A 16" 6.5 with appropriate ammunition out-performs 20" .308 with 175gr SMK in drop and wind deflection. But what really matters is that the gun is smaller and lighter.
There are at least 5 other companies with compliant models, and we all fully expect this to go to full and open competition.
Of the competitive tenders that I have participated in for the USSS, they are among the best for fairness and adherence to requirements. No, I haven't won every opportunity, and the ones I was not successful with I do believe that they got what matched their needs the best. The world of government procurement is strange for those that don't work in it, so I understand the suspicion and "feels" associated with it, but ultimately it comes down to hitting threshold and objective requirements, and all else being equal, showing a greater value over the life of the contract. We aren't building spaceships or bridges, so "going over budget" isn't something that applies.