.